Value vs growth shares: which will win?

Inflation is the big worry at the moment. Will it be here chronically to whack growth shares for years to come?

| More on:
A set of scales with a bag of money balanced against a timer, indicating growth versus value shares

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

The last few weeks has seen the ASX and US markets crucifying growth stocks in favour of value shares.

The S&P ASX All Technology Index (ASX: XTX) has lost more than 14% since its 10 February high, while the Nasdaq Composite (NASDAQ: .IXIC) has dropped 7% in a month – even after a slight bounce back this week.

The big theme driving this growth anxiety is the prospect of inflation, and its potential to raise interest rates.

"There are plenty of inflationists who have been forecasting an apocalypse for a dozen years. They are about to have their day in the sun," said Nucleus Wealth head of investments Damien Klassen.

"And you can bet they will be appearing in financial media to proclaim vindication."

Pre-COVID deflationary forces are still there

Klassen, posting on a Nucleus blog, posited that all the forces that suppressed inflation for 10 years before COVID-19 have not disappeared.

Those include:

  • Technological advances driving prices lower
  • Globalisation leading to competitive pricing
  • High levels of debt, leading to constrained spending
  • Increasing inequality, leading to higher income-earners saving more instead of spending
  • Culturally low expectations of inflation, leading to less aggressive requests for pay rises
  • Elevated unemployment driving low wage growth

As opposed to these deflationary forces, the drivers that will trigger inflation are all temporary phenomena caused by a one-off pandemic.

They include supply chain disruptions, structural consumption changes, supply chain changes, inventory rebuild, government stimulus and a lower US dollar.

Inflation could go one of two ways

Klassen proposed that one of two scenarios could play out.

The first path was if inflationary forces beat the deflationary ones.

"Inflation gets the upper hand, bond yields rise, and value stocks perform well. Growth stocks fall, quality stocks underperform," he said.

The second option was if those pre-COVID deflationary forces reasserted themselves.

"Deflation/disinflation resumes after a short inflationary shock," Klassen said.

"Bond yields fall, bond prices rise. Defensive stocks outperform, as does quality. Value stocks and financials underperform. Growth stocks are more complicated."

Which is the more likely scenario? Klassen predicted the first scenario would occur, then transition into the second.

"Without stimulus, we will be back to the second scenario tomorrow," he said.

"With the current stimulus, I'm thinking 6 to 12 months."

Don't sell your growth shares in a panic

Klassen's forecast that deflation would eventually retake the mantle from inflation matches with what other experts have said this week.

The investment committee for T Rowe Price Group Inc (NASDAQ: TROW)'s Australian operations is already pivoting from value shares to growth.

"Central banks made it pretty clear that they want low yields to be maintained. For this reason, we are sceptical about the ability for interest rates to derail the recovery," it reported.

"Recent actions taken by the Reserve Bank of Australia to buy government bonds to bring down long-term interest rates are a strong indication that monetary policy will remain accommodative."

Chief executive of UK's DeVere Group, Nigel Green, warned investors to not overdo the rotation out of growth into value.

"The danger is the massive hype surrounding rotation from growth stocks – those expected to grow sales and earnings at a faster rate than the market average – into value stocks," he said.

"It should not be a case of either value or growth stocks.  A properly diversified portfolio needs to have both."

Motley Fool contributor Tony Yoo has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on How to invest

Calculator and gold bars on Australian dollars, symbolising dividends.
How to invest

How to turn your savings account into a gold mine starting with $10,000

Here's why shares could be superior to savings accounts.

Read more »

A young well-dressed couple at a luxury resort celebrate successful life choices.
How to invest

3 winning tips both Warren Buffett and Peter Lynch recommend

Let's learn from investing gurus of our time.

Read more »

A young well-dressed couple at a luxury resort celebrate successful life choices.
Share Market News

With nothing in my savings account, I'd use Warren Buffett's golden rule to build wealth

Here's how you could grow your wealth by following the Oracle of Omaha's golden rule.

Read more »

three businessmen high five each other outside an office building with graphic images of graphs and metrics superimposed on the shot.
How to invest

3 pieces of investment advice from Peter Lynch

Want to invest like a pro? Here are three valuable lessons from legendary American investor Peter Lynch.

Read more »

Invest written on a notepad with Australian dollar notes and piggybank.
How to invest

3 lower-risk ASX shares for beginner investors

I would happily recommend these three shares to a beginner today.

Read more »

A grey-haired mature-aged man with glasses stands in front of a blackboard filled with mathematical workings as he holds a pad of paper in one hand and a pen in the other and stands smiling at the camera.
How to invest

3 lessons my seven-bagger ASX 200 stock has taught me

Three valuable lessons from investing in one of the highest-quality companies on the ASX.

Read more »

a small boy dressed in a bow tie and britches looks up from a pile of books with a book laid in front of him on a desk and an abacus on the other side, as though he is an accountant scouring books of figures.
Value Investing

3 ASX shares trading below their book values

Looking for undervalued stocks? Price-to-book values may be your guide.

Read more »

A man wearing only boardshorts stretches back on a deck chair with his arms behind his head and a hat pulled down over his face amid an idyllic beach background.
How to invest

How to earn $1,900 in passive income with just $10,000 in savings

I think the ASX offers some world beating opportunities for passive income investors.

Read more »