Gold at record highs! Are ASX gold miners or ETFs a better bet?

Are ASX gold miners like Newcrest Mining Ltd (ASX: NCM) a better bet than a gold ETF? With prices nearing record highs, it's a tough choice.

| More on:

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

The gold price has been a quiet achiever over the year so far. While most investors' attention has been focused on the recovery of the S&P/ASX 200  (INDEXASX: XJO) since the market bottom on 23 March, the gold price has also been climbing. At March's low, the yellow metal was priced around US$1,478 an ounce. Today, that same ounce will set you back US$1,778 (which is more than a 20% bump). Just 2 days ago, gold hit $1,787 an ounce — it's the highest price since 2011's all-time high of $1,917.90.

Why has the gold price been climbing?

Gold is usually viewed as a 'safe haven' asset due to its physicality, scarcity, and former role as a monetary base. The coronavirus pandemic has created an almost perfect environment for gold to flourish in this role in recent months. Further, investors worry about the consequences of central banks using 'quantitative easing' (QE) to assist their economies through the crisis. QE is viewed by many people as 'money printing'. This is leading to fears of an inflationary investing environment in the coming years. Last month, I wrote about how the ultra-rich are hoarding gold for this very reason.

How can you invest in gold?

There are 3 conventional ways of investing in gold:

  1. Buying physical gold bullion
  2. Invest in a gold miner
  3. Buy gold through an exchange-traded fund (ETF).

Buying physical bullion can be unattractive to investors due to storage and transportation costs, so we'll leave this out of the discussion.

That leaves ETFs or ASX gold miners for your perusal.

Advantages of gold ETFs

A gold ETF is an easy way to invest in gold because the fund manager buys and stores the gold on investors' behalf, usually in a bank vault or other secure location. An ASX example is the ETFs Metal Securities Australia Ltd (ASX: GOLD).

Gold ETFs are an easy choice, as they will usually mirror the returns you will see in the gold price. This will, of course, be adjusted for currency fluctuations. But there are a couple of drawbacks. Gold (as an unproductive asset) gives off no yield, so you can't generate cash flow unless you sell your units. Also, the gold still has to be stored and guarded, which means you will pay a fee to the ETF for the privilege.

Advantages of ASX gold miners

A gold miner is another popular way of gaining exposure to gold. As a gold miner is a company, you, as a shareholder, indirectly 'own' any gold the company mines. And as a company is (hopefully) profitable, you can also receive a yield on your investment through dividend payments. As an example, Newcrest Mining Limited (ASX: NCM) is the largest ASX gold miner and currently offers a trailing dividend yield of 1%.

But the good news for a gold miner is that it can deliver returns that exceed the gold price movements. If a company's cost to mine an ounce of gold is US$1,000, and gold is selling for $1,500 an ounce, the company makes a profit of $500 per ounce. But if gold prices rise to US$2,000 an ounce, your investment just doubled its profitability, even though gold 'only' rose 33%.

Of course, this works in reverse too. Meaning that a gold miner is effectively a 'leveraged bet' on gold prices. There are also other concerns to worry about with a miner including how well the company is run and the debt it employs.

Foolish takeaway

A gold miner can be a lucrative way to gain exposure to gold. But it's also riskier than just owning physical bullion or investing in an ETF. As such, if exposure to gold is important to your investing philosophy, I think most retail investors are best served by an ETF.

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen owns shares of Newcrest Mining Limited. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Gold

Miner standing at quarry looking upset
Gold

Buying Northern Star shares? Here's the latest on the gold miner's production woes

Northern Star provided a detailed response to the ASX regarding its FY 2026 gold sales downgrade.

Read more »

Woman with gold nuggets on her hand.
Gold

Up 177% in a year, why is this ASX 300 gold stock leaping higher again on Friday?

Investors are piling into this high-flying ASX gold stock again today. But why?

Read more »

A man leaps from a stack of gold coins to the next, each one higher than the last.
Gold

Why this ASX 200 gold stock is tipped for a 'major re-rate' in 2026

A leading fund manager expects a strong year ahead for this cashed up ASX 200 gold stock.

Read more »

Gold nugget with a red arrow going down.
Gold

Why this top-tier ASX gold stock is sliding again this week

This ASX gold miner is under pressure after cutting production guidance and facing rising caution from analysts.

Read more »

A woman holds a gold bar in one hand and puts her other hand to her forehead with an apprehensive and concerned expression on her face after watching the Ramelius share price fall today
Gold

Why is this popular ASX 200 gold stock tumbling today?

This gold miner's update has disappointed investors.

Read more »

Woman with gold nuggets on her hand.
Gold

This ASX gold giant jumped almost 5% on Wednesday. Here's why

Newmont shares jumped nearly 5% on Wednesday after the gold miner released a fresh operational update to the market.

Read more »

Image of young successful engineer, with blueprints, notepad and digital tablet, observing the project implementation on construction site and in mine.
Gold

This gold stock just hit a fresh high, but at least one broker thinks it can go higher

This gold company is on track to meet full-year guidance.

Read more »

a woman wearing a sparkly strapless dress leans on a neat stack of six gold bars as she smiles and looks to the side as though she is very happy and protective of her stash. She also has gold fingernails and gold glitter pieces affixed to her cheeks.
Gold

This ASX 100 gold stock says it is on track to hit the upper end of production guidance

This gold company has grown its cash and bullion reserves after another strong quarter.

Read more »