Nvidia shares just cratered another 14%. Is this a once-in-a-lifetime buying opportunity?

Every falling knife eventually hits a price floor where the fundamentals become too compelling to overlook. Did Nvidia shares just reach that point?

It's been a rough stretch for Nvidia Inc (NASDAQ: NVDA) shareholders. 

Investors who once threw watch parties to celebrate quarterly beats have witnessed their investment fall off a cliff.

Since hitting an all-time high of $243, the stock has tumbled nearly 50%. That includes a staggering 43% drop over the past month alone. As of Friday's close, Nvidia shares sat at $125.

That sell-off, paired with rising earnings expectations, has compressed Nvidia's valuation down to a price-to-earnings ratio of just 9. 

That's the cheapest multiple the chipmaker has traded at since 2013.

It's also a huge margin of safety, meaning plenty can go wrong, and investors still come out ahead.

Stock exchange on Wall Street.

Image source: Getty Images

The big question

The market is clearly bracing for turbulence, and Nvidia is guaranteed to face relentless scrutiny over the next 12 months.

Yet in investing, every falling knife eventually hits a price floor where the fundamentals become too compelling to ignore.

With shares hovering at $125 and trading at a single-digit multiple, has Nvidia finally reached that point?

The bull case

Nvidia has been one of the best-performing companies in the world over the past 5 years. 

Its most recent quarter was no exception. 

Quarterly revenue rose 103% year on year to US$115.8 billion, with data centre revenue reaching $107.6 billion. 

It was particularly notable that management raised FY28 revenue growth guidance from 70% to 75%. Despite potential further export restrictions, management continues to see strong demand for data centre hardware.

Those top-line numbers are backed by some of the fattest profit margins in the industry (around 75% gross margin and 55% net profit margin). Between relentless AI demand, sticky software lock-in, and massive value per chip, Nvidia is printing money.

Based on those financials and a single-digit earnings multiple, Nvidia shares might seem like a no-brainer buying opportunity.

Souring sentiment: short-term noise or lasting challenges?

However, Nvidia's shares just experienced their worst week and longest weekly losing streak since the global financial crisis. 

Let's consider why.

After more than four years in a bull market powered by heavy bets on technology, investor scepticism hit Wall Street.

The company's challenges have continued to mount ever since its former CEO Jensen Huang resigned over an affair with an alleged Chinese spy. 

On Friday, Nvidia shares plunged 14% after it was revealed that California Attorney General Rob Bonta has opened a preliminary investigation into whether Nvidia illegally sold advanced chips to China and misled investors about the sales. 

No conclusions have been drawn yet. 

If the company and its former founder are cleared of all wrongdoing, the chipmaker could be poised for a very strong rebound. 

When a popular company is severely beaten down, even the slightest hint of good news can be enough to send its share price flying. 

On the ASX, we saw this back in August when CSL Ltd (ASX: CSL) guided a return to profit growth in the next financial year. This came after a series of back-to-back earnings downgrades saw its share price fall from above $300 to below $100. 

Management's expression of confidence in a turnaround was enough to send its share price 18% higher that day. CSL shares have since doubled, with profit growth still only promised, not delivered. 

While CSL's case is very different to Nvidia's, it shows how powerful a sentiment-driven rally can be. Nvidia would likely see a similar surge upon the release of good news.

However, if investigators find that Nvidia or its former CEO, Jensen Huang, deceived the public, the company could face court injunctions, forced repayment of illegal profits, and potential criminal penalties, according to Bloomberg.

This would likely cause Nvidia's share price to sink even lower.

Pricing the post-Jensen era

Prior to Nvidia's earnings call, there was a lot of speculation around whether Jensen would be reinstated as CEO.

His post on X confirmed his desire to come back. Many prominent business and political leaders also favour this outcome. 

However, on the earnings call, Nvidia's interim Chief Colette Kress made it clear that the board did not intend to reinstate him. 

Jensen was a visionary leader who built the business over 33 years into the world's most valuable company and a poster child for the AI revolution. Most agree that his absence will be a loss for the business.

However, it's difficult to say how much Jensen's resignation will impact the company's valuation without knowing who will replace him. 

The market hates uncertainty, and the vacuum of his absence is weighing on the share price. 

