Better buy today: Coles or Woolworths shares?

Is Coles Group Ltd (ASX: COL) or Woolworths Group Ltd (ASX: WOW) a better buy today? Let's look at dividends, P/E ratios and more to see how these 2 supermarket giants compare.

| More on:
Woman in striped long sleeved top holds both hands up and looks to one side signifying a comparison between two ASX shares

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Both Coles Group Ltd (ASX: COL) shares and Woolworths Group Ltd (ASX: WOW) shares have been something of a beacon of stability in 2020 so far. With the coronavirus pandemic upending the world this year, it has been a strange and often scary period in which to invest in ASX shares.

Both Coles and Woolworths are consumer staples giants, with customers flocking to the supermarkets like never before in the first few months of the pandemic. This has lead to ASX investors treating both supermarket chains like islands of capital stability in an ocean of uncertainty.

And fair enough too. Both Coles and Woolworths are among the ever-shrinking pool of ASX 50 companies that are unlikely to cut their dividend payments to shareholders in 2020 and beyond for one. Their defensive, consumer staples nature for another is almost certain to keep the companies healthy and profitable under any future circumstances, whatever they may be. We all need to eat and buy household essentials after all. 

But which of these 2 Australian icons is the better buy today? Well, that's what we'll be trying to answer.

An age-old question: Coles or Woolies?

Unlike Coles or Woolies shoppers, who might tend to choose whichever supermarket is closest, we as investors can take a holistic view of these companies. So, let's start with some statistics (always fun).

On market capitalisation, Woolworths is the biggest player in the game – $49.27 billion on current prices, compared to Coles' $24.24 billion. This does reflect Woolworths' ownership of the Big W discount chain, as well as the ALH Hotels Group and the Endeavour Drinks business (which includes the bottle shop chains Dan Murphy's and BWS). In contrast, Coles is more of a one-trick pony, owning just the Coles network of stores, as well as some bottle shop chains of its own (including First Choice Liquor and Liquorland).

But Woolworths still has a larger presence in the overall grocery market. According to a recent Roy Morgan report, Woolworths maintained a 32.9% share of the market over the course of last year, which compares favourably with the 26.6% share of the grocery market Coles commanded. According to the report, this was a 0.7% drop for Woolworths over the previous year and a 1.4% drop for Coles.

What about the Coles and Woolworths share prices?

At the time of writing, Woolworths is trading for $39.01 and Coles for $18.17. Incidentally, the latter is just a touch off Coles' all-time high of $18.32 that the company recently reset.

These share prices give Woolworths a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 19.42 and a trailing dividend yield of 2.64%. In contrast, Coles is currently trading on a P/E ratio of 20.46 and offers a trailing dividend yield of 2.31%.

So here we can see the market is pricing Coles at a slight premium to Woolies today.

Foolish takeaway

I would say neither Coles nor Woolies is a screaming bargain today. Investors have clearly kept up both companies' share prices, probably to reflect a 'stability' premium they now offer in this uncertain world.

If I had to choose one company, I think I would go with Woolworths. It's currently offering a greater market share than Coles, has a cheaper price (relative to earnings) and a higher starting dividend yield. It's also a more diversified company. As such, I think Woolies wins the supermarket wars, for today at least.

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia owns shares of COLESGROUP DEF SET and Woolworths Limited. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on ⏸️ Dividend Shares

falling healthcare asx share price Mesoblast capital raising
⏸️ Dividend Shares

Sonic Healthcare (ASX:SHL) dividend rises 7%, share price falls after FY21 results

Triple digit profit growth and a solid dividend was not enough to impress investors on Monday.

Read more »

A smiling woman with a handful of $100 notes, indicating strong dividend payments
⏸️ Dividend Shares

The Adairs (ASX:ADH) dividend more than doubled in FY21

A record financial result will see a generous dividend paid out to Adairs shareholders.

Read more »

A businessman on a road raises his arms as dollar notes rain down on him.
⏸️ Dividend Shares

The Newcrest (ASX:NCM) dividend boosted 129%

Newcrest marks its sixth successive year of increasing dividend payments to shareholders

Read more »

Happy couple laughing while shopping in supermarket
52-Week Highs

August has been a great month so far for the Woolworths (ASX:WOW) share price

We take a look at how shares in the supermarket giant have been performing ahead of the company's full-year results

Read more »

wine glass full of coins
⏸️ Dividend Shares

The Treasury Wines (ASX:TWE) dividend bumped up by 60%

Here's how Treasury Wines dividends for FY21 have stacked up.

Read more »

Young boy cries and covers eyes with torn money on table
⏸️ Dividend Shares

The Origin (ASX:ORG) dividend has dropped 20%

What's happened to Origin's dividends?

Read more »

two people hold a sheet above their head while making a bed in a room featuring homewares.
Retail Shares

How did the Adairs (ASX:ADH) share price respond last earnings season?

The homewares retailer will be looking for another year like last year when it releases its FY21 earnings tomorrow.

Read more »

Two men excited to win online bet
Share Market News

Why the Tabcorp (ASX:TAH) dividend was boosted by 32%

The strong performance of Tabcorp's business will see a combined FY21 dividend of 14.5 cents.

Read more »