Is it better to buy Bitcoin directly, or use Bitcoin ETFs?

Owning Bitcoin has never been easier on the ASX.

| More on:

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points
  • Bitcoin has experienced significant growth, increasing 91.6% over the past year, although it remains slightly below its all-time high.
  • Investors have the option to buy Bitcoin directly or through Bitcoin ETFs, each with distinct advantages and disadvantages.
  • Direct ownership offers control and flexibility but carries risks like theft and high transaction costs, while ETFs provide safety and lower costs at the expense of direct asset control.

There's no doubt that owning Bitcoin (CRYPTO: BTC) has been a spectacular investment over the past few years.

Sure, the cryptocurrency is infamously volatile and has had more than a few ups and downs over its history. But with Bitcoin up a stunning 91.6% over just the past 12 months, anyone who has owned this digital token for more than a few months would be very happy right now. That's despite the fact that the cryptocurrency, at ~US$115,300 per coin today, is still more than 6.5% down from the all-time high of over US$123,000 that we saw last month.

Thanks to these monstrous gains, many ASX investors might be looking to add ot their Bitcoin exposure right now.

However, anyone wishing to buy Bitcoin or other major cryptocurrencies has plenty of avenues to explore today.

There's always the option to buy Bitcoin directly from the numerous cryptocurrency exchanges that facilitate the direct buying or selling of cryptocurrencies. Many investors prefer this path as it allows individuals to own the digital assets directly.

However, owning cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin directly does have a few pitfalls. That's why many investors prefer to opt for the increasingly popular Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that are now available. Bitcoin and other cryptocurrency ETFs only became available in the last few years following regulatory approval. Today, they are easily available and increasingly popular.

So let's discuss the pros and cons of each form of owning Bitcoin today.

a pile of bitcoins with a bitcoin resting against it stands in front of an Australian flag.

Image source: Getty Images

Bitcoin: Buy direct?

The advantages of owning Bitcoin directly are self-explanatory. Many investors want to own these digital assets outright and have them in their own name. This path allows investors to move the coins around and between different wallets at will and store the coins as they see fit. That includes using hack-proof cold storage. If one wishes to use Bitcoin as an actual currency, if so inclined, this is the only ownership method that will permit this.

However, direct ownership has downsides. For one, it puts coins at risk of theft through hacking. Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are high-value targets for thieves, and hacking of exchanges and individual wallets is not uncommon. If your wallet or exchange is not insured or adequately protected, this could happen to you.

There is also the risk of losing your passwords or access mechanisms, particularly if you keep the Bitcoin in cold storage. There are countless horror stories of people losing substantial amounts of money this way.

Another downside to buying Bitcoin directly is the cost. Although transaction fees have come down substantially in recent years, you will still pay a hefty spread to buy and sell Bitcoin. These can add up, particularly if you trade frequently.

What about ASX cryptocurrency ETFs?

This is why many investors now prefer to use Bitcoin ETFs to invest in cryptocurrencies. The ASX is now home to several Bitcoin ETFs. These include the Global X 21Shares Bitcoin ETF (ASX: EBTC), the BetaShares Bitcoin ETF (ASX: QBTC), and the VanEck Bitcoin ETF (ASX: VBTC).

These ETFs usually work in a similar fashion to gold ETFs. The fund provider owns its own supply of Bitcoins, and investors buy a share of this underlying pile of Bitcoins indirectly by buying units of the fund.

The primary advantages of this method of Bitcoin investing are cost and safety. Although Bitcoin ETFs charge management fees, often around 0.45% per annum, it will still be cheaper for most investors than buying the coins directly. Additionally, these funds employ world-leading security measures and insurance to protect investors.

The big disadvantage of using Bitcoin ETFs is the indirect ownership and control of the assets. This may be more important to some Bitcoin investors than others. If one is simply looking for some exposure to these assets without necessarily wanting that direct control, a Bitcoin ETF might be the preferred option. But for investors who find Bitcoin's decentralised nature appealing, that direct ownership might be worth the extra cost.

At the end of the day, it's up to individual investors' preferences and risk tolerances to determine which way of owning Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies works for them.

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen has positions in Bitcoin. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Bitcoin. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Bitcoin. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Cryptocurrencies

Panicked man with his hand on his head with a red Bitcoin symbol and arrow going down.
Cryptocurrencies

Why did the Bitcoin price just plunge 6%?

Bitcoin and Ethereum both just got walloped. But why?

Read more »

A man sits at his computer with his head in his hands while his laptop screen displays a Bitcoin symbol and his desktop computer screen displays a steeply falling graph.
Cryptocurrencies

Bitcoin is back below US$77,000. Is this an opportunity for ASX investors?

Three big falls, three very different businesses.

Read more »

A rich buisnessman buys luxury items with Bitcoin
Cryptocurrencies

Why is the Bitcoin price rocketing 16% this week?

Crypto investors have sent the Ethereum and Bitcoin prices soaring this week. But why?

Read more »

A smiling woman holds a Bitcoin token in her hand.
Cryptocurrencies

Amid big swings in the Bitcoin price, can the crypto really help diversify your investment portfolio?

Leading analysts sound off on the diversification benefits of buying Bitcoin.

Read more »

A man sits at a desk with a phone in one hand, his other hand on his chin and studies a computer screen in front of him with what appears to be cryptocurrency data on both screens.
Cryptocurrencies

ASX shares or crypto? Here are the benefits and risks of each

Which asset should ASX investors choose?

Read more »

A Bitcoin symbol atop a spring, indicating the uncertain direction of cryptocurrency as a commodity
Cryptocurrencies

What could spark a Bitcoin price rebound in 2026?

Three powerful catalysts could determine whether Bitcoin’s brutal 2026 downturn finally begins to reverse.

Read more »

Red arrow crashing in the ground with a Bitcoin token next to it.
Cryptocurrencies

Down 48%, why a Bitcoin price rebound may be off the cards

Will Bitcoin and Ethereum ever recover their 48% and 61% price losses?

Read more »

Gold Bitcoins lying on a global finance currency chart with arrows shooting higher.
Cryptocurrencies

Could US lawmakers drive a rebound in the beaten-down Bitcoin price?

Bitcoin and Ethereum are both down almost 50% in a year. Could this be the catalyst crypto investors have been…

Read more »