The Suncorp Group Ltd (ASX: SUN) share price is tanking today after a top broker downgraded it due to "structural" risks from climate change.
Shares in the insurance and banking group have so far tumbled 5.12% to a three-week low of $11.50.
This makes the share the worst performer on the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) at the time of writing.
For comparison, the Insurance Australia Group Ltd (ASX: IAG) share price and QBE Insurance Group Ltd (ASX: QBE) share price are also falling, by around 3% and 2% respectively.
Image source: Getty Images
What's up with the Suncorp share price?
No catastrophe (CAT) insurer can escape the impact of climate change. But the Suncorp share price could also be taking a beating after Morgan Stanley cut its price target with an "underweight" rating, according to the Australian Financial Review.
The broker reckons that Suncorp and IAG are more exposed to catastrophic weather events than QBE. QBE is a more diversified business.
Morgan Stanley said:
Investors have been discounting climate change and CAT risks as cyclical for insurers, but we think they are structural as our new analysis shows.
Consensus ratings are heavily OW [overweight] on both SUN and IAG, leaning on both stocks being cheap because they have de-rated in the past three years, and also ascribing the ongoing over-runs on CAT costs as cyclical one-offs or sheer bad luck.
We would say that just because SUN and IAG have de-rated recently, does not mean that SUN and IAG are cheap enough.
When cheap isn't cheap enough
The Suncorp share price has de-rated by around two times price-to-earnings (P/E) points to circa 14 times consensus P/E. The IAG share price shed around 3 times P/E points to 15 times consensus.
But despite the big sell-off today, there is further downside risk to the Suncorp share price, according to Morgan Stanley.
The broker lowered its 12-month price target on Suncorp to $10.50 from $12.50 a share. This implies that the Suncorp share price has to fall another 9% before reaching fair value.
The Suncorp share price vs. the IAG share price
The IAG share price was also downgraded by the broker. Morgan Stanley trimmed its 12-month price target to $3.70 from $4.05 a share.
The reason why IAG is fairing a little better is probably because the broker kept its "equal-weight" recommendation on the shares.
With the big loss in the Suncorp share price today, it is now down 0.2% since the start of 2022. At least that's a bit better than the IAG share price, which has shed almost 2% of its value since the start of January.
In comparison, the ASX 200 is nursing a loss of 4.6% for the calendar year.
