True cost of early super withdrawal revealed – and it's not pretty!

The true retirement costs of allowing Australians to withdraw their superannuation funds early may be even more than originally estimated.

hand holding hammer smashing open empty piggy bank

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Enabling Australians to withdraw up to $20,000 from their superannuation funds has been one of the more controversial government policies for dealing with the coronavirus pandemic.

Eligible Australians were allowed to withdraw up to $10,000 in the 2020 financial year (FY20) from their superannuation accounts, and have access to a further $10,000 in FY21 (up until December).

The early super withdrawal scheme is being administrated by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO).

What are the arguments?

Proponents argue that it is necessary for Aussies undergoing financial and economic hardship to have access to 'their' money to ride out the crisis.

On the other hand, critics of the scheme argue that it is undermining the retirement safety net of our country. Reports that anyone who applies to access the money has been allowed to withdraw from super, regardless of hardship, have further damaged the scheme's credibility (although the ATO is reportedly following these up).

Regardless of your views, it's hard to argue with damning new analysis that has just been released.

ASX exchange-traded funds (ETFs) provider BetaShares has released modelling of the early super withdrawal scheme. It makes for some fascinating reading, to say the least.

Early super withdrawals prove costly

Its headline finding is that the $30 billion (as of 29 July) in early super withdrawals will cost the retirement system between $100 billion and $130 billion in the coming years. This is made up of lost returns from investments that would have added value had they remained within a fund. Extra pension payments the government will have to pay as a result are also included.

BetaShares CEO, Alex Vynokur, had this to say of the early superannuation withdrawal modelling:

This was a well-intentioned but misguided policy from the start. The true cost of allowing people to access their super early will ultimately be paid by future Australian governments and taxpayers… An amount between $100 billion and $130 billion represents a very significant future shortfall (which will only increase as further super is released early). It will need to be funded by future Australian governments and therefore the Australian public will ultimately bear the cost, as those who have withdrawn super will be less able to fully fund their own retirement needs.

The BetaShares modelling also shows that young Australians have the most to lose from this policy. It estimates that a $10,000 withdrawal represents a lost $70,400 in retirement funds for an investor with 40 years until retirement, using consumer price index (CPI) + 5% modelling. If CPI + 7% is used, the figure jumps to $149,745. This comes after Treasury figures quoted by BetaShares revealed that half of all early super release claims are being made by people aged under 35.

The report also quotes data that reveals 64% of people who accessed early release "spent the money on discretionary items such as clothing, food, gambling and alcohol".

Sobering stuff indeed!

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Share Market News

property prices represented by person holding on to miniature house
Share Market News

Shares vs. property: Record stock ownership amid landlords' exit

Household wealth derived from owning shares just hit a record $1.4 trillion.

Read more »

A man wearing a red jacket and mountain hiking clothes stands at the top of a mountain peak and looks out over countless mountain ranges.
Share Gainers

Here are the top 10 ASX 200 shares today

It was mayhem on the markets today, with one of the worst days in a long time for ASX shares.

Read more »

A businesswoman pulls her glasses down in shock to look at the bad news on her computer.
Share Market News

The Aussie stock market just wiped out all of 2024's gains! Time to buy?

We're back to the start for 2024 after another negative session. Is there a way for investors to make the…

Read more »

Person handing out $50 notes, symbolising ex-dividend date.
Share Market News

Insiders are buying Mesoblast and these ASX shares

Insiders seem to see value in these shares.

Read more »

a sad gambler slumps at a casino table with hands on head and a large pile of casino chips in the foreground.
Share Fallers

'Catastrophic' risk: Why Star shares have lost 25% in 4 days

The outcome of this inquiry could determine whether Star Entertainment hits Blackjack or bust.

Read more »

Man pointing at a blue rising share price graph.
Share Gainers

Guess which little ASX iron ore stock is surging 68% on big news

Investors are bidding up the iron ore miner following a promising project update.

Read more »

A male investor erupts into a tantrum and holds his laptop above his head as though he is ready to smash it, as paper flies around him, as he expresses annoyance over so many new 52-week lows in the ASX 200 today
Share Fallers

Why Domino's, Macmahon, Star, and Zip shares are sinking today

These ASX shares are falling more than most today.

Read more »

a woman holds her hands up in delight as she sits in front of her lap
Share Gainers

Why Decmil, SCEE, Spartan Resources, and Telix shares are pushing higher

These shares are avoiding the market selloff today.

Read more »