Is this ASX 200 company 'exploiting government stupidity'?

Inflation continues to dominate the investment debate.

| More on:
A family drives along the road with smiles on their faces.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points

  • As inflation continues to soar, many business models are being pulled into the limelight
  • This also brings critics to the forefront, with one logistics industry heavyweight voicing concerns 
  • ASX 200 shares continue to face threats from the prospects of uncontrolled inflation

ASX 200 shares closed lower on Tuesday with the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) losing 0.38% to finish at 6,826 points.

With the chatter of inflation making its way around investor circles, even the most seasoned investors are searching for ways to protect capital, and save a buck or two.

Australian inflation at its highest level in decades

Inflation is a rate of change calculator; the first derivative of price. It measures how fast prices are increasing, as opposed to just what the price increase is.

This has important implications in the debate. If prices are increasing at a rapid pace – which they are today – it is difficult to slow them down without putting a dampener on the wider economy.

Hence why people tend to wind back discretionary spending to trim back the effects on personal savings and wealth.

There are, however, certain costs that are unavoidable and must be factored into our everyday budgets.

In Australia, one of the more peculiar costs our city dwellers face is that of toll roads. While not a unique Australian phenomenon, the prices we pay just to use various motorways in our capital cities are.

Enter Transurban Group (ASX: TCL), the manager and operator of the major toll roads in Australian capital cities. It also has a footprint in the United States and Europe.

The company, which books its revenues from the collection of toll fees charged to road users, clipped an 18% year-over-year gain in revenue for FY22. It brought this down to a 107% year-over-year gain in net profit to $19 million.

These results occurred while average daily traffic (ADT) recorded for the 12 months declined by 0.5%, proving that average prices increased.

And as mentioned, in Australia, we pay exorbitant fees to use toll roads.

According to Budget Direct:

Here in Australia, the most expensive road in the country is Melbourne's CityLink network, where drivers pay up to A$10.05 to drive the full 22km.

However, following CityLink, the next seven most expensive tolls in Australia are all found in New South Wales, with the most expensive of these being the toll on the M4 section of WestConnex, where the maximum charge is A$8.52.

You may start to question how all of this really stacks up.

We are, after all, Transurban's customers by design, not by choice, when having to use the roads.

Moreover, tolls are typically indexed to inflation, meaning that, instead of Transurban absorbing any cost increases in its $19 million profit margin, costs are passed directly on to consumers.

What Transurban's critics have to say

It should come as no surprise that the company and its business model have received a fair bit of criticism of late.

Most recently, the director of logistics giant Linfox Group, Bill Kelty, was vocal about the substantial returns Transurban receives as part of its ownership of numerous Australian tollways.

Kelty was critical of the entire situation in a recent interview.

"You have Transurban rooting everybody, you've got governments not able to make decisions," Kelty said, cited by the Australian Financial Review (AFR).

"Don't get me wrong, Transurban are not the rogues here – Transurban is exploiting government stupidity," he added.

Kelty said former Victorian premier Jeff Kennett guaranteed a 14% return for Transurban in its earlier days.

"You could have got it [infrastructure] funded at 4% – it's cost every school and every hospital equivalent in Victoria," he concluded.

However, one point to think about, is that Transurban is majority-owned by superannuation funds. This means the whole toll road situation may be generating additional wealth for Australian savers.

Transurban shares finished 0.72% down on Tuesday at $13.71.

Motley Fool contributor Zach Bristow has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Economy

A young woman uses an application in her smart phone to check currency exchange rates in front of an illuminated information board.
Economy

What a rising Aussie dollar means for your ASX shares

A rising dollar flows through to many ASX shares.

Read more »

Percentage sign on a blue graph representing interest rates.
Share Market News

ASX 200 turbulent following the RBA interest rate decision

ASX investors will need to accept plenty of uncertainty on the outlook for interest rates in 2026.

Read more »

Percentage sign on a blue graph representing interest rates.
Economy

What will a likely US rate cut mean for Australian shares?

An interest rate cut in the US appears to be a near-certainty, with implications for share markets both in the…

Read more »

Higher interest rates written on a yellow sign.
Share Market News

Buying ASX shares? Here's what to know before the RBA starts hiking interest rates

Investors buying ASX shares should prepare for potentially higher interest rates in 2026. But how?

Read more »

Surprised man looking at store receipt after shopping, symbolising inflation.
Share Market News

What Australia's shocking inflation print means for ASX 200 investors and interest rates

The RBA is facing an uphill inflation battle. Will the bank’s next move be to raise interest rates?

Read more »

A woman in a business suit sits at her desk with gold bars in each hand while she kisses one bar with her eyes closed. Her desk has another three gold bars stacked in front of her. symbolising the rising Northern Star share price
Gold

Why are ASX 200 gold stocks like Northern Star smashing the benchmark on Thursday

Investors are piling into the ASX 200 gold miners today. But why?

Read more »

Pieces of paper with percetage rates on them and a question mark.
Share Market News

Buying ASX 200 shares and hoping for interest rate relief? Here's what the RBA minutes reveal

The RBA kept interest rates on hold in November. What can ASX investors expect now?

Read more »

Frustrated and shocked business woman reading bad news online from phone.
Share Market News

Why is the ASX 200 down so much on Friday?

ASX 200 investors are reaching for their sell buttons on Friday. But why?

Read more »