Image source: Getty Images
Telstra vs Woodside shares: which dividend stock looks better now?
When you're hunting for dependable dividend income from the ASX, Telstra Group Ltd (ASX: TLS) and Woodside Energy Group Ltd (ASX: WDS) are two names most investors have pondered at some point. Both companies are giants in their sectors, both pay franked dividends, and both rank among the most widely held blue chips around. But if you're weighing Telstra vs Woodside shares this month, which stock delivers the better overall package of yield, value, and momentum?
The case for Telstra
Telstra is Australia's largest telecommunications and information services company. It offers a wide range of products including mobile, fixed, broadband, data, and digital services for residential and business customers. In recent years, Telstra has undertaken a major restructure and now operates via several business units, such as ServeCo and InfraCo, aiming to sharpen focus and capital allocation. Its presence still stretches internationally, but the core remains a dominant force in Australia.
On fundamentals, a few things stand out. Telstra's market cap sits at $53.58 billion, making it one of the largest companies on the ASX. The dividend yield clocks in at 4.35%, with a high franking rate of just over 90%. Its current P/E ratio is 24.27, and Telstra has delivered a modest year-to-date return of 3.5%. According to its most recent public description, Telstra now oversees distinct subsidiaries, designed to streamline and modernise operations. Historically, Telstra has paid consistent franked dividends, appealing to income investors, though the absolute growth in those dividends has been modest.
The case for Woodside Energy
Woodside Energy operates as Australia's largest independent oil and gas producer, with extensive offshore and onshore assets. The company recently boosted its international scale by merging with BHP's petroleum business, making it a global energy player. Based in Perth, Woodside is a top-tier ASX heavyweight known for its focus on LNG, oil, and gas and for pursuing new energy opportunities.
Looking at the numbers, Woodside's market cap is a hefty $58.72 billion. The company is currently serving up a 5.11% fully franked dividend yield – handily higher than Telstra's. Its P/E ratio is 13.94, significantly lower than Telstra's, indicating that the market is pricing Woodside's earnings more conservatively. The company has posted a very strong year-to-date return of 42.1%, reflecting robust momentum. Historically, Woodside's dividends tend to fluctuate along with commodity prices, but its commitment to returns is evident in a big dividend per share of $1.63 this year.
Valuation comparison
Here's how Telstra and Woodside stack up on key quantitative measures:
| Metric | Telstra | Woodside |
|---|---|---|
| Market Cap | $53.58 billion | $58.72 billion |
| P/E Ratio | 24.27 | 13.94 |
| Dividend Yield | 4.35% | 5.11% |
| Earnings Per Share (EPS) | 0.199 | 1.605 |
| Dividend Per Share | 0.21 | 1.63 |
| Franking | 90.48% | 100% |
Note: While Telstra's P/E and EPS are mathematically consistent, investors should keep in mind that Woodside's substantially higher EPS aligns with its much greater dividend per share and yield. Both companies offer franked dividends, but Woodside's are fully franked (100%), versus Telstra's ~90%. Telstra trades on a much higher earnings multiple than Woodside. For context, these companies sit in very different sectors—telecommunications and energy—so direct P/E comparisons should be taken with a pinch of salt.
Recent share price momentum
Comparing recent share price performance up to October 2026:
- Telstra closed at $4.81 on 1 October 2026, down 0.41% from the previous session. Over the past month, its movement has been steady but lacked major gains. Its year-to-date return is 3.5%.
- Woodside closed at $30.89 on 1 October 2026, after a 3.11% decline that session. Despite that daily slip, the year-to-date return stands at a very strong 42.1%.
Both companies have seen some day-to-day volatility, but Woodside has clearly outpaced Telstra by a wide margin in year-to-date share price performance.
Which is the better buy?
If I had to choose between Telstra and Woodside this month for a dividend-focused portfolio, my pick would be Woodside Energy. The reasons? Woodside's yield is higher at 5.11%, it's fully franked, and the dividend per share is substantially larger. Its valuation also looks more attractive, with a P/E ratio well below Telstra's, suggesting the market doesn't have especially high near-term growth expectations priced in. Combine that with Woodside's dazzling 42% year-to-date share price rise, and I think the market's enthusiasm is justified by both operational progress (post-BHP merger) and solid cash returns.
Telstra is hardly a poor choice for those wanting defensive, steady dividend flow, but the growth and value currently appear more exciting at Woodside, even after such a strong run. Of course, energy stocks carry their own risks—earnings and payout levels are more tied to commodity cycles than Telstra's relatively predictable telco business. But based strictly on this snapshot of yield, franking, value, and momentum, I'd lean toward Woodside as the better dividend buy right now.
