Treasury Wine Estates vs Temple & Webster: Which beaten down ASX stock is better value?

Treasury Wine Estates and Temple & Webster have both tumbled, but I think one offers more compelling value for a turnaround.

A woman in her late 30s holds her hands out either side with the palms up as if indicating she doesn't know the answer to a question.

Image source: Getty Images

Treasury Wine Estates vs Temple & Webster shares

When the market hands out a bruising, sometimes opportunity follows. Lately, both Treasury Wine Estates Ltd (ASX: TWE) and Temple & Webster Group Ltd (ASX: TPW) have seen their share prices knocked around, leaving many investors pondering which battered name represents better value. Treasury is a global wine powerhouse with decades of history, while Temple & Webster is a pure-play online retailer in Australia's booming e-commerce sector. Let's dive into the numbers and their stories to see which offers the more attractive bounce-back potential.

The case for Treasury Wine Estates

Treasury Wine Estates is one of Australia's most recognisable names in wine, boasting a long heritage and a portfolio of over 70 brands such as Penfolds, Wolf Blass, and 19 Crimes. Since demerging from Foster's Group in 2011, Treasury has built a reputation as one of the world's largest wine companies, exporting premium wines globally. According to its most recent public profile, the business manages a broad spread of vineyards and employs thousands across production, sales, and distribution, making it a true global operator.

The fundamentals show a company with a market cap of $4.17 billion and a relatively low P/E ratio of 9.23. The dividend yield stands at a healthy 3.88%, with recent dividends franked at 70%. Notably, Treasury's reported earnings per share (EPS) is negative at -1.334, suggesting a recent period in the red—something that aligns with challenging trade conditions, including the impact of Chinese tariffs on Australian wine exports. However, the company has a long history of paying regular dividends, and a significant 70% franking on its most recent payouts.

The case for Temple & Webster Group

Temple & Webster Group is one of Australia's leading e-commerce retailers, specialising in furniture and homewares entirely online. Founded in 2011, it's grown fast, curating a whopping selection of more than 200,000 products and bringing new brands and private labels under its umbrella. Its low overhead digital model has helped it crack into living rooms nationwide, especially during e-commerce booms.

In the numbers, Temple & Webster is far smaller than Treasury, with a market cap of $492.99 million. Its P/E ratio is sky-high at 121.90, signalling investors are paying up for potential future growth. Reported EPS sits at 0.064—positive, but modest. Importantly for income seekers, Temple & Webster does not currently pay a dividend, so there's no yield or franking to sweeten the returns. With a heavy online focus, the company is positioned for the structural shift to digital retail, although its high valuation places a lot of faith in future growth.

Valuation comparison

Where these two diverge sharply is in valuation and yield:

MetricTreasury Wine EstatesTemple & Webster Group
Market Cap$4.17 billion$492.99 million
P/E Ratio9.23121.90
Dividend Yield3.88%0.00%
Franking on Recent Dividend70%N/A
Earnings per Share-1.3340.064

Note: Treasury Wine Estates' reported P/E ratio may be based on a different earnings measure (e.g. underlying or forward earnings) than the EPS figure shown, which is why they may appear inconsistent.

Temple & Webster is trading on an extremely high multiple, reflecting expectations for long-term growth. By contrast, Treasury looks much more attractively priced on earnings (at least using these P/E numbers), and offers a solid dividend—albeit with that red-inked EPS warning flag.

Recent share price performance

Comparing the period from 21 August 2026 to 18 September 2026:

  • Treasury Wine Estates' share price fell from $5.65 to $5.15, a drop of 8.8% over the period. Treasury is down 1.7% year-to-date.
  • Temple & Webster's share price slid from $4.30 to $4.23, a narrow fall of 1.6% in the same timeframe. Its year-to-date return is substantially worse, sitting at -69.1%—illustrating a huge sell-off in 2026.

Which is the better buy?

Both shares have been thumped recently, but if I'm reaching for value in a beaten down name, my pick would be Treasury Wine Estates. Its P/E ratio is dramatically lower, and there's a fully franked yield on offer for patience—a welcome cushion in uncertain times. Temple & Webster has promise and some growth appeal, but its razor-thin profits and sky-high valuation leave a lot riding on future success. The drop in Treasury's share price looks less severe than Temple & Webster's 69% YTD plunge, and while Treasury's negative EPS tempers my enthusiasm, I think its longstanding brands, global scale, and ongoing dividend give it the edge as a value rebound play. Here's hoping the next vintage is rosier.

Motley Fool contributor Laura Stewart has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Temple & Webster Group and Treasury Wine Estates. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Treasury Wine Estates. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Temple & Webster Group. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips. This article was prepared with the assistance of Large Language Model (LLM) tools for the initial draft. Any content assisted by AI is subject to our robust human-in-the-loop quality control framework, involving thorough review, substantial editing, and fact-checking by our experienced writers and editors holding appropriate credentials. The Motley Fool Australia stands behind the work of our editorial team and takes ultimate responsibility for the content published by The Motley Fool Australia.

More on Cheap Shares

Hand sketching investment growth concept chart with chalk on blackboard.
Cheap Shares

2 ASX shares tipped to grow up to 120% in the next 12 months

These ASX shares are projected to deliver big returns.

Read more »

Buy and sell keys on an Apple keyboard.
Cheap Shares

Xero stock has fallen 60%. Is it a bargain or a value trap? My verdict

Should investors be interested in Xero?

Read more »

A man in his 30s with a clipped beard sits at his laptop on a desk with one finger to the side of his face and his chin resting on his thumb as he looks concerned while staring at his computer screen.
Cheap Shares

$5,000 to invest? Treasury Wine shares could be dirt cheap

I've been looking at whether the worst could be behind this business, and a few developments have caught my attention.

Read more »

Buy, hold, and sell ratings written on signs on a wooden pole.
Cheap Shares

Considering buying Zip shares? Here's the view of 7 experts

Is Zip an attractive opportunity according to experts?

Read more »

A financial expert or broker looks worried as he checks out a graph showing market volatility.
Cheap Shares

Experts say these small ASX shares have big growth potential

A fund manager has explained why these stocks are an appealing buy.

Read more »

Wooden clock sculpture next to piles of coins.
Cheap Shares

2 top ASX shares to buy and hold for the next decade

These investments have a very appealing future, in my view.

Read more »

Red buy button on an Apple keyboard with a finger on it.
Cheap Shares

2 ASX shares highly recommended to buy: Experts

Many experts rate these stocks as buys.

Read more »

A group of people in suits watch as a man puts his hand up to take the opportunity.
Cheap Shares

A rare buying opportunity in 1 of Australia's top shares?

This is a great time to invest in this compelling business, in my view.

Read more »