How can you fully invest and not sell, then buy during market corrections?

It’s a ‘buy and hold’ investor’s dilemma. Isn’t it impossible to do all 3 things? What are the experts on about?

| More on:
Elderly couple look sideways at each other in mild disagreement

Image source: Getty Images

Retail ASX investors are always told to be in it for the long term.

Trading is gambling, while ‘buy and hold’ is true investing, the experts say.

You see, a stock market will have a bad day, month or even year. But eventually, it moves in an upwards direction.

So if you can ignore the volatility and stay fully invested for the long-run, then the chances are your wealth will have grown at the end of it.

Sensible advice.

The other bits of strategy we hear are:

Also eminently sensible. 

If you sell when shares have plunged, all you’re doing is turn a paper loss into an actual loss — without any chance of recovery.

And if you can pluck up enough courage, buying shares during corrections is like picking up a pair of pants at the Boxing Day sales.

They’re still the same trousers, just cheaper.

But hang on a minute

This is all good and well, but how can you possibly practise all 3 of the strategies in the ‘buy and hold’ game?

If you’re fully invested, you have no spare cash to invest. And you don’t sell during a correction, so you still don’t have any cash.

So how do you buy up those bargains without any money?

The Motley Fool asked some experts as to how a retail investor can possibly carry out all 3 pieces of advice.

You really can’t do all 3

“Those are all worthy sentiments. And I think they are all good advice,” said The Motley Fool Australia chief investment officer Scott Phillips.

“But yes, they’re incompatible! But they’re incompatible in the same way that no 2 investors are the same or find themselves in the same circumstances.”

Phillips revealed that he preferred to stay fully invested, and therefore sacrifice the “buy bargains” mantra.

“I rarely have ‘extra’ cash when a crash comes. But I think that’s the right approach, given that the market tends to go up more than it goes down and, over time, continues to set new high watermarks, one after the other.”

Shaw and Partners senior investment adviser Adam Dawes takes the opposite approach.

“We always like to keep at least 10% of clients’ money in the bank for opportunities — or using a broker expression ‘Keeping your powder dry’.”

Not being invested will cost you

To Phillips, to have money lying around doing nothing is a wasted opportunity.

“To not be invested would be to bet against the tide of history, which has continued to push markets higher,” he told The Motley Fool.

“And if you’re waiting to buy on a ‘dip’, you might end up missing a 20% gain while you wait for a 5%, 10% or 15% ‘dip’ to come along!”

And it’s not like anyone knows whether they’re at the top, bottom or otherwise anyway.

“It’s hard enough to know what mood the market is in today, let alone tomorrow, or next week,” said Phillips.

“I’m not going to say it’s a waste of time trying to guess but… Ah, bugger it. I’ll just say it: It’s a waste of time.”

Beware of the bargains during market corrections

Both Dawes and Phillips agreed on one thing though.

If you’re going to buy up bargains during a market correction, you better make sure the business is sound.

“My mantra in the recovery phase or bottom of the market is ‘Don’t be a hero’,” Dawes told The Motley Fool.

“Buy good quality stocks and put them in the bottom drawer. Example: Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA) at $55, BHP Group Ltd (ASX: BHP) at $25. You need to look past the valley and just buy good quality business that will last the test of time.”

As for selling during a crash, aside from the obvious loss of money, Dawes also pointed out a devastating psychological effect.

“If you sell, then most clients don’t get back in as they are paralysed with fear as markets continue to recover,” he said.

“It is not wise to sell as markets always come back. March 2020 it came back within 6 months and GFC took a little longer.”

Wondering where you should invest $1,000 right now?

When investing expert Scott Phillips has a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the flagship Motley Fool Share Advisor newsletter he has run for over ten years has provided thousands of paying members with stock picks that have doubled, tripled or even more.*

Scott just revealed what he believes could be the five best ASX stocks for investors to buy right now. These stocks are trading at near dirt-cheap prices and Scott thinks they could be great buys right now.

*Returns as of January 12th 2022

Motley Fool contributor Tony Yoo has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Investing Strategies

Concept image of Bitcoin and hand using laptop.

Using Bitcoin to diversify your portfolio? Read this

Cryptos have been rising and falling largely in line with other risk assets.

Read more »

ASX share fund manager Robert Gregory
Investing Strategies

My fund just went up 51%: This is how I did it

Ask A Fund Manager: Glenmore Asset Management's Robert Gregory explains the philosophy behind his portfolio's industry-leading performance.

Read more »

red percentage sign with man looking up which represents high interest rates
Investing Strategies

Warning: 3 ASX shares under pressure from rising interest rates

There is much bargain-hunting to be done right now, but there are still some stocks that you better off waiting…

Read more »

A female athlete in green spandex leaps from one cliff edge to another representing 3 ASX shares that are destined to rise and be great
Broker Notes

3 ASX shares destined for greatness: Firetrail

Stocks themselves have no memory, so even ones that have dropped violently this year can shoot back up if the…

Read more »

A man and a woman sit in front of a laptop looking fascinated and captivated by ASX shares news articles especially one about the Bannerman Energy share price
Broker Notes

2 ASX shares that could surprise you in a year’s time

Here are a couple of stocks that have different spins on the word 'quality', both of which could serve you…

Read more »

A person holds their hands over three piggy banks, protecting and shielding their money and investments.
Investing Strategies

How is the AFIC share price performing with the ASX 200 volatility?

Is the AFIC share price seeing the same volatility as the ASX 200?

Read more »

woman meditating and keeping calm
Investing Strategies

How to deal with the current share market calamity

This poem from 112 years ago tells you how to deal with massive stock market corrections, like we're seeing at…

Read more »

Model bear in front of falling line graph, cheap stocks, cheap ASX shares
Investing Strategies

Unprecedented: Does this event mean we’re now in a bear market?

A statistical anomaly has just occurred that's historically a bad signal. One expert breaks down whether we should be worried.

Read more »