The AGL (ASX:AGL) share price is down 38% so far in 2021. Here's why

AGL shares are having a year to forget.

The AGL Energy Limited (ASX: AGL) share price is having a year to forget. At close of trade of Friday, shares in the energy producer were selling for $7.46. While that's up 3.9% on the previous close, it's down 1.84% over 2 days and an almost unbelievable 38.5% in 2021.

Just for context, the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) is up 14.1% this year. In other words, the AGL share price is underperforming the benchmark index by a whopping 52.6 percentage points.

Let's take a closer look to see what's going on.

Sad looking worker standing next to an oil drill.

Image source: Getty Images

AGL's FY21 results

For the full financial year, AGL Energy declared a statutory loss of over $2 billion but an underlying profit of $537 million. The underlying figure is down 33.5% on the prior corresponding period.

Not only did profits fall, but most other financial indicators too. For example:

  • Revenues decreased 10% on the pcp to $10.9 billion.
  • Underlying earnings per share (EPS) dropped 31.6% to 86.2 cents.
  • Net operating cash outflow before significant items was $870 million – a 35% drop.
  • The full year dividend of 75 cents per share (41 cents interim + 35 cents final) is down 23.5% on the pcp for a yield of 10.1% on the current AGL share price.

AGL Managing Director and CEO, Graeme Hunt, said the impacts of the pandemic and longer-term trends were hurting the company:

"Our FY21 result reflects a challenging year for AGL Energy as we realised the impact of lower wholesale electricity prices, reduced electricity generation output at peak periods, and the roll-off of legacy supply contracts in Wholesale Gas."

"Although wholesale electricity prices have rallied in recent months, our result reflected the impact over the past two years of increasing generation supply and lower demand arising from the COVID-19 pandemic and milder weather."

What else has hit the AGL share price

As Motley Fool has previously reported, there have been several significant items that have hit AGL shares.

For example, on 30 June AGL announced plans to demerge into two businesses, both listed on the ASX. Accel Energy would focus on low-carbon energy production while AGL Australia's remit will pertain to multiple energy products as well as energy trading, storage, and supply. The AGL share price slumped on this news.

Management expects the demerger to be completed by the fourth quarter of FY22.

As well, there were multiple updates relating to the company's current and proposed work sites, including Crib Point, Loy Yang, the Portland smelter, and Liddell.

AGL share price snapshot

While the last 7 and half months have been challenging for the AGL share price, the last 12 have been more so. Over 52 weeks, AGL shares have collapsed 51.4%.

Not only is AGL massively underperforming the ASX 200, but it's also underperforming its industrial peers. The S&P/ASX 200 Energy Index (ASX: XEJ) is down 2.66% this year and up 6.31% over the 12 months.

AGL Energy has a market capitalisation of around $4.5 billion.

Motley Fool contributor Marc Sidarous has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Energy Shares

Woman calculating dividends on calculator and working on a laptop.
Energy Shares

If I invest $5,000 in Santos shares today, what could they be worth by late October 2027?

Santos shares have boomed 45% higher over the past 12 months.

Read more »

Engineer in the oilfield wearing red helmet and work clothes, with pumpjack and wellhead in the background.
Energy Shares

Would I buy Woodside or Santos shares if oil prices remain high?

One has major new developments on the way, while the other is already seeing production growth.

Read more »

An oil worker holds his hands in the air in celebration in silhouette against a seitting sun with oil drilling equipment in the background.
Energy Shares

Can Woodside shares rally to fresh 52-week high?

Are the oil and gas major's shares a buy, sell, or hold now?

Read more »

Smiling oil worker in front of a pumpjack.
Energy Shares

Woodside Energy vs Beach Energy: Which ASX energy share is better for young investors right now?

Woodside Energy vs Beach Energy: which ASX energy stock looks best a 20 year old investor?

Read more »

two men in suits shake hands at the top of a shined wood boardroom table.
Energy Shares

Beach Energy expands Taroom Trough acreage with major farm-in deal

Beach Energy is set to acquire a major operated stake in the Taroom Trough, expanding its acreage and future gas…

Read more »

A man and his small son crouch in a green field under a beautiful sunset sky looking at renewable, wind generators for energy production.
Energy Shares

Genesis Energy posts customer growth and advances renewables in FY27 Q1 update

Genesis Energy grew customer numbers to 493,450 and advanced its renewables pipeline in a strong FY27 Q1 update.

Read more »

A traffic light with the green light flashing representing the BHP board moving forward with unification of corporate structure
Energy Shares

APA Group green-lights Bulloo Interlink Pipeline, announces Origin Energy deal

APA Group has green-lit its Bulloo Interlink Pipeline, backed by a new five-year gas transport deal with Origin Energy.

Read more »

Two colleagues working with company financial results.
Energy Shares

Santos delivers record Q3 production and earnings in 2026

Santos delivered record Q3 production and sales revenue, with Barossa and Pikka ramping up and full-year guidance tightened.

Read more »