Index killer? Here’s how AFIC (ASX:AFI) shares stack up to the ASX 200

How does AFIC measure up to the ASX 200?

| More on:
Woman holds up hands to compare two things with question marks above her hands

Image source: Getty Images

Much has been made of the rise of the exchange-traded fund (ETF) over 2021 thus far. Especially since this year has seen the ASX ETF sector swell to a record size in terms of funds under management (FUM). But it wasn’t that long ago that there was no such thing as an ASX ETF. Yes, the first ASX ETF only launched in 2001. So what did investors who wanted broad, diversified market exposure do before that? Well, one solution was investing in Listed Investment Companies (LICs) like the Australian Foundation Investment Co. Ltd (ASX: AFI).

ETFs and LICs

LICs were about the closest thing to an ETF you could get before there were actual ETFs. A LIC is a company and not a trust, as an ETF is. But it still invests in other underlying shares for the benefit of its shareholders, as an ETF does. AFIC is one of the oldest LICs on the ASX, having first opened its doors way back in 1928, a good ten years or so before the onset of the Second World War.

But nowadays, investors wanting broad diversification in a single company or fund are spoilt for choice. And many investors would rather just own the market and get the market’s return through an ETF rather than trying their luck with a LIC.

But is this attitude a good one to have? Let’s check out how AFIC shares have performed against the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) over the past 6 months. We’ll use the iShares Core S&P/ASX 200 ETF (ASX: IOZ) as a benchmark, since it is the most popular ASX ETF covering the ASX 200 Index.

So IOZ units have returned approximately 3.28% over the past 6 months, including dividend distributions. How does AFIC compare?

Well, the AFIC share price alone is up 8.95% over the same period, including the 1.2% jump we see today. Including the 14 cents per share final dividend investors received in August, and we get a return of more than 10%.

So AFIC has clearly trounced the ASX 200 over the past 6 months.

How do AFIC shares measure up to the ASX 200?

But let’s zoom out. Over the past year, the ASX 200 ETF has returned roughly 15.36%, including dividend distributions. AFIC, in contrast, has delivered a 19.5% return over the same period, also including dividends.

Over five years, IOZ units have averaged an annual return of 9.96%. AFIC again bests it with a 13.8% average.

So how has AFIC managed to outperform its own index so consistently? Well, by not holding the same shares in the same proportions as the index. For example, AFIC tells us that its top 5 holdings as of 30 November were:

  1. Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA) with an 8% portfolio weighting
  2. CSL Limited (ASX: CLS) with a 7.3% weighting
  3. BHP Group Ltd (ASX: BHP) with a 6% weighting
  4. Macquarie Group Ltd (ASX: MQG) with a 4.7% weighting
  5. Wesfarmers Ltd (ASX: WES) with a 4.6% weighting

In contrast, here are the current top five holdings and their weightings in the ASX 200:

  1. Commonwealth Bank with an 8.05% weighting
  2. CSL with a 6.2% weighting
  3. BHP with a 5.83% weighting
  4. National Australia Bank Ltd. (ASX: NAB) with a 4.47% weighting
  5. Westpac Banking Corp (ASX: WBC) with a 3.66% weighting

So as you can see, these two portfolios do differ quite significantly, with AFIC clearly giving the big four ASX 200 bank shares a wider berth than the index itself.

This differentiation from the index has evidently worked in AFIC favour over the last few years. But who knows what the next few hold.

At the current AFIC share price of $8.41, this ASX LIC has a market capitalisation of $10.31 billion, with a dividend yield of 2.85%.

Should you invest $1,000 in AFIC right now?

Before you consider AFIC, you'll want to hear this.

Motley Fool Investing expert Scott Phillips just revealed what he believes are the 5 best stocks for investors to buy right now... and AFIC wasn't one of them.

The online investing service he’s run for over a decade, Motley Fool Share Advisor, has provided thousands of paying members with stock picks that have doubled, tripled or even more.* And right now, Scott thinks there are 5 stocks that are better buys.

*Returns as of January 13th 2022

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen owns National Australia Bank Limited. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. owns and has recommended CSL Ltd. The Motley Fool Australia owns and has recommended Wesfarmers Limited. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Macquarie Group Limited and Westpac Banking Corporation. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Financial Shares

A man wearing glasses and a purple vest holds his hand to his chin and wonders why the Pendal share price is falling today
Financial Shares

Why was the Pendal share price in freefall on Thursday?

Pendal shares went ex-dividend today and investors will receive their interim payment on 1 July.

Read more »

A businesswoman in a suit and holding a briefcase marches higher as she steps from one stack of coins to the next.
Financial Shares

Why is the Magellan share price marching higher today?

Magellan launched Barrenjoey in September 2020. Barclays invested $45 million in the start-up at the time.

Read more »

A man reacts with surprise when her see a bargain price on his phone
Financial Shares

2 ASX shares with prices ‘far too low’ right now: Forager

Prominent fund explores why this pair of finance stocks will perform well and how 'the fear is overdone'.

Read more »

Young boy with glasses in a suit sits at a chair and reads a newspaper.
Financial Shares

What was the highest ever AMP share price?

AMP shares have been an infamous ASX performer in recent years. We take a look back through time.

Read more »

child in superman outfit pointing skyward, indicating a rising share price
Financial Shares

Why is the Magellan share price up 7% today?

Magellan shares are rocketing today, but why?

Read more »

A woman sits at her computer in deep contemplation with her hand to her chin and seriously considering information she is receiving from the screen of her laptop regarding the Xero share price
Broker Notes

Why does this broker see another 33% upside in the QBE share price?

The insurer looks set to deliver considerable upside, according to more than one broker.

Read more »

Rising arrow on a blue graph symbolising a rising share price.
Financial Shares

This ASX All Ordinaries share just leapt 7% on a $15 million share buyback

Money3 is returning value to shareholders.

Read more »

A woman researcher holds a finger up in happiness as if making the 'number one' sign with a graphic of technological data and an orb emanating from her finger while fellow researchers work in the background.
Financial Shares

Strategic Elements share price rockets 60% on ‘breakthrough’ news

What's causing this share to surge so high today?

Read more »