The BHP Group Ltd (ASX: BHP) share price has pulled back a little on Monday and is trading around $58.14.
Nevertheless, the mining giant's shares remain up approximately 27% year-to-date with just one and a half months to go.
Could more outsized returns be on the cards in 2027?
Here's why I think a 10% return (or more) could be possible for investors next year.

Image source: Getty Images
What would a 10% return require?
Let's assume the BHP share price finishes 2026 trading at $58.14.
For investors to earn a total return of 10% over the following year, including dividends, their investment would need to increase in value by $5.81 per share.
BHP's dividends could do a reasonable amount of the work.
According to CommSec consensus forecasts, the company is expected to pay dividends totalling $2.07 per share in FY27.
That represents a potential dividend yield of approximately 3.6%.
If BHP pays that amount during 2027, its share price would only need to rise by 6.4% for investors to achieve a 10% total return. This would take it to approximately $61.89.
Is that a realistic BHP share price?
I think the current earnings forecasts could support a BHP share price of $61.89.
According to CommSec consensus estimates, BHP is expected to generate earnings per share (EPS) of $3.31 in FY27 and $3.28 in FY28.
At the hypothetical $61.89 target, BHP would trade on a forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of approximately 18.9 times FY28 earnings.
That would be a fairly demanding valuation for a mining company, especially given the cyclical nature of commodity markets.
However, analysts expect earnings to increase to $4.06 per share in FY29. If that forecast proves accurate, it would represent approximately 15.2 times FY29 earnings.
I think that's an attractive valuation if BHP can deliver the anticipated earnings growth.
Why I think BHP could get there
One reason I'm optimistic is the increasing contribution from BHP's copper operations.
In FY26, copper generated more than half of the company's underlying operating earnings for the first time.
I think that's an important development because it gives BHP another major source of profitability alongside iron ore.
And although copper production is expected to decline in FY27 as ore grades fall at Escondida, the company is benefiting from stronger prices.
During the September quarter, BHP's average realised copper price was 53% higher than a year earlier.
I wouldn't assume those prices will remain elevated indefinitely, but they demonstrate how valuable its existing copper operations can be.
I'm also encouraged by the performance of its Western Australian iron ore business, which achieved record mine and port production during the September quarter.
I believe that operational strength gives BHP a solid foundation as it invests in future copper production.
And with its Jansen potash project expected to begin production in mid-2027, investors could also begin looking ahead to another source of earnings growth.
Of course, commodity prices could weaken, and BHP faces considerable capital expenditure requirements.
However, I believe its existing cash-generating operations and development pipeline give investors good reasons to remain positive.
Foolish takeaway
I think a total return of more than 10% from the BHP share price in 2027 is achievable.
With dividends potentially contributing around 3.6%, the shares wouldn't need to rise massively to reach that target.
And given BHP's earnings outlook and long-term opportunities, I'd be happy to buy shares around $58.14 and hold them through 2027 and beyond.