Treasury Wine Estates Ltd (ASX: TWE) shares have been through a painful period and seem to have found more sellers than buyers over the past few years.
This has left the wine giant trading around $4.97 today, which is a world away from its 2023 levels of close to $15.00.
Image source: Getty Images
Why have the shares fallen?
Treasury Wine owns some valuable brands, led by Penfolds, but brand strength has not protected the company from a difficult operating environment.
The business has been dealing with weaker demand, excess inventory, and distribution challenges across major markets including China and the United States.
Those problems have placed pressure on sales and profitability. They have also damaged investor confidence because Treasury Wine now needs to show that products are reaching consumers rather than simply moving into distributor warehouses.
Management is responding by reducing costs, simplifying the business, tightening control over inventory, and reshaping its American operations.
I think those changes are necessary, even though the recovery is unlikely to be quick or perfectly smooth. The company needs to rebuild confidence through several reporting periods rather than one encouraging announcement.
What does the valuation look like?
According to CommSec consensus estimates, earnings per share are expected to fall to 31.2 cents in FY26 before recovering to 38.1 cents in FY27 and 40 cents in FY28.
At $4.97, Treasury Wine shares trade on a PE ratio of approximately 15.9 times FY26 earnings, 13 times FY27 earnings, and 12.4 times FY28 earnings.
Those multiples look low for a company with Penfolds and a portfolio of established premium wine brands.
The valuation suggests the market doubts whether the forecast recovery will arrive. I can understand that caution after the recent setbacks, although I think investors are now being compensated for accepting the uncertainty.
If Treasury Wine returns to earning 40 cents per share and rebuilds momentum beyond FY28, I think today's price could look extremely attractive in hindsight.
What about the dividend?
Treasury Wine has suspended its dividend while it protects capital and works through its current problems.
Consensus estimates do not include a dividend across the forecast period provided. That would likely make the shares unsuitable for anyone who needs dependable income today.
However, I think the dividend could return earlier if earnings, cash generation, and the balance sheet recover more quickly than expected.
Are Treasury Wine shares dirt cheap?
I think the answer is yes, although this is a turnaround investment rather than an obvious bargain with nothing to worry about.
Penfolds remains a globally recognised luxury brand, and Treasury Wine still has distribution, winemaking expertise, vineyards, and customer relationships that would be difficult to recreate.
The challenge is converting those strengths into dependable earnings again.
Consumer preferences can change, premium wine demand may remain weak, and the clean-up across China and the United States could take longer than hoped. Further disappointments would probably create more volatility.
Foolish takeaway
At around 12 times forecast FY28 earnings, I think Treasury Wine shares are dirt cheap if the business returns to form.
The market is giving investors a chance to buy valuable brands while confidence is low and the recovery remains uncertain.
I would be prepared to accept that uncertainty because the current price offers considerable upside if management stabilises the business, restores earnings growth, and eventually reinstates the dividend.
