2 'cheap' ASX 200 shares this contrarian investor is buying

Outperformance with limited downside. Where Allan Gray is investing to beat the market.

| More on:
Pictured is two gold fish bowls one with six goldfish and one with none and one goldfish is jumping from the full bowl to the empty bowl representing this ASX share breaking away from its peers

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Over the past year, the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) has produced a net total return of 4.4%. Not a terrible outcome without any further context. However, for a lot less risk, one can now generate the same return on cash at the bank.

The question then becomes, is a broad market index the place to be moving forward? Some investors think possibly not — despite paying a lower-than-normal multiple on market earnings — due to the risk of earnings declining from their historically high levels.

Instead, contrarian fund manager Allan Gray Australia is eyeing value in the unloved pockets of the share market.

A shot at asking for more

There are no free handouts in the investing arena. In most cases, there is a rather justifiable reason for shareholders to part ways with a stock. Contrarian investors go hunting in these waters, searching for companies that may be temporarily distressed, but not structurally broken.

Speaking at the Allan Gray Investment Forum in Brisbane last week, chief investment officer Simon Mawhinney revealed Downer EDI Ltd (ASX: DOW) as one such business his team has identified.

The ASX 200 company provides an array of important services across Australia and New Zealand, categorised into three segments: transport, utilities, and facilities.

Despite the critical nature of Downer's services and the company's market leadership, it has long accepted egregiously low margins. It is this issue that Mawhinney and the team are optimistic Downer can change.

Source: Downer Investor Day Presentation

In February, Downer's management revealed ambitions of delivering EBITA margins of more than 4.5% in FY25, as shown above. For context, the figure came in at 2.5% in the latest half-year results.

If the company can deliver on this target, the valuation begins to look 'cheap', as Mawhinney highlighted. The ASX 200 share would trade at around eight times EBITA based on its current enterprise value of around $4 billion — far cheaper than the 17 or 18 times market average.

Meanwhile, the downside risk is Downer maintains current unsatisfactory margins and continues to trade in line with the broader market. Hence, the fund manager is of the mind this business represents an opportunity with an asymmetric skew to the upside.

Are better returns ahead for this ASX 200 share?

Testing the faith of its shareholders, Lendlease Group (ASX: LLC) shares have sunk 25.6% in the last 12 months.

The company's margins have been under pressure since the onset of the pandemic, dispersing any inkling of optimism among many. Though, the Allan Gray team is looking beyond the near term to hold a contrarian view on this real estate heavyweight.

Now holding a 3% weighting in the Allan Gray Australia Equity Fund, the team sees value in Lendlease if it can make progress on its own targets across its construction, development, and investment segments.

In his presentation, Mawhinney called out Lendlease's ambitions of improving its return on invested capital (ROIC) — 10% to 13% for developments and 6% to 9% for investments. Likewise, the company is targeting a 2% to 3% EBITDA margin for construction. This would all equate to an 8% to 10% margin in aggregate.

For comparison, the company's historical ROIC and EBITDA margin are shown below.

Source: Lendlease Group 2023 Half Year Financial and Operational Metrics

If Lendlease can reach its own targets, the business "would be trading at 8 to 10 times earnings", Mawhinney stated. Elaborating on the Lendlease opportunity, the investor said:

Not bad, if not very, very cheap, if management is correct and they haven't overpromised. The likelihood is that they have overpromised and it's not as cheap as that, but there's a very large margin of safety implicit in Lendlease's price today.

That margin of safety Mawhinney mentions is likely pertaining to the current price-to-book (P/B) ratio of this ASX 200 share.

Lendlease Price-to-Book Ratio since 2003. Data by Trading View.

Investors can grab Lendlease shares for less than their book value at the moment. That's an event that has occurred only a few times since 2003, as pictured above.

Motley Fool contributor Mitchell Lawler has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Value Investing

a man with a wide, eager smile on his face holds up three fingers.
Value Investing

3 Australian value stocks to buy right now

I think these stocks are capable of beating the market.

Read more »

An ASX investor relaxes on her couch as the Harvey Norman share price drops due to the shares trading ex-dividend from today.

Cheap and growing: The best bang for buck ASX shares I'd buy

Three companies that I believe are outstanding quality despite being thrown in the discount bucket.

Read more »

Value spelt out in orange on wooden blocks on top of each other.
Dividend Investing

7% and 6% dividend yields! 2 ASX value shares on my buy list

A number of quality ASX value stocks have faced recent headwinds as cost of living pressures begin to bite.

Read more »

a young boy dressed up in a business suit and tie has a cute grin and holds two fingers up.
Value Investing

2 ASX All Ords shares to buy delivering 'exceptional cash flows': fund manager

These stocks could be solid picks and pay big income too.

Read more »

Two happy shoppers finding bargains amongst clothes on a store rack
Value Investing

2 ASX 200 value stocks I'd have loved to buy in the August mini-crash

Here are two ASX value stocks that got mighty cheap during August.

Read more »

Value spelt out with a magnifying glass.
Value Investing

Here's how I'd invest $2,000 in ASX value shares right now

I’m going to talk about three different ideas that could be great value.

Read more »

A woman holds up hands to compare two things with question marks above her hands.
Value Investing

Did ASX value shares or growth shares do better in FY23?

Which was the better bet in FY23?

Read more »

Value spelt out in orange on wooden blocks on top of each other.
Value Investing

Should I buy ASX value stocks right now?

It could be time to shine for the cheap end of the share market.

Read more »