Sell alert! Why this expert is calling time on Lynas shares

A leading investment expert believes the spectacular run higher for Lynas Rare Earths shares may be grinding to a halt.

Lynas Rare Earths Ltd (ASX: LYC) shares are marching higher today.

Shares in the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) rare earths miner closed yesterday trading for $15.51. In afternoon trade on Thursday, shares are changing hands for $15.71 each, up 1.3%.

For some context, the ASX 200 is up 1.1% today, with the benchmark index just breaking into new all-time highs.

Over the past year, the ASX 200 has now gained 8.1%, which pales in comparison to the 135.2% one-year gains achieved by Lynas shares. That's enough to turn a $10,000 investment into $23,518.

Looking to the year ahead, however, Bell Potter Securities' Christopher Watt believes the rare earths miner could face some stiff headwinds (courtesy of The Bull).

Here's why.

Red sell button on an Apple keyboard.

Image source: Getty Images

Time to sell Lynas shares?

"While Lynas boasts strategic positioning in rare earths amid a positive long-term theme, execution risks, in our view, remain elevated," said Watt, who has a sell recommendation on Lynas shares.

According to Watt:

The consensus among market watchers is for significant volatility ahead. Operational challenges, including power supply disruptions at the Kalgoorlie processing plant and geopolitical uncertainty, add further complexity.

Watt also pointed to the highly volatile price moves Lynas Rare Earths investors have weathered over the last year.

"The share price has been volatile. It rose from $6.89 on February 12, 2025 to $21.64 on October 15. LYC was trading at $15.92 on February 12, 2026," he said.

And, unlike many ASX 200 mining stocks, Lynas doesn't bring any passive income to the table.

"There's no dividend yield," Watt concluded.

What's been happening with the ASX 200 rare earths miner?

Lynas shares closed up 6.7% on 21 January after the company reported its second-quarter (Q2 FY 2026) update.

Investors were clearly pleased with the rare earth miner's $201.9 million gross sales revenue, up 43% from Q2 FY 2025.

Revenue got a big boost from the 74% year-on-year increase in the average selling price Lynas received across all its rare earths products over the three months. The average price was $85.60 per kilogram.

However, as Watt noted above, Lynas did encounter significant operational challenges over the quarter.

Lynas ran into power supply disruptions at its Western Australia-based Kalgoorlie plant in November. And operations were also hindered by planned kiln maintenance at the miner's Malaysian Kuantan facility.

This led to a 9% year-on-year decrease in total rare earth oxide (REO) production in Q2 FY 2026 to 2,382 tonnes. REO production was down a sharp 40% from the prior quarter.

Motley Fool contributor Bernd Struben has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has recommended Lynas Rare Earths Ltd. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Resources Shares

Mining vehicle at a mine site.
Resources Shares

Up 70% over the past year, why I think this ASX copper company is just getting started

There's plenty to like about the deal this company struck.

Read more »

a man wearing a hard hat and a high visibility vest stands with his arms crossed in front of heavy equipment at a mine site.
Broker Notes

BHP share price drops 13% to seven-month low in just 1 week. Do experts say buy?

Market analysts offer their advice as BHP shares plunge this week.

Read more »

Two workers working with a large copper coil in a factory.
Resources Shares

Why you might want to buy BHP shares before next week

Copper will be key to BHP's fortunes going forward.

Read more »

A woman sits on a step laughing at something on her mobile phone as it is being charged by a lithium-powered battery.
Resources Shares

This ASX lithium stock could soar 327% or more, brokers say

The most bullish experts think the shares could rise up to 505% over the next 12 months.

Read more »

Copper balls.
Resources Shares

Copper price falls to 6-month low, taking Rio Tinto and BHP shares with it

The copper price has become a barometer of investor confidence in the US AI investment boom.

Read more »

Woman and man worker in quarry on excavation machine looking at a clipboard.
Resources Shares

At $143, are Rio Tinto shares oversold or overpriced?

Find out where brokers expect the shares to travel next.

Read more »

a man in a business suit points his finger amid a digitised map of the globe suspended in the air in front of him, complete with graphs, digital code and glyphs to indicate digital assets.
Resources Shares

2 ASX shares tipped to grow up to 35% in the next 12 months

These stocks may have a very exciting future.

Read more »

Young businesswoman sitting in kitchen and working on laptop.
Resources Shares

Could the BHP share price return more than 10% in 2027?

The shares have already enjoyed a strong year, but I've been looking at whether investors could see more gains in…

Read more »