CBA vs AMP: Which is better for a 40-year-old investor seeking passive income?

Comparing CBA and AMP shares for passive income: dividend yields, franking, and 2026 performance for Aussie investors.

Smiling man points to graph comparing different companies.

Image source: Getty Images

Commonwealth Bank of Australia vs AMP shares

If you're considering Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA) versus AMP Ltd (ASX: AMP) shares for passive income, you're not alone. Both are well-known names in Aussie financial services, but they stand in very different corners of the market. Let's break down where these two fit in the ASX ecosystem, how their dividends compare, and which might better suit a 40-year-old investor searching for reliable income.

The case for Commonwealth Bank of Australia

Commonwealth Bank of Australia, or CBA, is the bank most Australians recognise. As one of the "big four" local banks, CBA offers everything from everyday banking to superannuation, insurance, funds management, and broking. Its huge customer base and geographic reach through Australia, New Zealand, Asia, and beyond make it a dominant force in Australian financial services.

What jumps out in the numbers? First, CBA has a massive market cap of $251.64 billion—this is financial muscle few can match on the ASX. Its dividend yield is 3.31%, and those dividends are fully franked at 100%, meaning investors benefit from the maximum tax credits. The trailing P/E ratio sits at 23.38, reflecting the bank's premium status (and market confidence) but also suggesting investors pay up for its perceived stability.

The case for AMP

AMP, once one of the giants in Australian wealth management, is now a very different beast to CBA. AMP still delivers superannuation, insurance, and banking products, but in recent years has massively restructured—offloading large business units, entering joint ventures, and refocusing on its core services. AMP is aiming to restore its reputation and grow through a more focused wealth and banking platform.

What's striking here is the smaller scale: AMP's market cap is $6.13 billion, a small fraction of CBA's. Yet, its shares have soared YTD, up 43.41%, likely helped by optimism around its ongoing turnaround. The dividend yield stands at 1.95%—lower than CBA—and dividends are only 20% franked, so the tax benefit for income-seekers is much lower. Its P/E ratio sits at 34.59, higher than CBA's, which may reflect expectations for future growth, but could also indicate the market is willing to pay more for the turnaround story.

Valuation comparison

Here's how the key numbers stack up side-by-side:

MetricCommonwealth Bank of AustraliaAMP
Market Cap$251.64 billion$6.13 billion
P/E Ratio23.3834.59
Dividend Yield3.31%1.95%
Dividend Franking100%20%
Dividend per Share (TTM)$5.05$0.05
Earnings per Share6.5170.074
Year To Date Return-1.96%43.41%

What stands out? CBA offers higher dividend yield and much fuller franking—critical if you're relying on dividends for income in retirement or semi-retirement. AMP's higher P/E and much lower dividend payouts, as well as only 20% franking, make it less attractive for passive income, at least on these numbers.

Recent share price momentum

Comparing recent share price performance up to 7 October:

  • Commonwealth Bank of Australia closed at $150.37 on 7 Oct 2026, posting a -1.32% move that day and a YTD return of -1.96%.
  • AMP closed at $2.54 on 7 Oct 2026, down 0.78% for the day but boasting a stellar YTD gain of 43.41%.

While AMP's 2026 share performance has far outpaced CBA, its day-to-day volatility is also higher. CBA has delivered flat-to-slightly-negative returns YTD, but in the context of larger banks, that's not unusual given macro conditions.

Which is the better buy?

If passive income is your goal—especially with franking credits to boost after-tax returns—I'd lean clearly toward Commonwealth Bank of Australia. The combination of a higher dividend yield (3.31% vs AMP's 1.95%), fully franked payouts, and greater dividend reliability across many years all play in CBA's favour. Its earnings, scale, and track record make it a mainstay for anyone seeking regular, tax-effective income.

AMP's dramatic rebound in 2026 is eye-catching, but for passive income seekers, the thin yield, patchy franking, and the uncertainty of recent years don't tick enough of the right boxes. AMP might suit those hunting for turnaround potential or capital gains. But for a 40-year-old after consistent, tax-friendly dividends—the sort that can help fund a comfortable lifestyle without too much risk—my pick would be Commonwealth Bank of Australia.

Motley Fool contributor Laura Stewart has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips. This article was prepared with the assistance of Large Language Model (LLM) tools for the initial draft. Any content assisted by AI is subject to our robust human-in-the-loop quality control framework, involving thorough review, substantial editing, and fact-checking by our experienced writers and editors holding appropriate credentials. The Motley Fool Australia stands behind the work of our editorial team and takes ultimate responsibility for the content published by The Motley Fool Australia.

More on Dividend Investing

A woman holds out a handful of $50 Australian dollar notes.
Dividend Investing

296,399 shares of this ASX dividend stock pays an income equal to the Age Pension

This ASX dividend stock could be precisely what income seekers are looking for.

Read more »

Businessman smiles with arms outstretched after receiving good news.
Dividend Investing

Forget term deposits! I'd buy these ASX dividend shares instead

ASX dividend shares offer multiple benefits compared to banking products.

Read more »

Senior couple enjoying each other's company while walking on the beach.
Dividend Investing

3 super ASX dividend stocks that make my shortlist in November for passive income in 2027

Looking for an income boost next year? Here are three shares to consider.

Read more »

Man holding fifty Australian Dollar banknotes in his hands, symbolising dividends.
Dividend Investing

2 compelling ASX shares with dividend yields above 10%

These businesses offer exceptionally high dividend yields.

Read more »

Rising stacks of coins next to a piggy bank.
Dividend Investing

$4,000 buys 2,564 shares in an impressively reliable ASX dividend stock

This stock offers significant dividend income.

Read more »

Woman shopping for cleaning products at a supermarket.
Consumer Staples & Discretionary Shares

Coles shares fell 13%. How's the dividend yield looking?

Coles' pain could be income investors' gain.

Read more »

Person holding Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
Dividend Investing

2 ASX dividend shares I'd use to generate $400 a month in 2027

These two businesses have incredibly attractive income characteristics.

Read more »

a woman smiles widely as she leans on her trolley while making her way down a supermarket grocery aisle while holding her mobile telephone.
Dividend Investing

How many Coles shares do I need to buy for $1,200 of dividend income in 2027?

Coles is still a strong option for dividend income.

Read more »