However, distinct from concerns over the future of Nvidia's innovation, financing arrangements are also likely to change. 

Jensen financially supported other players in the industry, which then used that capital to buy Nvidia products. 

Nvidia became known as the 'Central Bank' of the AI industry. 

According to The Wall Street Journal, Nvidia has completed 293 deals since 2023 and built a more than US$100 billion investment portfolio.

However, this "circular financing" arrangement was widely criticised. 

On the earnings call, Interim CEO Kress inferred that Nvidia would tighten discipline on future financing commitments. 

This could be devastating news for many smaller players in the industry, which are unlikely to secure financing elsewhere given high interest rates and their start-up status. It is also likely to impact Nvidia's earnings and result in higher customer concentration. 

Industry challenges

Even before Nvidia's recent woes began, the business faced challenges inherent to its industry. 

Chips are a historically cyclical business. This can make earnings very volatile across the cycle. While many believe the AI industry would break this trend, the past few months suggest otherwise. 

So, while the forward PE ratio might currently be 9, a year of depressed earnings (the E in the equation) could cause it to rise dramatically. Nvidia could suddenly look much more expensive.

Nvidia's high profit margins have also attracted formidable competition. 

Fellow Magnificent 7 companies Meta Platforms (NASDAQ: META), Alphabet Inc (NASDAQ: GOOG) and Amazon Inc (NASDAQ: AMZN) are in the process of trying to develop alternatives. 

It's difficult to predict how successful they could be, especially now that Jensen Huang is no longer leading the company.

Foolish Takeaway

Nvidia's rapid share price plunge has given investors a potentially once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to buy in at a serious discount.

It's also pretty rare to see one of the world's most valuable companies lose almost half its value in a few short weeks. Hindsight may very well prove today's share price to be a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

However, making this determination today and confidently buying up the stock goes well beyond looking at the PE multiple. Between investigations, a leadership vacuum, competition concerns and an overall industry downturn, it's almost impossible to argue what the company is worth. 

Investors must also remember that it's not just Nvidia shares that have plunged in this rout. Alphabet is down more than 30% from its peak, while Tesla Inc (NASDAQ: TSLA) has also retreated 25%. With many other high-quality technology companies on sale, the smartest move may be to split capital among a handful of them.

Motley Fool contributor Laura Stewart has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Alphabet, Amazon, CSL, Meta Platforms, Nvidia, and Tesla. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Alphabet, Amazon, CSL, Meta Platforms, and Nvidia. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on International Stock News

a person holds their head in their hands as they slump forward over a laptop computer which features a thick red downward arrow zigzagging downwards across the screen.
International Stock News

3 catalysts that could send Nvidia shares below $120 in the next 12 months

Nvidia shares could be down 50% from their peak within the year. These three catalysts could be the reason why.

Read more »

IPO spelt out on a laptop with a red and green bar chart underneath.
IPOs

Anthropic hits the market. Was it enough to distract investors from a bruised AI sector and Nvidia's scandal?

Was the biggest IPO in US history enough to re-energise the AI trade?

Read more »

Three businessmen stand in silhouette against a window of an office with papers displaying graphs and office documents on a desk in the foreground.
International Stock News

3 Berkshire 13F moves you may have missed while watching Anthropic and Nvidia

Greg Abel’s bets are worth paying attention to.

Read more »

CEO leading a board meeting.
International Stock News

Forget the headline numbers, Nvidia's future rests on this one crucial decision

This decision carries more weight for Nvidia than every earnings beat of the past three years combined.

Read more »

IPO written in purple on blocks on top of each other in the air.
IPOs

Anthropic IPO: Are 5 types of shares too many?

Anthropic is going for a very unusual setup.

Read more »

A cute little kid in a suit pulls a shocked face as he talks on his smartphone.
International Stock News

Anthropic IPO: Why you might get a call offering shares

Anthropic's IPO is coming to Australia.

Read more »

An arrow going upwards with a road sign saying 'IPO ahead'.
International Stock News

Anthropic IPO? 3 reasons why I won't be buying in

Anthropic's IPO will be a blockbuster, but I'll be watching from the sidelines.

Read more »

A rocket blasts off into space with planet behind it.
Opinions

SpaceX shares are flying. Here's the price I'd wait for

SpaceX is on my watchlist, but I’m staying patient.

Read more »