Battle of the online classifieds: Should I buy Car Group or Seek shares?

Brokers rate both shares highly.

As Aussie stocks continue to slide this week, job classifieds company Seek Ltd (ASX: SEK) shares are down 5% on Monday's session at the time of writing.

This brings losses for the year to 14%, with shares currently swapping hands at $19.25 apiece, a distant cry from the $26 levels in February.

With shares in the red, investors might be wondering whether to favour Seek or fellow classifieds company CAR Group Ltd (ASX: CAR) going forward.

Both companies have strong positions in their respective spaces, but do their prospects differ? Let's break it down and help you decide which might suit your portfolio.

A woman sits on sofa pondering a question.

Image source: Getty Images

Are Seek shares a buy?

Seek is an online employment marketplace. The jobs market is there to stay (there will always be job openings that expand and contract along with the business cycle). But does this mean Seek will be there in the future?

As my colleague James reported last month, Bell Potter initiated coverage on Seek shares with a buy rating and a price target of $27 apiece, implying a potential upside of 40% from current levels.

Bell says that Seek's $180 million investment to consolidate its ANZ and Asian marketplaces on the one platform could "facilitate 50% group EBITDA margins", a lift of 6.7 percentage points.

The broker also points out that the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA)'s likely interest rate cuts will "see ad volumes increase", a net positive for Seek shares.

The broker forecasts a 19% compound annual growth rate (CAGR) in Seek's profits from FY24 to FY28.

CAR Group, on the other hand, owns carsales.com.au, an online marketplace for buying and selling cars.

Analysts at Wilsons recently pointed out that CAR shares are trading at a discount compared to their five-year average valuation.

The firm reckons that CAR's "competitive positioning, its pricing power", and "its ongoing margin expansion" give it the edge in the online auto listings market.

CAR's global expansion strategy is another potential growth driver that provides a "long runway" to continue its growth offshore.

It projects CAR to grow profits by the "mid-teens" over "the medium/long-term".

Which is the better buy?

So, which stock should you consider, if any at all? Well, two broker ratings aren't enough to make that decision, that's for sure.

According to CommSec, the consensus of analyst estimates rates both CAR and Seek shares a buy.

Valuation-wise, Seek currently trades at more than 150x its last 12 months' earnings per share (EPS), with analysts projecting a 71% growth in profits by 2026.

Even adjusting for this growth, you're still paying $91 for a dollar of future profits to own Seek shares.

Contrast this to CAR, which sells at 45x trailing earnings, still very expensive on objective terms, which adjusts to 37x after growth estimates.

Valuation ratios aren't a predictive tool, but they can't be overlooked either. Investors should keep this in mind when weighing up both these names.

Seek shares takeaway

Both Seek and CAR have strong growth prospects, but their stories differ. Brokers say Seek is positioned to take advantage of a potential recovery in the jobs market, whereas RBA rate cuts could support car transactions for CAR's marketplace.

The consensus is that both are a buy, so as to which one – it depends on your own financial goals and circumstances.

But none of us have a crystal ball, which is why paying an appropriate valuation or an investment is paramount. That said, both Seek and CAR trade at lofty valuations as I write.

Motley Fool contributor Zach Bristow has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended CAR Group Ltd. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Broker Notes

Two male ASX investors and executives wearing dark coloured suits sit at a table holding their mobile phones discussing the highest trading ASX 200 shares today
Broker Notes

Buy, hold, sell: Resmed, Goodman Group, CBA shares

We review three fresh buy, hold, and sell calls from John Athanasiou at Red Leaf Securities.

Read more »

colleagues on a lunch break looking at iPhone
Broker Notes

Top brokers name 3 ASX shares to buy now

Here's what brokers are recommending as buys this week.

Read more »

Woman with her fingers crossed and eyes shut.
Broker Notes

7 ASX 200 shares in the buy zone as optimism returns to the market: experts

Brokers reaffirmed their buy calls on Liontown, Rio Tinto, Xero, and others this week.

Read more »

ASX shares broker ratings represented by three different coloured buttons.
Broker Notes

6 ASX shares upgraded and downgraded by the experts this week

Brokers have changed their ratings and 12-month price targets on Qantas, Codan, and others. 

Read more »

A woman sits in a cafe wearing a polka dotted shirt and holding a latte in one hand while reading something on a laptop that is sitting on the table in front of her
Broker Notes

Buy, hold, sell: CSL, NextDC, PLS shares

Mark Elzayed from Vestra Capital explains his ratings on three ASX 200 shares.

Read more »

Buy, hold, and sell ratings written on signs on a wooden pole.
Broker Notes

Eagers Automotive, REA Group, National Australia Bank: Buy, sell, or hold?

The leader of this pack might surprise.

Read more »

Man sitting in a plane seat works on his laptop.
Broker Notes

Qantas shares were just downgraded but I still rate them as a buy

I think the downgrade was wrong and see value in the airline's shares.

Read more »

Smiling miner.
Broker Notes

4 ASX mining shares with 90% to 155% upside ahead: experts

These ASX mining shares have outstanding price growth potential.

Read more »