If I could choose only one, would I buy Telstra or Wesfarmers shares?

I like both businesses, but if I could only add one to my portfolio today, there's a clear reason behind my choice.

Telstra Group Ltd (ASX: TLS) and Wesfarmers Ltd (ASX: WES) are two ASX blue-chip shares I would happily consider owning for the long term.

Both have established market positions, recognisable brands, and a history of rewarding shareholders.

But if I could only buy one of them today, which would I choose?

For me, the decision comes down to what each company could offer investors over the coming years.

A man and woman watch their device screens, making investing decisions at home.

Image source: Getty Images

The case for Telstra shares

I think Telstra shares are a solid option for investors looking to generate income from their portfolios.

Australia's largest telecommunications company benefits from the essential nature of its services, with millions of Australians relying on its mobile and broadband networks.

Its extensive infrastructure and customer base also give it opportunities to increase earnings through modest price increases, efficiency improvements, and growing demand for connectivity.

However, I think the main attraction is its dividend. According to CommSec consensus forecasts, Telstra is expected to pay a partially franked dividend of 22 cents per share in FY27.

At the current share price of around $5.16, that represents a forward dividend yield of 4.3%.

Analysts then expect the dividend to increase slightly to 22.5 cents per share in FY28, lifting the potential yield to 4.35%.

While that's a respectable income stream, the forecast dividend (and earnings) growth is only modest. And I think Wesfarmers has stronger prospects for growing its earnings over time.

The case for Wesfarmers shares

Wesfarmers owns several leading Australian businesses, including Bunnings, Kmart, Officeworks, and Priceline Pharmacy.

I like the diversity of its operations and the opportunities it has to grow earnings across multiple industries.

Bunnings remains a powerful business with a dominant position in home improvement, while Kmart continues to benefit from its reputation for affordable products.

Wesfarmers also has opportunities in healthcare, chemicals, and lithium. And the earnings forecasts suggest the company could deliver robust growth over the coming years.

According to CommSec consensus estimates, Wesfarmers is expected to generate earnings per share (EPS) of $2.66 in FY27, rising to $3.06 by FY29.

For context, the company reported EPS of $2.53 in FY26.

That implies compound annual earnings growth (CAGR) of approximately 6.5% over the three years to FY29.

I think that's a solid outlook for a company of Wesfarmers' size. 

It also offers a forward dividend yield of 2.9% based on consensus estimates.

However, Wesfarmers shares aren't cheap. At around $79.18, they trade on a PE ratio of approximately 29.8 times forecast FY27 earnings.

That's a premium valuation, and it leaves less room for disappointment if earnings growth falls short of expectations.

However, I think the quality of its businesses and its longer-term growth opportunities help justify paying a premium.

Foolish takeaway

If I could only choose one, I would buy Wesfarmers shares.

I like Telstra and think it deserves consideration for investors who want a higher level of dividend income.

But Wesfarmers offers the balance I prefer. Its collection of high-quality businesses provides several opportunities to increase earnings, while its growing dividends offer another way to reward shareholders.

Motley Fool contributor Grace Alvino has positions in Wesfarmers. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Wesfarmers. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Telstra Group. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Wesfarmers. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Blue Chip Shares

A young woman drinking coffee in a cafe smiles as she checks her phone.
Blue Chip Shares

Why I'd buy Wesfarmers and Coles shares today

These businesses aren't trading at bargain prices, but I think their long-term opportunities justify a closer look.

Read more »

Happy young couple riding a motorbike together.
Blue Chip Shares

Why I'd buy these ASX blue-chip shares until at least 2036

I'm looking at three established businesses that could become more profitable over the next 10 years.

Read more »

Blue chips with stock written on them.
Blue Chip Shares

2 ASX blue-chip shares offering large dividend yields

I think these businesses have a very compelling future.

Read more »

Three smiling corporate people examine a model of a new building complex.
Blue Chip Shares

3 popular ASX shares I'd happily buy and hold until 2036

Wondering where to invest for the long term? I have my eyes on these shares.

Read more »

Person holding a blue chip.
Blue Chip Shares

2 top ASX blue-chip shares to buy according to experts

These two large businesses could be big opportunities.

Read more »

Happy young couple riding a motorbike together.
Blue Chip Shares

Why I think these 3 ASX shares could be turnaround winners in 2027

These shares have been having a tough time but could be worth a second look.

Read more »

Blue chips with stock written on them.
Blue Chip Shares

2 great ASX blue-chip shares I'd buy right now

I think these stocks can help build wealth.

Read more »

Two work colleagues looking at a laptop and discussing something.
Blue Chip Shares

Five ASX blue chips, five verdicts. One of them I wouldn't touch right now

I've taken a closer look at five familiar ASX shares, and there's one I wouldn't be comfortable buying at current…

Read more »