Will the Nasdaq or S&P 500 have a better 2023?

Depending on what the economy does, the performance of these indexes could be wildly different.

ASX share investor sitting at computer looking confused

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

This article was originally published on Fool.com. All figures quoted in US dollars unless otherwise stated.

As 2022 starts to close, it's only natural for investors to start peeking toward 2023. So far in 2022, the indexes have fared pretty miserably, with the Nasdaq-100 down 29% and the S&P 500 down 17%. Which one will have a better 2023?

Let's look at these indexes and their makeups and find out which is more likely to have a better 2023 ahead.

The indexes are highly concentrated on the top

At the top, the indexes have a lot of overlap.

Company Makeup of S&P 500
Apple 6.86%
Microsoft 5.43%
Alphabet* 3.34%
Amazon 2.53%
Berkshire Hathaway 1.67%

Data source: Slickcharts. Data as of Nov. 19. *Note: Both Alphabet class shares combined.

Company Makeup of Nasdaq-100
Apple 13.63%
Microsoft 10.15%
Alphabet* 6.74%
Amazon 5.44%
Tesla 3.20%

Data source: Slickcharts. Data as of Nov. 19. *Note: Both Alphabet class shares combined.

As you can see, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, and Alphabet make up a considerable chunk of these indexes. In the S&P 500, they account for 19.83%. It's basically double for the Nasdaq-100, with that group making up 39.16% of the index. It's pretty straightforward: How these companies do will significantly steer how the overall index does.

While these three are tech-focused, they compete in different markets. Both Apple and Amazon are a good measure of the pulse of the consumer, as their sales are highly affected by consumer sentiment. If inflation cools, and consumers don't need to worry about rising grocery prices or housing costs, they may treat themselves to the latest device.

Alphabet and Microsoft are business-focused, but for different reasons. Alphabet's primary revenue stream is advertising, and many clients have pulled back their spending levels in 2022 due to the uncertain business environment. If the outlook improves, expect this revenue to return. Microsoft's cloud business and Office product suite indicate how willing businesses are to spend on their infrastructure, but Microsoft's consumer product division also indicates how individuals are doing. 

If the consumer gets stronger and business outlook improves, these four will boom. If that's the case, then the Nasdaq-100 will likely have a better year because it is concentrated in companies that will benefit the most. But if 2023 brings an economic recession, the S&P 500's diversity will help it to outperform the Nasdaq-100.

The companies outside the top five are very different

For the S&P 500, when you move out of the top five, the companies become much more diverse.

Company Makeup of S&P 500
Tesla 1.47%
United Health Group
Johnson & Johnson
Nvidia 1.18%

Data source: Slickcharts. Data as of Nov. 19.

Now, there are industrials, healthcare, and energy sectors represented, giving the index some much-needed balance. Looking at the top 20 reveals even more diversity, with financials, energy, and healthcare rounding the index out.

This is far from the case for the Nasdaq-100.

Company Makeup of Nasdaq-100
Nvidia 3.09%
PepsiCo 2.32%
Costco Wholesale 2.16%
Meta Platforms
Broadcom 1.94%

Data source: Slickcharts. Data as of November 19. Note: Both Alphabet class shares combined.

Besides Pepsi and Costco, these companies are more in the tech sector. But, unlike the S&P 500, it doesn't get much better outside the top 10, with most of the top 20 consisting of chipmakers, communication companies, and software businesses. Now, this probably isn't a surprise because the media often refers to this index as the "tech-heavy Nasdaq."

Still, tech businesses don't do well if the economy is struggling.

Does that mean you should write the Nasdaq-100 off? Absolutely not. Tech stocks tend to do very well in the recovery phases of a recession. Plus, the stock market is forward-looking, and stocks usually tend to do better during a recession than leading up to one.

That last tidbit of information should keep investors in the market, especially now with a recession, or at least an economic slowdown, imminent. However, if you're trying to decide which index to buy, you need to utilize the 2023 outlook. If you think 2023 will be a repeat of 2022, then the S&P 500 is the better choice. On the other hand, if you believe the economy will begin to recover and the Federal Reserve eases its interest rate hikes, then the Nasdaq-100 is the place to be.

One last point: There's nothing wrong with owning both indexes if you don't know what 2023 will bring. Personally, I think this is an intelligent strategy, as it gives investors the upside of recovery and the safety of a balanced investment.

This article was originally published on Fool.com. All figures quoted in US dollars unless otherwise stated.

Keithen Drury has positions in Alphabet (C shares), Amazon, Costco Wholesale, Nvidia, and Tesla. John Mackey, CEO of Whole Foods Market, an Amazon subsidiary, is a member of The Motley Fool’s board of directors. Randi Zuckerberg, a former director of market development and spokeswoman for Facebook and sister to Meta Platforms CEO Mark Zuckerberg, is a member of The Motley Fool's board of directors. Suzanne Frey, an executive at Alphabet, is a member of The Motley Fool’s board of directors. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Alphabet (A shares), Alphabet (C shares), Amazon, Apple, Berkshire Hathaway (B shares), Costco Wholesale, Meta Platforms, Inc., Microsoft, Nvidia, and Tesla. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has recommended Broadcom Ltd, Johnson & Johnson, and UnitedHealth Group and has recommended the following options: long January 2023 $200 calls on Berkshire Hathaway (B shares), long March 2023 $120 calls on Apple, short January 2023 $200 puts on Berkshire Hathaway (B shares), short January 2023 $265 calls on Berkshire Hathaway (B shares), and short March 2023 $130 calls on Apple. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Alphabet (A shares), Alphabet (C shares), Amazon, Apple, Berkshire Hathaway (B shares), Meta Platforms, Inc., and Nvidia. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on International Stock News

A woman holds a soldering tool as she sits in front of a computer screen while working on the manufacturing of technology equipment in a laboratory environment.
International Stock News

Up nearly 80% this year, does Nvidia stock have room for more?

Nvidia's stock added a lot of its gains the day after Q4 earnings.

Read more »

Piggy bank on an electric charger.
International Stock News

If you'd invested $1,000 in Tesla stock 5 years ago, here's how much you'd have today

Tesla bears may not have noticed it, but Tesla profits are forecast to 3x over the next five years.

Read more »

Businessman using a digital tablet with a graphical chart, symbolising the stock market.
International Stock News

Bull vs. bear: Can the S&P 500 keep rising in 2024?

We review the bull and bear case for the S&P 500 this year.

Read more »

woman with coffee on phone with Tesla
International Stock News

Why Tesla stock put pedal to metal today

Tesla's robotaxi is coming in August.

Read more »

A male investor sits at his desk looking at his laptop screen holding his hand to his chin pondering whether to buy Macquarie shares
International Stock News

If you invested $10,000 in Nvidia stock the day ChatGPT came out, this is how much you'd have today

Buying Nvidia when the disruptive AI chatbot launched would have been a smart move.

Read more »

A Tesla car driving along a road at sunset
International Stock News

Why Tesla stock was climbing today

Investors were encouraged by news of a price hike on the Model Y.

Read more »

Plate with coloured wedges being parcelled out like a slice of pie representing a share split
International Stock News

Stock-split watch: Is Nvidia next?

Nvidia last split its stock when it traded for a pre-split $744 in 2021.

Read more »

A woman in jeans and a casual jumper leans on her car and looks seriously at her mobile phone while her vehicle is charged at an electic vehicle recharging station.
International Stock News

1 Wall Street analyst thinks Tesla stock is going to $125. Is it a sell?

Tesla is no longer a magnificent stock, according to a Wells Fargo analyst.

Read more »