Why Macquarie's $321 million Shield problem is back in court

Another Shield court case is giving investors something else to watch.

Macquarie Group Ltd (ASX: MQG) shares are moving higher on Thursday.

This comes despite another legal headache returning to investors' radar after appearing largely settled.

At the time of writing, the investment bank's stock is up 0.81% to $241.76.

That still leaves the stock down almost 8% over the past month, although it remains around 19% higher in 2026.

So, what's going on?

A judge sitting in a blurred background reaches forward to strike his gavel on the strikeplate on his judge's bench.

Image source: Getty Images

What is the new claim about?

According to The Australian, Gordon Legal has launched a class action in the Supreme Court of Victoria against Macquarie Investment Management.

The action involves Rachelle Dessent and around 2,800 account holders who invested in the Shield Master Fund through Macquarie's platform.

Macquarie agreed last September to compensate affected investors for the money they had put into Shield.

Around $480 million was invested in the fund between 2022 and its closure in 2024, with roughly $321 million coming through Macquarie's platform.

But Gordon Legal says getting the original investment back doesn't necessarily cover everything investors lost.

It says some investors potentially missed out on returns their superannuation could have earned if the money had been invested elsewhere.

Furthermore, the claim is also seeking compensation for the distress investors allegedly suffered.

Gordon Legal partner James Naughton told The Australian that some investors "have not been fully compensated for all their losses, even if they have already received payouts".

Why is Shield still causing problems?

Shield was available through Macquarie's superannuation platform from early 2022 until investments were stopped in 2023.

The fund later collapsed and was put into liquidation, leaving thousands of investors facing losses.

That ultimately left Macquarie facing regulatory action over the issue.

Last year, ASIC took Macquarie Investment Management to court after the company admitted it failed to place Shield on a watch list for extra monitoring.

Macquarie later agreed to pay around $321 million to roughly 3,000 affected investors.

What should investors watch?

At this stage, there's no telling how much more this could end up costing Macquarie.

Gordon Legal is seeking further compensation, but no dollar figure has been put on the claim just yet.

Evidently, that makes it hard to know whether this could become another sizeable cost or something Macquarie can absorb easily.

Nonetheless, investors don't seem too worried today, with the shares still trading slightly higher.

I'd be watching how the case develops and whether Macquarie ends up facing another sizeable payout over the Shield collapse.

Motley Fool contributor Aaron Teboneras has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Macquarie Group. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Macquarie Group. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Bank Shares

Bank building with the word bank in gold.
Bank Shares

If I invest $15,000 in NAB shares, how much passive income will I receive in 2027?

Is NAB a strong option for dividends?

Read more »

Happy young woman saving money in a piggy bank.
Bank Shares

How many CBA shares do I need to buy for $10,000 of passive income?

The banking giant is popular with income investors for a reasons.

Read more »

couple happily discussing their issues with a banker
Bank Shares

Bendigo and Adelaide Bank vs Bank of Queensland: Which is better value?

Comparing Bendigo and Adelaide Bank vs Bank of Queensland shares: which regional bank looks better value on recent fundamentals and…

Read more »

Four business people wearing formal business suits and ties walk abreast on a wide paved surface with their long shadows falling on the ground ahead of them.
Bank Shares

Westpac vs Macquarie Group: Which bank is better value now?

Westpac vs Macquarie Group: which bank share offers Aussies better value for October? Here’s how the heavyweights compare on dividends,…

Read more »

Australian dollar notes in businessman pocket suit, symbolising ex dividend day.
Bank Shares

If I invest $8,000 in CBA shares, what passive income could I earn in FY27 and FY28?

Brokers aren't too bullish about the outlook for the bank shares over the next 12 months, but its passive income…

Read more »

Couple using their digital tablet together.
Bank Shares

Are CBA shares still worth buying near $150?

I look at whether the recent pullback has made this major bank more attractive today.

Read more »

Bank written on a brown building.
Bank Shares

Westpac vs NAB shares: Which big bank is the better buy?

I compare Westpac and NAB shares for value, yield and momentum – here’s which bank I’d buy now.

Read more »

A man in a suit smiles at the yellow piggy bank he holds in his hand.
Bank Shares

If I invest $10,000 in CBA shares today, what could they be worth in October 2027?

Find out what brokers expect next out of CBA shares.

Read more »