Better buy: Telstra shares or TPG?

Which of these would be a better telco stock to call on for returns?

| More on:
A woman holds up hands to compare two things with question marks above her hands.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points

  • Telstra and TPG both offer an essential service, which could mean defensive earnings
  • On an earnings multiple and dividend yield basis, Telstra appears to be the better choice
  • Telstra has such a strong regional network, that TPG wanted to use it as well

The ASX telco share sector could be a source of defensive returns because of the essential nature of the internet for households and businesses. ASX investors have two main choices to choose from – Telstra Group Ltd (ASX: TLS) shares and TPG Telecom Ltd (ASX: TPG) shares.

I'm going to compare a couple of the main statistics for each of these businesses, and then talk about the main reason why I'd pick one over the other.

Valuation

The price/earnings (P/E) ratio is not exactly a perfect measure of which business is better.

A company's profit can be massaged to make it look better, for example by spreading out research, development and asset depreciation costs over multiple years.

Alternatively, investing for growth, which is good for the long term, can hurt profit in the short term.

But, comparing profit valuations is probably as good as any metric to look at.

FY23 may be a period of adjustment for a number of businesses and sectors with the changes in the economy and interest rates. So, we'll look at the projections on Commsec for FY24 and FY25.

The TPG share price is valued at 32 times FY24's estimated earnings and 24 times FY25's estimated earnings.

Looking at the Telstra share price, it's valued at 24 times FY24's estimated earnings and 21 times FY25's estimated earnings.

Purely on a P/E ratio comparison, Telstra shares look better valued.

Dividend yield

Dividends can be a key way for investors to generate cash returns if they don't want to sell their shares and lock in capital gains.

Looking at the Telstra grossed-up dividend yield projections, it could be 5.9% in FY24 and 6.25% in FY25.

In FY24, TPG could pay a grossed-up dividend yield of 5.1% and 5.4% in FY25.

Both of the ASX telco shares are projected to grow their payouts over the next two years, but Telstra is seemingly going to pay a stronger yield in both years.

While the dividend isn't everything, it could mean that Telstra shares are more rewarding in terms of cash hitting the bank account over the next two years.

Which ASX telco share is better?

The Australian Financial Review recently reported on the latest commentary from the broker Morgan Stanley on the two businesses.

The broker currently has a buy rating on Telstra, with a price target of $4.75. That implies a potential rise of around 10%. A price target is where the broker thinks the share price will be in 12 months.

It said there is "a shift in wallet share from large telcos to software vendors is a potentially small headwind for Telstra but not strong enough to change its profit forecasts or share price valuation."

However, for TPG, the Morgan Stanley price target is $5.60, which is only slightly higher than where it is today. It suggested there could be "margin pressure and fixed-line enterprise headwinds for TPG as a result of new cloud technologies."

For me, the biggest thing that Telstra has going for it is the sizeable advantage it has with its network in both metropolitan and regional areas. It's a key selling point for potential customers. TPG seemed to think Telstra had such a strong network that it wanted to utilise Telstra's regional spectrum – while that agreement is currently blocked on competition fears, it's likely a sign of how a rival views Telstra's power.

Being the number one telco player in the market enables Telstra to increase prices (and profitability), which could bode well for future shareholder returns.

Motley Fool contributor Tristan Harrison has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Telstra Group. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Tpg Telecom. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Communication Shares

Two male ASX investors and executives wearing dark coloured suits sit at a table holding their mobile phones discussing the highest trading ASX 200 shares today
Communication Shares

Why 7% of this fundie's portfolio is invested in Telstra shares

Telstra is an important stock for this fund.

Read more »

A woman shows her phone screen and points up.
Communication Shares

Can the Telstra share price keep outperforming until next year?

Is this telco able to keep delivering for investors?

Read more »

A happy woman stands outside a building looking at her phone and smiling widely
Earnings Results

This ASX telco stock is jumping 15% (hint: it's not Telstra)

A strong result is getting investors excited on Tuesday.

Read more »

A man and a woman stand on an external balcony in a dense city environment filled with high rise buildings and commercial properties. The man is pointing up at a high rise building and the woman is looking on.
Real Estate Shares

Here's 1 ASX 200 share that could soar in the next bull market

Brokers like the tailwinds behind this company.

Read more »

A smartly-dressed businesswoman walks outside while making a trade on her mobile phone.
Communication Shares

$10,000 invested in Telstra shares 4 months ago is now worth…

Was it a good idea to invest in the telco giant in May?

Read more »

Businessman walks through exit door signalling resignation
Communication Shares

Guess which ASX 200 stock is tanking on its CEO exit

ASX 200 investors are hitting the sell button as this leading media company looks for a new top dog.

Read more »

man looks at phone while disappointed
Communication Shares

TPG share price higher on $1.2b Optus deal approval

This telco is heading into regional areas with this deal.

Read more »

A woman standing in a blue shirt smiles as she uses her mobile phone to text message someone
Communication Shares

Buy one, sell the other: TPG vs Telstra shares

A leading broker gives its verdict on these telco giants.

Read more »