Affirm shares are surging, why is the Afterpay (ASX:APT) share price left behind?

The Afterpay (ASX: APT) share price is down 6.9% this week despite US-listed Affirm charging 20% higher in the past 4 trading sessions.

| More on:
Two boys in baskets on skateboards race each along a road.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

The Afterpay Ltd (ASX: APT) share price has found itself sliding 7% this week in stark contrast to its buy now, pay later (BNPL) rival in the United States.

The performance of US-listed Affirm Holdings Inc (NASDAQ: AFRM) is going gangbusters, with the Affirm share price up ~20% in the last four trading sessions to US$77.97.

Despite BNPL shares largely moving hand-in-hand, here's why the Affirm share price might be coming out ahead this week.

Why the Affirm share price is outperforming 

Recent acquisition targeting online returns 

The Affirm share price is likely being propped up this week by the company's $300 million acquisition of Returnly on 21 April.

Returnly allows eligible consumers to receive an instant merchant credit upon initiating a return, allowing them to order a new or replacement item immediately. The company takes on the product return risk and settles the order in real-time, making the return and exchange process seamless and helping merchants drive higher repurchase rates.

Affirm observes that an estimated $428 billion in merchandise was returned to retailers in 2020.

Affirm is still playing catch up against the Afterpay share price 

Taking a look at the bigger picture, Affirm's shares have slipped more than 45% from its February highs of US$146.90 and are down 15% since its first day of listing, where it closed at US$91.10.

By comparison, the Afterpay share price is down 25% since its all-time record high of $159.00.

Markets aren't made equal 

The broader market could be a driving force behind Affirm's rebound. 

The tech-heavy NASDAQ-100 (INDEXNASDAQ: NDX) has significantly outperformed the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) in almost any time frame. The Nasdaq has increased 2.60% in the past four trading sessions, up ~9.60% year-to-date and up ~44% since its pre-COVID high. 

By comparison, the ASX200 is ~0.25% higher in the past four trading sessions, up ~5.25% year-to-date and down 2.25% since its pre-COVID highs. However, the ASX200 may not be a good representation or a driving force for Afterpay, given its weighting towards financials and mining. 

The S&P/ASX200 Info Tech (INDEXASX: XIJ) is down 4.50% year-to-date and up 32% since its pre-COVID highs, highlighting an underperformance in both a shorter and longer time frame. 

This outperformance and more rich valuation of US-listed shares is also a driving factor of why the Afterpay share price is eyeing a US listing

Afterpay still fetches a higher valuation 

With a market capitalisation of $33 billion, the Afterpay share price is still the most richly valued BNPL stock, trading at approximately 67 times FY20 revenue compared to the 39 times of Affirm. 

Motley Fool contributor Kerry Sun has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia owns shares of AFTERPAY T FPO. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on BNPL shares

A cool dude looks back at the camera while ziplining above the treetops.
BNPL shares

Why the Zip share price keeps going up

It's been triple-digit gains this year for Zip.

Read more »

A young woman smiles as she rides a zip line high above the trees.
BNPL shares

The Zip share price surged another 14% in September. Can it keep running hot into 2025?

That’s despite a sizeable fall today.

Read more »

Man holding a calculator with Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
BNPL shares

$10,000 invested in Zip shares a year ago is now worth…

Was it a good idea to buy this payments company's shares last year?

Read more »

Young girl wearing glasses flexes her left bicep confidently.
BNPL shares

Are Zip shares headed for ASX large-cap status?

Could Zip really become a large-cap blue chip?

Read more »

woman using affirm to pay
BNPL shares

Why Zip shares could still offer 'significant opportunity for growth'

Up 779% in a year, this top fund manager thinks Zip shares can continue to grow.

Read more »

A young woman in a shop hands her credit card to the cashier
Share Gainers

Up 693% in a year, is it too late to buy Zip shares now?

Can the Zip share price continue to outperform after its blistering one year rally?

Read more »

Two people comparing and analysing material.
BNPL shares

Is ASX-listed Zip outpacing buy now, pay later juggernaut Klarna?

How does Zip stack up?

Read more »

A happy girl in a yellow playsuit with a zip gives the thumbs up
Share Gainers

If I'd bought 1 share of Zip stock in 2023, here's how much I'd have now!

Late 2023 would have been an opportune time for me to load up on Zip shares.

Read more »