ASX mining shares are up 16% in two months. Experts name 3 to buy and 1 to sell

The S&P/ASX 300 Metal & Mining Index hit a new record high yesterday.

ASX mining shares have delivered strong price growth amid the iron ore price holding above US$100 per tonne for eight weeks.

The iron ore price has held above US$100 per tonne since 2 July.

Since then, the S&P/ASX 300 Metal & Mining Index (ASX: XMM) has risen 16.2% to a new record high of 6,106 points yesterday.

Over this period, the S&P/ASX 200 Materials Index (ASX: XMJ) has also lifted 13.3%.

By comparison, the benchmark S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) has lifted 5.1%.

Three happy miners standing with arms crossed at a quarry.

Image source: Getty Images

Why are ASX mining shares rising?

The stabilisation of the iron ore price has helped propel the ASX iron ore mining shares, despite some price dips during earnings season.

For example, ASX mining share Fortescue Ltd (ASX: FMG) fell 4% on Tuesday after the full-year FY25 report was released.

The pure-play iron ore miner revealed a 41% profit dive, yet the share price decline was just 4% and it began rebounding within two days.

The BHP Group Ltd (ASX: BHP) share price rose 1.6% on the day of its FY25 report, despite revelations of a 26% fall in profit.

Both mining giants slashed their final dividends: Fortescue by 33% and BHP by 19%.

Yet these ASX mining shares — the two largest on the market — continue in an upward trajectory.

Analysts believe a rotation out of banks, particularly the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA), is giving miners new support.

Mark Delaney, Chief Investment Officer at AustralianSuper, said he began selling CBA shares three months ago.

Early last month, Delaney told the Australian Financial Review (AFR):

We've rotated back into resources, which might be too early, but … that's sort of what you want to do.

AustralianSuper is the nation's largest superannuation fund and manages about $365 billion in retirement savings.

It's not just ASX iron ore shares that have risen strongly over the past two months.

ASX gold mining shares are up too, as are some copper shares.

The gold price remains supported amid global unease about the reliability of the US dollar as the reserve currency.

In this article, we reveal 3 ASX mining shares rated buys and 1 rated a sell by professional brokers and analysts.

BHP Group Ltd (ASX: BHP) 

The BHP share price closed at $43.01 yesterday, and is 18% higher since 1 July.

Analysts' opinions are mixed on BHP shares.

Ord Minnett has an accumulate rating on the market's largest ASX mining share.

The broker has a 12-month share price target of $42.50 on BHP stock.

Ord Minnett noted that BHP's full-year report was largely in line with expectations due to a strong performance in the copper segment.

As we covered this week, BHP is now the world's largest copper producer.

The red metal accounted for 45% of BHP's total underlying EBITDA in FY25.

Fortescue Ltd (ASX: FMG)

The Fortescue share price closed at $19.34 yesterday, up 26% since 1 July.

Bell Potter has a selling rating on Fortescue shares.

According to a new note, the broker has downgraded the ASX mining share from a hold to a sell.

Bell Potter also cut its 12-month share price target to $17.05 from $17.40.

Commenting on the full-year report, Bell Potter said:

While it was a good result relative to our (low) expectations, we remain cautious on the outlook relative to the current valuation.

In our view, the current share price reflects the recent uptick in the iron ore price, to which we see limited sustained upside.

Newmont Corporation CDI (ASX: NEM)

The Newmont share price closed at $110.58 yesterday, up 24% since 1 July.

Ord Minnett reiterated its buy rating on this ASX gold mining share following its 2Q FY25 report.

The broker has a target price of $115 on Newmont shares.

In a new note, the broker said:

Newmont posted a June-quarter result that beat market and Ord Minnett expectations on production, costs, and operating earnings, and unveiled a further share buyback program of US$3 billion ($5 billion) thanks to its strong fiscal performance –free cash flow was a record US$1.7 billion – and robust balance sheet. 

The broker sees growth potnetial ahead for this ASX gold mining share.

Ord Minnett see plenty of value in Newmont – some of its assets are running below optimum levels but the investment in improving grades and operational efficiency should allow their potential to be realised, pushing gold production to around 6.0 million ounces in CY27 from our now increased but still conservative forecast of 5.7 million ounces in CY25.  

Getting the execution of these investments right should drive strong earnings growth and provide the impetus for an increase in its valuation multiple …

Capstone Copper Corp CDI (ASX: CSC)

The Capstone Copper share price closed at $10.90 yesterday, up 16% since 1 July.

Macquarie has an outperform rating on this ASX copper mining share with a target price of $12.50 following its 2Q FY25 report.

In a note, Macquarie discussed the impending expansion of its Mantoverde Optimized (MV-O) project in Chile.

Macquarie forecasts copper production to rise from 102,100 tonnes in 2025 to 147,200 tonnes in 2027.

The broker says the MV-O expansion is a low-capital-intensity growth path for Capstone Copper.

Motley Fool contributor Bronwyn Allen has positions in BHP Group. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended BHP Group. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Resources Shares

Miner and company person analysing results of a mining company.
Resources Shares

PLS Group vs Mineral Resources: ASX mining shares compared

Weighing up PLS Group vs Mineral Resources shares? I compare the fundamentals, recent performance and dividends, and pick my preferred…

Read more »

Two people wearing hard hats talking with each other at a mine site, with two workers in the background.
Resources Shares

Is the Fortescue share price a cheap buy?

I crunch the earnings forecasts to see whether this fallen mining share is actually good value.

Read more »

Three miners looking at a tablet.
Resources Shares

Regis Resources vs Fortescue: Which ASX miner is the better buy?

Regis Resources or Fortescue? I compare value, yield, and share price momentum to pick my preferred ASX mining stock now.

Read more »

Young successful engineer, with blueprints, notepad, and digital tablet, observing the project implementation on construction site and in mine.
Resources Shares

Which junior ASX mining stock has surged 50% on big news?

A takeover deal has put a rocket under this company's shares.

Read more »

A miner shakes hands with a businessman or banker inside an underground mine setting.
Resources Shares

Yancoal Australia share price in focus as Kestrel Coal Mine deal closes

Yancoal Australia shares are in the spotlight after finalising its acquisition of an 80% interest in the Kestrel Coal Mine.

Read more »

Woman shaking the hand of a man on a deal.
Resources Shares

Lynas to acquire Meteoric Resources in major rare earths deal

Lynas Rare Earths will acquire Meteoric Resources in an all-share deal, strengthening its rare earths portfolio and expanding its global…

Read more »

a man with a hard hat and high visibility vest stands with a clipboard and pen in front of a large pile of rock at a mining site.
Resources Shares

Yancoal shares in focus after Hunter Valley mine approval

Yancoal Australia gains NSW approval to extend Hunter Valley Operations mining until 2045, supporting jobs and regional growth.

Read more »

Cheerful businessman with a mining hat on the table sitting back with his arms behind his head while looking at his laptop's screen.
Resources Shares

Liontown Resources approves $389m Kathleen Valley lithium expansion

Liontown Resources approved a $389 million expansion at Kathleen Valley, aiming to boost production by 56% and further cement its…

Read more »