Fossil fuels vs renewables: What's ahead for ASX energy shares?

Does the world need more fossil fuels… or less? The outcome of this growing debate could help or hinder these ASX energy shares.

If you were running a successful, multi-billion company and someone asked what your plans were to wind it down, what would you say?

This isn't a rhetorical question.

In fact, it is the gist of the demand Market Forces, an environmental activist investor group, is making to some of Australia's biggest energy shares.

As the Australian Financial Review (AFR) reports, Market Forces is asking "ASX-listed fossil fuel companies to plan for their own demise in order to align with Paris climate goals".

Their first target is the $14 billion ASX oil and gas giant, Santos Ltd (ASX: STO), part of the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO).

Santos' management, as you might expect, indicated they had no plans to shutter operations, replying:

Santos does not intend to close down its oil and gas operations, as doing so would be against the interests of shareholders and would not be consistent with global climate and human development goals, particularly reducing air pollution and poverty.

According to Santos, 80% of the world's primary energy needs are still derived from oil and gas. A figure that's unchanged since 1975. Rather than eliminating its fossil fuel production, the company is working on reducing emissions via novel technologies in carbon capture and storage. Santos is also involved in developing hydrogen energy sources with no carbon footprint.

Other ASX energy shares in Market Forces' crosshairs this year are Woodside Petroleum Limited (ASX: WPL) with a market cap of $24 billion; Oil Search Ltd (ASX: OSH) with a market cap of $8.5 billion; Whitehaven Coal Ltd (ASX: WHC) with a market cap of $1.6 billion; and New Hope Corporation Limited (ASX: NHC) with a market cap of just over $1 billion.

Market Forces is working under the assumption that Australia, and the rest of the world, can quickly transition away from fossil fuels, replacing the energy sources with renewables.

But how close is Australia really to switching off all the gas in favour of solar and wind?

Two hands raised against eachother with lightning flashes between them, indicating and energy clash between fossil fuels and renewables

Image source: Getty Images

Has the demise of gas been greatly exaggerated?

Consultancy firm Wood Mackenzie estimates that Australia will require 10 times more gas to generate power than what the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) has forecast.

According to the AFR, WoodMac forecasts that gas will still provide some 10% of Australia's power in 2030, as opposed to AEMO's 1% estimate.

WoodMac senior analyst Rishab Shrestha said:

You need a balanced portfolio to avoid extreme price spikes. We need to manage the speed of this transition, and perhaps the transition blueprint that has been laid out does not necessarily capture all the risks that are associated with that.

The ongoing debates could offer headwinds or tailwinds to the share prices of the biggest ASX energy companies, depending on the outcome.

Motley Fool contributor Bernd Struben has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on ASX Share Market News

Happy wife holding her hands on her husband's shoulders while both look at a laptop.
Broker Notes

Top brokers name 3 ASX shares to buy next week

Brokers gave buy ratings to these ASX shares last week. Why are they bullish?

Read more »

A man stands in front of a chart with an arrow going down and slaps his forehead in frustration.
ASX Share Market News

ASX 200 mining shares smashed in major market sell-off

The ASX 200 fell 5.39% amid a mining sell-off, with BHP shares tumbling almost 13% last week.

Read more »

A woman weraing a stripy t-shirt winks as she points to the decorative gold crown on her head.
ASX Share Market News

CBA shares back on top of the ASX 200 as BHP dives 13% this week

CBA shares have rallied 9.5% over the past month whilst BHP tumbled 13% this week.

Read more »

a man wearing a hard hat and a high visibility vest stands with his arms crossed in front of heavy equipment at a mine site.
Broker Notes

BHP share price drops 13% to seven-month low in just 1 week. Do experts say buy?

Market analysts offer their advice as BHP shares plunge this week.

Read more »

A distressed young woman reads bad news on her smartphone while standing in a modern indoor setting.
Broker Notes

5 ASX 200 shares experts recommend we buy amid the market carnage this week

ASX 200 shares are down 5.2% this week and back in the red for 2026 overall.

Read more »

Comical investor reading documents and surrounded by calculators.
Broker Notes

Buy, hold, sell: Hub24, Reece, Ramsay Healthcare shares

Analysts reveal their ratings on this financial services provider, plumbing supplies company, and private hospital operator.

Read more »

IPO spelt out on a laptop with a red and green bar chart underneath.
IPOs

Anthropic hits the market. Was it enough to distract investors from a bruised AI sector and Nvidia's scandal?

Was the biggest IPO in US history enough to re-energise the AI trade?

Read more »

A man with his back to the camera holds his hands to his head as he looks to a jagged red line trending sharply downward.
Broker Notes

Three of the worst performers in the ASX 200. Brokers think they're ready to bounce back

There could be a lot of value in these poor performers.

Read more »