Looking at the WAM Capital Ltd (ASX: WAM) share price today, it's likely that one particular metric might jump out at you. That would be this listed investment company (LIC)'s dividend yield. At the time of writing, WAM Capital shares are going for $1.69 each. At this pricing, WAM Capital is trading with a trailing dividend yield of 9.17%.
Let that sink in for a moment. We have a stock that is ostensibly offering to return $9 a year in cash flow for every $100 invested. That's almost twice what you could expect from a savings account or term deposit right now. And more than twice what other popular dividend stocks, ranging from Coles Group Ltd (ASX: COL) to Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA) and Telstra Group Ltd (ASX: TLS), currently have on the table.
So, does that 9% yield make WAM Capital shares a screaming buy for income-hungry investors, or investors more generally?
Well, as you might suspect, the answer is definitely not an unambiguous 'yes'. Whenever the market is offering a stock with a 9% yield, one should always exercise a high degree of caution. After all, if that kind of yield was a sure thing, investors would flock to its shares, pushing up the price and lowering the running yield.
That is clearly not happening with WAM Capital, so we must ask ourselves why.
Image source: Getty Images
Does a 9% yield make WAM Capital shares a screaming buy?
Well, our first red flag is the WAM Capital share price itself. This is not what one might call a high flyer. At the current share price, this LIC has lost more than 24% of its value over the past five years. In fact, investors who bought WAM Capital shares ten years ago would also be down by about 25% from their initial investment.
This indicates to us that WAM Capital pays out all of its profits, and then some, as dividends.
WAM Capital's dividends also look to be on shaky ground. Over 2025, this company paid an annual dividend of 15.5 cents per share. As of the company's most recent update, it appears that WAM Capital has only 21.1 cents per share in its 'profit reserve', which it uses to fund its dividends. That means WAM Capital can only afford another 12-18 months of payouts if this reserve isn't topped up.
So, it seems the market has weighed up all this and decided there is a high risk of lower dividends from WAM Capital going forward. This company could well be a reliable source of dividend income for investors who buy today. But given the company's poor share price performance over many years and its near-empty profit reserves, investors should at least consider the not-insignificant risks of this stock.
