Woolworths vs Coles shares: One I'd buy and one I'd sell

The supermarket war is as hot as ever.

Key points
  • Woolworths shares are slightly up, offering a 7.01% potential upside, as recent sales growth in WooliesX and B2B sectors suggests a recovery path in FY26 after previous earnings declines.
  • Despite recent strength and a 25.7% annual gain, Coles shares could be showing signs of hitting a ceiling, with analysts providing diverse ratings and concerns about limited future catalysts.
  • Woolworths has mixed analyst support with an average target suggesting growth, while Coles, despite a recent high, faces stronger headwinds and recommendations to sell or hold.

The supermarket war between long-time rivals Woolworths Group Ltd (ASX: WOW) and Coles Group Ltd (ASX: COL) has been going on for decades. The two supermarket giants have a duopoly over market share in Australia, accounting for around 70% of the market share combined. 

Together they control prices, supplier terms, and customer behaviour more than any other supermarket in the Australian retail sector. 

But when it comes to the Australian share market, I'd buy one of the supermarket shares, but sell the other.

One boy is triumphant while the other holds his head in his hands after a game of chess.

Image source: Getty Images

I'd buy Woolworths shares

Woolworths shares closed 0.78% higher at the close of the ASX on Tuesday afternoon, at $28.26 each. Over the past month Woolworths shares have climbed 8.73%, but over the year the shares are still down 4.24% thanks to a sharp investor sell-off in late-August.

At the time, the supermarket chain suffered a loss of investor confidence following a disappointing FY25 result. The company reported a 12.6% decline in its earnings before interest and tax, and a 17.1% drop in its net profit. 

More recently in late-October, Woolworths revealed its first quarter sales update, providing some investor relief. It reported 2.7% growth in group sales driven by growth in WooliesX and B2B sectors. 

It looks like the latest results could be a sign that the supermarket giant is well-placed to recover over FY26, and I think there is a good opportunity to buy the shares ahead of its resurgence.

Analysts are a little more reserved, however. TradingView data shows that out of 17 analysts, 11 have a hold rating on Woolworths shares and another 6 have a buy or strong buy rating. There is an average target price of $30.24. That implies a potential 7.01% upside at the time of writing.

I'd sell Coles shares

Coles shares closed 0.09% higher at the close of the ASX on Tuesday afternoon, at $22.30 a piece. Over the past month the share price has dropped 5.31%, but over the year the shares are still 25.7% higher.

The Coles share price enjoyed a 15.9% spike in late-August off the back of a robust FY25 result. It also posted a strong quarterly update in late-October where it reported a 3.9% increase in group sales. But liquor sales were down 1.1% and new legislation pushed its tobacco sales 57% lower.

It looks like Coles is positioning itself as the stronger market player, but I'm concerned that its share price has reached a ceiling and has started to correct from its peak.

TradingView data shows analyst sentiment is starting to shift too. Out of 17 analysts, 10 have a buy or strong buy rating, while 5 have a hold rating, and 2 have a strong sell rating on Coles shares.

The average target price on Coles shares is $23.83, which implies a potential 6.85% upside for investors at the time of writing.

Alto Capital's Tony Locantro is one broker who sees headwinds building for Coles shares following on its strong run. He has a sell recommendation on the stock.

Michael Gable from Fairmont Equities also recently said his team "can't identify sufficient catalysts to justify the share price".

Morgans has a hold rating and $22.90 price target on Coles shares. The broker thinks investors should wait for a better entry point before buying.

Motley Fool contributor Samantha Menzies has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Woolworths Group. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Opinions

A young well-dressed couple at a luxury resort celebrate successful life choices.
Opinions

My 3 biggest ASX portfolio winners and the one I'm buying more of

These businesses have significant growth potential.

Read more »

A woman relaxes on a yellow couch with a book and cuppa, and looks pensively away as she contemplates the joy of earning passive income.
Opinions

3 reasons why I think this leading ASX 200 share is a buy

This underrated business could be a top buy today…

Read more »

A woman sprints with a trail of fire blazing from her body.
Opinions

I hunted the ASX for shares with the potential to double. This one stood out

Do you have this ASX share in your investment portfolio?

Read more »

A fit woman in workout gear flexes her muscles with two bigger people flexing behind her, indicating growth.
Opinions

I wanted growth, not hype. Only 3 ASX shares passed my checks

One of these ASX shares is tipped to climb up to 38%.

Read more »

Man with his hands out as if pondering his options.
Opinions

I've always loved Wesfarmers shares. But after a trip to Kmart, I'm not so sure

A weekend trip took some gloss off this stock.

Read more »

Piles of increasing coins alongside an hourglass.
Opinions

Why I'm planning to buy more Soul Patts shares in 2027

I think Soul Patts is a great long-term buy.

Read more »

a close up of a woman's face looks skywards as she is showered in a sea of graphic symbols of gold and silver coins bearing the bitcoin logo.
Cryptocurrencies

Are you a 'greater fool' for owning Bitcoin?

Is Bitcoin truly an investment?

Read more »

A woman in a red dress holding up a red graph.
Opinions

I went looking for shares which could double by 2030. These 3 made my shortlist

All of these shares are in recovery mode.

Read more »