To sell or not to sell? 3 brokers weigh in on Webjet (ASX: WEB) shares

Travel will return eventually, but is Webjet's valuation too high already? Here's what three brokers think.

Webjet Limited (ASX: WEB) shares are polarising investors at the moment.

As a leader in the online booking field, it feels like it will be a beneficiary of the post-COVID resurgence in travel.

However, it has had to raise capital multiple times since the pandemic struck just to stay alive. And in recent times, it has regularly featured at the top of the league table of most shorted stocks on the ASX.

This year Webjet shares started the year at $5.14 then rose to as high as $6.24. Now they have sunk down to $4.99 at the time of writing.

So if you were fortunate enough to buy this stock during the depths of coronavirus despair last year, do you take your winnings and run?

Three fund managers offered their take:

A traveller dressed in colourful shirt and panama hat looking puzzled, indicating uncertainty regarding the Webjet share price

Image source: Getty Images

The case to sell Webjet shares

Sage Capital chief investment officer Sean Fenton reckons Webjet shares have had a good pandemic recovery run, and investors should cash in now.

"You might look at a share price chart and think 'wow, it's still cheap'. But they've done at least two,… maybe even three, equity issues in the last 12 months. Due to that, their market cap is now greater than it was pre-COVID," he told a Livewire video.

Despite the rollout of vaccines and more freedoms for travel, there are still too many immediate hurdles for the company.

"It's not necessarily the end of the pain in terms of generating cash flow for the business. For me, the value is not there for a company with so much uncertainty and earnings risk."

The case to not sell Webjet shares

Perpetual portfolio manager Anthony Aboud would hold onto Webjet.

He thinks it's "dangerous" to sell at the moment due to almost 10% of its stocks being shorted.

"With a big short interest like that, it can be dangerous to be short here," said Aboud. 

"One thing working in their favour is that this is one of the companies people go to for exposure in the reopening trade. But I do agree with Sean. It has a higher enterprise value now than pre-COVID and I'm not 100% sure that the outlook is better."

The case to buy Webjet shares

Not everyone is pessimistic about Webjet.

The Motley Fool reported last month that Ord Minnett brokers retained their buy rating for the online travel agency. The price target was even raised to $7.15, which would be a more than 40% gain from the current level.

"The broker believes the company is well-positioned financially to strengthen its competitive position in the B2B segment," wrote my colleague James Mickleboro.

"This is due to a number of its competitors struggling financially during the pandemic."

Motley Fool contributor Tony Yoo owns shares of Webjet Ltd. The Motley Fool Australia owns shares of and has recommended Webjet Ltd. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Travel Shares

Airplane in the sky.
Travel Shares

Up 19% in a week: Why is everyone suddenly buying Virgin Australia shares?

Investors are rushing to snap up this ASX travel stock.

Read more »

Man using his device in an airport.
Travel Shares

Qantas shares down on update: Should I buy the dip?

Let's see if Australia's flag-carrier airline is in the buy zone.

Read more »

Front view of aircraft in flight.
Travel Shares

At $8.70: Are Qantas shares a bargain buy, or a risky investment?

Is the airline stock a buy, sell, or hold now?

Read more »

View of an airport.
Travel Shares

Are Qantas shares worth buying in October?

I look beyond the higher fuel bill to see whether Qantas still stacks up as a long-term investment.

Read more »

Smiling woman taking a video through a plane window with her phone.
Travel Shares

If I invest $5,000 in Flight Centre shares, what passive income could I earn in FY27?

Find out what passive income you could generate off Flight Centre shares.

Read more »

Sell written several times on board.
Broker Notes

Sell alert! Expert calls time on Corporate Travel and CBA shares

A leading expert expects CBA and Corporate Travel shares to face significant headwinds.

Read more »

Smiling woman taking a video through a plane window with her phone.
Travel Shares

Qantas Airways vs Flight Centre: Which ASX travel stock is the better buy today?

I compare Qantas and Flight Centre on dividends, value, size, and performance to decide which ASX travel stock looks better…

Read more »

Woman looking through an airplane window while holding a book.
Travel Shares

Which ASX travel stock does Morgans tip to jump 60%?

A new acquisition could be a boost for this company.

Read more »