2 things the best share portfolios have in common

There is a jungle of theories on investing in stocks. But it all boils down to just a couple of basic attributes.

A business woman sits in the lotus yoga position near her laptop, indicating a patient investment style

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

There are many competing theories about stock investing.

You can target growth shares, or you can concentrate on value stocks. Perhaps you can try to 'buy the dip', or you can practise dollar-cost averaging. You can be contrarian, or ride the momentum.

They are all successful at certain times and underperform during other periods. If there was one clear winning strategy, we'd all be doing it.

But among this dizzying array of options, there seem to be 2 base characteristics that the most successful portfolios have in common, according to Montaka Global Investments portfolio manager Chris Demasi.

"In 2016, Martijn Cremers and Ankur Pareek published a ground-breaking research report," he said on the company blog.

"It showed that only the most distinct and most patient funds go on to meaningfully outperform the stock market over very long periods."

So what exactly do the terms 'distinct' and 'patient' mean?

Avoid becoming a 'closet indexer'

The research suggested that the best-performing portfolios have 'high active share'.

The term 'active share' refers to the part of the stock portfolio that is invested differently from market sentiment at the time of purchase.

"Highly concentrated stock pickers, for example, have high active share of 90% or more typically," Demasi said.

"On the other hand, 'closet indexers' with diversified and undifferentiated portfolios that look like the market (often despite claims otherwise) have low active share of 60% or less."

After all, how are you going to outperform if you're doing the same thing as the rest?

Demasi said the typical stock picker that has an active share above 90% outperformed the market by almost 1% each year.

"This seemingly small yearly benefit becomes extraordinarily large when compounded over more than a quarter of a century, when the market appreciated at 9.4% per annum on average," he said.

"A portfolio of the highest active share funds would have beaten the market by more than 180%. A hypothetical investor with initial capital of $1 million would be almost $2 million wealthier."

The power of patience when investing

The most successful portfolios also display Buddha-like patience for each stock.

Demasi explained it in terms of 'fund duration', which is a term describing the average length of time each stock is held over a 5-year period.

"Managers with long fund duration hold stocks at least 2 years, while short fund duration managers usually sell stocks 8 months after purchasing them."

Those who went long showed obvious outperformance.

"The long-term investors that stick to their convictions longer than 2 years outperform, and by almost 2% per annum. Less patient managers underperformed regardless of how active and concentrated they were — and, in fact, the more they traded the worse they performed," said Demasi.

"Basically, patience paid off in spades."

That sample investor who earned an extra $2 million from a high active portfolio would be even richer if she exercised equanimity.

"By allocating the initial $1 million of capital to a portfolio of those most concentrated active managers that were also the most patient with their holdings, the earlier hypothetical investor would have outperformed the market by an additional 380% and be another $3.8 million richer."

Motley Fool contributor Tony Yoo has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Investing Strategies

A woman sits at her computer with her chin resting on her hand as she contemplates her next potential investment.
Dividend Investing

2 market-leading ASX dividend stocks to buy in April

Analysts have put buy ratings on these market-leaders.

Read more »

Father in the ocean with his daughters, symbolising passive income.
Dividend Investing

I'd spend $8k on these ASX 200 shares today to target a $6,102 annual passive income

I believe these ASX 200 shares will continue rewarding passive income investors for years to come.

Read more »

Man holding Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
ETFs

Want the latest dividend from the Vanguard Australia Shares ETF (VAS)? Here's what you have to do

If you want to bag the latest VAS dividend, here's what you need to do.

Read more »

A smiling businessman in the city looks at his phone and punches the air in celebration of good news.
Dividend Investing

Investing for passive income? Keep any eye out for that boosted Telstra dividend today!

If you own Telstra shares, keep an eye out for that juicy dividend payout today.

Read more »

Couple at an airport waiting for their flight.
Cheap Shares

Is Qantas a bargain ASX 200 stock today?

Analysts at Goldman Sachs think the Flying Kangaroo could be dirt cheap.

Read more »

Person holding a blue chip.
Blue Chip Shares

2 ASX blue-chip shares I'd buy with $3,000 right now

These are large businesses with compelling futures.

Read more »

A happy construction worker or miner holds a fistfull of Australian money, indicating a dividends windfall
Dividend Investing

Invest $12,000 in Woodside stock and get $5,700 in passive income

Reliable dividend shares are everywhere on the ASX. Here's how you could use that to your advantage.

Read more »

Doctor doing a telemedicine using laptop at a medical clinic
Cheap Shares

1 secretly cheap ASX 200 stock I'm buying for the long run

The best performer on the index last year has had a poor start to 2024. Let's examine whether this is…

Read more »