Buy one, sell the other: TPG vs Telstra shares

A leading broker gives its verdict on these telco giants.

Investors that are on the lookout for exposure to the telco sector might want to listen to what analysts at Goldman Sachs are saying about two major players.

The two shares in question are Telstra Group Ltd (ASX: TLS) and TPG Telecom Ltd (ASX: TPG).

According to recent notes, the broker believes that investors should be selling one of these telco stocks and buying the other. But which is which? Let's find out.

A woman standing in a blue shirt smiles as she uses her mobile phone.

Image source: Getty Images

Sell TPG shares

This morning, Goldman Sachs has reiterated its sell rating on TPG shares with a slightly improved price target of $4.40. Based on its current share price of $4.96, this implies potential downside of 11% for investors over the next 12 months. This reduces to approximately 7.5% when including its forecast 3.6% dividend yield.

While TPG delivered a result and guidance that was largely in line with expectations, it hasn't been enough for the broker to change its mind. Commenting on its sell rating, Goldman said:

We are Sell rated on TPG, given its risk/reward profile is skewed to the downside. Despite improved mobile market rationality in Australia, we see downside risks of continued enterprise headwinds, elevated fixed competition and higher cost growth for TPG over the medium term.

Buy Telstra shares

The broker believes Telstra is the superior option for investors that are looking for telco sector exposure this month.

Last month, its analysts responded to Telstra's results by retaining their buy rating with a $4.35 price target. Based on the latest Telstra share price of $3.93, this implies potential upside of almost 11% for investors.

In addition, Goldman is forecasting a fully franked 4.8% dividend yield in FY 2025, lifting the total potential return to a touch under 16%.

Its analysts like Telstra due to its low risk earnings growth and meaningful opportunity to unlock value through asset sales. They explain:

We believe the low risk earnings (and dividend) growth that Telstra is delivering across FY22-25, underpinned through its mobile business, is attractive. We also believe that Telstra has a meaningful medium term opportunity to crystallise value through commencing the process to monetize its InfraCo Fixed assets – which we estimate could be worth between A$22-33bn.

Although there is some debate around the strategic benefits, we see a strong rationale for monetizing the recurring NBN payment stream, given its inflation linked, long duration cash flows could be worth $14.5bn to $17.9bn, with no loss of strategic benefit.

All in all, Telstra shares are the way forward according to the broker.

Motley Fool contributor James Mickleboro has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Goldman Sachs Group. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Telstra Group. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Communication Shares

Piles of coins.
Communication Shares

How many Telstra shares do I need to buy for $12,000 of passive income in 2027?

Can investors call on Telstra for strong dividends?

Read more »

A woman holds an old fashioned telephone ear piece to her ear while looking unhappy sitting at a desk with her glasses crooked on her nose and a deflated expression on her face.
Communication Shares

Why have Telstra shares lost 16% since May?

Telstra has been a loser in recent months.

Read more »

Smiling woman with her head and arm on a desk holding $100 notes, symbolising dividends.
Communication Shares

How much must I invest in Telstra shares to earn a $1,000 passive income in 2027?

Can investors call on Telstra for good dividend income in 2027?

Read more »

woman on phone
Broker Notes

With $2.4 billion in FY26 profits, are Telstra shares a good buy today?

A leading expert delivers his outlook for Telstra shares.

Read more »

a newsboy wearing historical costume of peaked cap and braces yells into an old fashioned megaphone while holding a newspaper in one hand, a so-called newsboy of previous eras when newsboys sold newspapers on street corners.
Communication Shares

Why did Nine Entertainment shares hit a 12-month low today?

It's been a bleak day for the media company.

Read more »

A group of people look intently towards the camera as though they are very interested in the information they are hearing.
Communication Shares

Tuas FY26 results: revenue climbs, subscriber base expands

Tuas' FY26 earnings saw a 24% revenue increase and strong subscriber growth as the company invests in network expansion.

Read more »

Man holding Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
Communication Shares

If I buy $6,000 of Telstra shares, how much dividend income will I receive?

Telstra could be a wise choice for dividend income in FY27.

Read more »

Smiling woman listening to music and using her phone.
Dividend Investing

Should I buy Telstra shares for passive income?

I take a closer look at what the latest dividend forecasts could mean for income investors.

Read more »