Is IAG stock a good defensive ASX 200 buy right now?

Could the insurer's stock really offer 16% upside?

| More on:
A man looks at his laptop waiting in anticipation.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points

  • The IAG share price is gaining in late Wednesday trading, rising 3.3% to $4.96
  • The insurance provider's pricing power might make it a defensive ASX 200 stock
  • Though, analysts are divided on whether its worth buying, with one tipping it to lift to $5.75 a share

The Australian economy – and, by extension, the ASX – tends to move in cycles. Fortunately, some S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) shares, like Insurance Australia Group Ltd (ASX: IAG), have inbuilt protection from the market's ebbs and flows.

With most experts agreeing 2023 will likely be a year of slowing economic growth in Australia, is now a good time to buy IAG shares? Let's take a look.

The IAG share price is currently trading at $4.96, 3.33% higher than its previous close. Meanwhile, the ASX 200 is down 0.07% in late trading.

What makes IAG a defensive ASX 200 stock?

ASX shares tend to fall into one of two categories – defensive and cyclical. Generally, the earnings of cyclical companies, and their share prices, expand and contract alongside the economy and the market. Thus, investors might choose to lean on defensive shares during a downturn.

So, what might make IAG a defensive ASX 200 share? Answer: Pricing power.

The company provides insurance through brands including NRMA and CGU, to name a few.

Insurance providers can, within reason, set their own prices, as Wilsons equity strategist Rob Crookston notes, courtesy of my colleague Tony. And, boy, are they benefiting.

IAG posted a 25% jump in underlying profits for the first half, coming in at $252 million, thanks in part to a 7.5% jump in gross written premiums.

It's worth noting, however, that insurers can be cyclical in ways other than economic ebbs and flows. KPMG insurance partner Scott Guse recently commented:

Insurance is by its nature cyclical and only 3 years ago the insurers' profits were minimal, due to huge claims from the bushfires.

Is the ASX insurance share a buy right now?

Does that mean IAG shares are worth buying right now? Well, that depends on who you ask.

JPMorgan seems to think so. The broker has slapped an overweight rating and a $5.75 price target on the ASX 200 stock, The Australian reports. That marks a potential 15.9% upside.

But Goldman Sachs hasn't been convinced. It has a neutral rating and a $5.18 price target on IAG shares – a potential 4.4% upside.

Not to mention, the insurer revealed its natural perils costs reached $524 million last half – $70 million higher than its allowance. That concerned Shaw and Partners senior investment adviser Jeb Richards, who labelled IAG's shares a sell last month. He said, courtesy of The Bull:

Factors, such as global warming, continue to drive more volatile weather patterns and rising claims across the broader Australian insurance industry. We see better opportunities elsewhere.

JPMorgan Chase is an advertising partner of The Ascent, a Motley Fool company. Motley Fool contributor Brooke Cooper has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Goldman Sachs Group and JPMorgan Chase. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Defensive Shares

Men standing together and defending the goal post symbolising defensive shares.
Defensive Shares

4 defensive ASX shares to own in a greedy market: Macquarie

These experts reckon the ASX's record highs won't last...

Read more »

Two mature women learn karate for self defence.
Defensive Shares

2 defensive ASX income shares I think investors should consider buying for bumper returns!

These stocks could offer defence and good returns.

Read more »

Defensive Shares

The pros and cons of buying Telstra shares right now

Is this an opportunity calling?

Read more »

A couple makes silly chip moustache faces and take a selfie on their phone.
Defensive Shares

My 2 favourite ASX utility shares for January 2024

These stocks could provide a good mixture of defence and growth.

Read more »

safe dividend yield represented by a piggy bank wrapped in bubble wrap
Defensive Shares

Weathering market storms: Dividend stocks in Australia as a safe harbour

Defensive earnings could help provide stability.

Read more »

safe dividend yield represented by a piggy bank wrapped in bubble wrap
Defensive Shares

Here's my recommendation for safe ASX shares to buy in December 2023

I think these stocks could be two leading defensive picks.

Read more »

Men standing together and defending the goal post symbolising defensive shares.
Defensive Shares

5 top defensive ASX shares for turbulent times

These stocks could be long-term defensive winners.

Read more »

a child dressed in army fatigues lies on the ground in his backyard wearing leaves and branches on his head as camouflage and peering through a pair of binoculars in a soldier pose.
Defensive Shares

Searching for defensive ASX shares? Here's what I look out for

Not all defensive companies make for good investments.

Read more »