S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) mining shares are outperforming today, up 0.8%, while the broader index is up 0.5%.
Here are some new ratings and 12-month share price targets on 3 ASX 200 mining shares.
Image source: Getty Images
Catalyst Metals Ltd (ASX: CYL)
The Catalyst Metals share price is $6.89, up 3.5% today and down 15% over 12 months.
Morgans has a buy rating on this ASX 200 gold share following its June quarter report.
The broker said:
CYL reported record production at Plutonic in Q4 to close out FY26, but we expect a softer FY27 outlook when guidance is released in late Sep-26.
Permitting timelines, the ramp-up of multiple new mines and a better understanding of processing capability are likely to drive a rebase of the Sep-25 10-year plan, potentially delaying the pathway to ~200kozpa.
As a result, we have amended our production forecasts and cost assumptions.
Following an analyst change, we retain our BUY recommendation with a revised price target of A$11.33 per share.
Sandfire Resources Ltd (ASX: SFR)
The Sandfire Resources share price is $22.49, up 0.5% today and up 84% over 12 months.
Morgans downgraded the ASX 200 copper share from accumulate to hold after its FY26 results.
The broker said:
SFR resumed dividends with a 35cps final dividend (+86% vs expectations) and we see scope for this to build further as its cash balance continues to grow with no drawn debt, supported by a favourable base metals price environment.
SFR's asset quality, management quality and balance sheet strength, alongside emerging growth optionality, underpin its case as a core copper exposure for long-term investors, though the stock appears fully valued at current prices.
Move to HOLD (previously ACCUMULATE) with a $23ps target price.
PLS Group Ltd (ASX: PLS)
The PLS Group share price is $5.31, up 2.3% today and up 132% over 12 months.
Morgans has a sell call on this ASX 200 lithium share.
Analyst Annabelle Sleeman explained:
Depleted lithium inventories leave scope for short-term upside, though we see the medium-term outlook as more volatile given uncertainty around supply and demand drivers.
PLS delivered an in-line FY26 Underlying EBITDA result and surprised with a maiden 5cps fully franked final dividend (22% FCF payout).
We view PLS as fairly valued at current levels, with its premium to peers already reflecting the company's best-in-class execution, balance sheet and growth optionality.
