I analysed the top dividend-paying shares in the ASX 20. 2 were streets ahead of the rest

A porftfolio of these shares would have outperformed the market by far.

Buying blue-chip shares that pay a strong dividend is a tried-and-true investment strategy over the long term.

The performance of those shares can vary widely year to year, however, meaning your total return can differ greatly from company to company.

I filtered out the top five dividend-paying shares in the S&P/ASX 20 Index (ASX: XTL), which are, in order of payout size, Woodside Energy Group Ltd (ASX: WDS) with 5.4%, Rio Tinto Ltd (ASX: RIO) with 4.91%, National Australia Bank Ltd (ASX: NAB) with 4.62%, BHP Group Ltd (ASX: BHP) with 4.62%, and Transurban Group (ASX: TCL) with 4.58%.

Keep in mind these are all trailing dividends, with the data taken from the ASX website, and all except Transurban were fully franked.

For a dividend investor, all of these figures are looking pretty good at the moment.

But when you factor in the share price moves over the past year, the pack splits apart.

Australian dollar notes in the pocket of a man's jeans, symbolising dividends.

Image source: Getty Images

Separating the wheat from the chaff

Perhaps not surprisingly, given the changes to capital gains tax laws coming down the pipeline, NAB was the worst performer, shedding 11.5% in value on the share price front over the past year.

Transurban shares fell by 1.9% over the past 12 months, while Rio Tinto is marginally in the black, with a 2.5% return.

Then you have Woodside and BHP.

Woodside gained 14.9% over the past year while BHP added 23.4%.

Had the numbers been calculated at a different time of the year, the gains could have been much greater, with the global miner's shares peaking at $68.77 in late August.

Once franked dividends are factored in, the total return on BHP shares rises to 31.7% over the past 12 months.

So what does all of this tell us?

To make it simple, I whacked all of this data into a spreadsheet and ran the calculations on a portfolio equally weighted between all five shares, held for a year.

What that found was that, by buying these five top dividend-paying shares, you would have returned 12.5% over the past year, including the impact of franking credits.

That's not bad in itself, but when you consider the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) has returned 3.67% over the past year, including dividends, according to Market Index data, it starts to look pretty good.

It also shows one of the downsides of diversification. Two of the chosen stocks were millstones, while BHP and Woodside delivered almost all of the gains on the share price front.

Foolish takeaway

It's perhaps not surprising that the cream of the ASX 20 stocks outperformed the broader market.

Those companies are the biggest on the bourse for a reason.

While past performance doesn't predict future performance, there's a good argument here that the big end of town provides a steady pair of hands for your money.

Motley Fool contributor Cameron England has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Transurban Group. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Transurban Group. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended BHP Group. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Dividend Investing

Mid-aged couple looking at a laptop.
Dividend Investing

3 defensive ASX dividend shares to buy and hold

Looking for reliable income? These shares could tick a lot of boxes.

Read more »

Man holding Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
Dividend Investing

$5,000 buys 4,065 shares in an impressively reliable ASX dividend stock

This underrated business is a top contender for income.

Read more »

Man reading his emails on a laptop while relaxing on a beach.
Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs)

How I'd build the ultimate passive income ASX ETF portfolio right now

You'll never need to touch this passive income portfolio again.

Read more »

Woman with $50 notes in her hand thinking, symbolising dividends.
Dividend Investing

I'd buy these ASX dividend shares over CBA shares for income

CBA is not the first choice I’d choose for dividend income.

Read more »

A young woman carefully adds a rock to the top of a pile of balanced river rocks.
Dividend Investing

2 ASX income shares I'd buy for reliable dividends today

These stocks have fantastic dividend track records.

Read more »

Ascending piles of coins next to a wooden dollar sign amidst the sun setting.
Dividend Investing

If I invest $6,000 in CBA, BHP & Westpac shares, what passive income could I earn in FY27?

Each of the ASX powerhouses pays a regular passive income twice per year.

Read more »

Man holding out Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
Dividend Investing

This ASX share portfolio would generate $20,000 in dividends

This portfolio could provide investors with a growing passive income.

Read more »

Wooden clock sculpture next to piles of coins.
Dividend Investing

5 ASX dividend shares paying out better than 5%

If you're investing for income, these companies might be worth a look.

Read more »