Sell Pilbara Minerals and buy Liontown shares: Bell Potter

Bell Potter thinks investors should be buying one lithium stock over the other.

Key points
  • Bell Potter suggests that recent industry developments make Liontown Resources a more attractive buy, especially due to its complete interest in Kathleen Valley and advantageous market positioning following the Mineral Resources-POSCO deal.
  • Despite positive sector sentiment spurred by the same deal, Bell Potter maintains a sell rating on Pilbara Minerals, citing its current premium as excessive and highlighting potential overvaluation based on current lithium price indices.
  • The broker believes that Liontown Resources could provide better value and growth potential for investors looking to capitalise on the lithium market.

Are you wanting to gain exposure to lithium for your investment portfolio?

If you are, it could pay to listen to what analysts at Bell Potter are saying about two popular ASX lithium stocks. Here's what you need to know:

A financial expert or broker looks worried as he checks out a graph showing market volatility.

Image source: Getty Images

Liontown Resources Ltd (ASX: LTR)

Bell Potter thinks investors should be buying Liontown shares following a big industry announcement. This morning, the broker has reaffirmed its buy rating on its shares with an improved price target of $1.52 (from $1.30). This implies potential upside of 15% for investors from current levels.

In response to a deal between Mineral Resources Ltd (ASX: MIN) and POSCO, the broker said:

The deal is clearly positive for lithium sector sentiment, with an existing lithium player looking to secure upstream supply. POSCO already holds an extensive portfolio of assets and agreements in the upstream and midstream lithium sector, including South American brines, spodumene concentrate offtake and conversion; the group has now entered a hard rock mining JV.

Analysis of deal multiples should consider: the relatively low level of control (POSCO is acquiring a minority interest in a JV, which holds a JV share in the underlying assets); the offtake agreement; and MIN's sell-down motivations. The implications for LTR are positive in terms of sentiment and value; LTR should trade on a premium to this deal given its 100% interest in Kathleen Valley (control), available offtake, and strengthened balance sheet.

Pilbara Minerals Ltd (ASX: PLS)

While the Mineral Resources-POSCO deal is a positive for the sector, it isn't enough for Bell Potter to change its view on Pilbara Minerals. It continues to rate the lithium miner as a sell with a $2.65 price target on its shares, which implies potential downside of 23%.

This is largely due to its belief that Pilbara Minerals shares are overvalued. It said:

We recognise PLS should trade on a premium to this deal given its 100% interest in Pilgangoora, growth optionality and strong balance sheet. However, we view the current premium to the deal multiples as excessive.

We maintain our Sell recommendation. We hold a positive long term lithium market outlook and recognise PLS' market leading position and growth optionality. However, we believe PLS' current market valuation implies an SC6 index price of around US$1,500/t into perpetuity, compared with the current price of around US$1,030/t.

Overall, the broker sees Liontown Resources shares as a better pick for investors that are looking for lithium exposure right now.

Motley Fool contributor James Mickleboro has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Materials Shares

Female miner in hard hat and safety vest on laptop with mining drill in background.
Materials Shares

Why are Lynas Rare Earths shares crashing 6% today?

Are Lynas Rare Earths shares a buy, sell, or hold now?

Read more »

Businessman planning and analysing investment data.
Materials Shares

Forget PLS, this ASX lithium stock could rise 80%

Is this lithium miner about to roar higher? Here's what Bell Potter is predicting.

Read more »

Couple using their digital tablet together.
Materials Shares

Orica updates on North American supply and land sales

Orica secures key North American supply and updates on land sales, supporting future growth and shareholder value.

Read more »

Man analysing data on his laptop.
Materials Shares

Forget BHP and buy this ASX copper stock

Bell Potter thinks there could be big returns on offer from this stock.

Read more »

A brightly coloured graphic with a silver square showing the abbreviation Li and the word Lithium to represent lithium ASX shares such as Core Lithium with small coloured battery graphics surrounding
Materials Shares

Why are Core Lithium shares crashing 8% on Thursday?

A busy morning of announcements has investors taking notice.

Read more »

a man clasps his hand to his forehead as he looks down at his phone and grimaces with a pained expression on his face as he watches the Pilbara Minerals share price continue to fall
Materials Shares

PLS shares have surged 85% in a year. So why are short sellers circling?

Could the bears be getting ahead of themselves?

Read more »

Senior farmer in overalls standing beside flood area on field.
Materials Shares

Why is this ASX share crashing 8% on Wednesday?

A positive earnings outlook hasn't stopped the selling.

Read more »

A man and woman sit next to each other looking at each other and feeling excited and surprised after reading good news about their shares on a laptop.
Materials Shares

3 reasons to buy BHP shares for 2027

I take a closer look at what could keep this mining giant growing well beyond 2027.

Read more »