Analysts are split over whether New Hope shares are a buy or a hold

A strong quarterly report notwithstanding, broker opinions are mixed.

Coal miner New Hope Corporation Ltd (ASX: NHC) released a quarterly production report this week, prompting the broker community to take a closer look at the company.

Interestingly, the brokers don't agree on whether the company is fully valued at the moment, with Macquarie breaking ranks with an outperform rating on the shares.

We'll have a closer look at some of the broker share price targets for New Hope shortly.

First, let's have a look at what they announced this week.

A coal miner smiling and holding a coal rock.

Image source: Getty Images

Robust production numbers

The company said in its quarterly report that its coal production was "strong", coming in at 4.3 million tonnes for the quarter, up 5% on the previous quarter.

Coal sales were 10.4% higher at 3.2 million tonnes, while the average realised price inched up from $139 per tonne to $140.70 per tonne.

New Hope said the underlying EBITDA for the quarter was $130.1 million, up 21.7% on the previous quarter, and the company had cash of $571.6 million.

The company said the conflict in the Middle East had been supportive of higher coal prices.

It said:

During the quarter, geopolitical conflict in the Middle East caused disruption and uncertainty to global energy markets. Global coal markets observed favourable price movements during the quarter, driven by concerns surrounding Middle Eastern LNG availability and shifting gas-to-coal for power generation. Japan, South Korea and Taiwan (JKT) increased coal imports, prioritising energy security amidst LNG supply disruption. Japan and South Korea have eased restrictions on older coal plants and postponed planned retirements. The Company anticipates increased demand in the coming quarter, as the Northern Hemisphere moves out of the shoulder season and into Summer. Looking ahead, the Group's forward sales book remains well supported with the majority of production for the next three months sold.

Broker dissent

In terms of the brokers that follow the company, both Bell Potter and Morgans have a hold recommendation on New Hope shares.

Bell Potter said they had increased their price target for the company from $4.50 to $5, after they applied "a 10% premium to our sum of the parts valuation with energy security concerns exacerbated by recent geopolitical issues''.

Their price target is still below the current share price of $5.44, however.

Morgans has a price target of $5.25 on the shares, up from $5 previously, saying New Hope "continues to be well-positioned to deliver low-cost, high-margin cash flow from its operations''.

They added:

We believe coal prices can rebound meaningfully above consensus over time, and NHC is positioned to capitalise, driving stronger cash flow and shareholder returns.

Macquarie, however, is an outlier with a bullish price target of $7 on New Hope shares.

Macquarie said:

Improving (stabilising) performance at Bengalla (hitting target run rates) and ongoing ramp-up at New Acland positions New Hope well in what could become a tighter market for thermal coal as global energy disruptions continue from the Middle East conflict.

Motley Fool contributor Cameron England has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Macquarie Group. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Macquarie Group. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Energy Shares

A woman wearing a black and white striped t-shirt looks to the sky with her hand to her chin, contemplating buying ASX shares.
Energy Shares

Boss Energy vs Paladin Energy: Which ASX uranium stock wins?

Boss Energy and Paladin Energy are ASX uranium leaders. Here’s which I’d buy based on value, growth, and latest performance.

Read more »

A mining worker clenches his fists celebrating success at sunset in the mine.
Broker Notes

Macquarie says this ASX uranium producer has more than 15% upside

A new mine design has impressed the broker.

Read more »

A service station attendant crosses his arms and smiles towards the camera with a backdrop of petrol bowsers and a drive-through facility.
Energy Shares

Woodside vs Ampol: Which ASX energy stock should you buy?

Woodside and Ampol both offer franked dividends and momentum—so which ASX energy stock wins out on value and yield?

Read more »

Woman sitting on a chair by the pool on her laptop, looking at a stock market chart.
Energy Shares

Origin Energy vs AGL Energy: Which ASX dividend stock is better for income?

Origin and AGL are both strong dividend payers—but I think Origin has the edge for income investors right now.

Read more »

Frustrated man looking exhausted while sitting at his desk with his laptop and carrying his glasses in his hand.
Energy Shares

Guess which ASX 200 stock was downgraded to a sell rating

Bell Potter is bearish on this stock. Here's what it is saying.

Read more »

An oil worker assesses productivity at an oil rig.
Energy Shares

Santos vs Woodside: Which ASX energy share is better value?

The numbers reveal a clear value winner between Santos and Woodside shares right now.

Read more »

Worker inspecting oil and gas pipeline.
Energy Shares

Here's the earnings forecast out to 2028 for Woodside shares

Will Woodside’s earnings grow with strong energy prices in the years ahead?

Read more »

Lakes in the form of footsteps among the green trees, indicating steps towards a healthier planet.
Energy Shares

Contact Energy reports higher sales and renewable project progress in August

Contact Energy lifted energy sales in August 2026 and progressed big renewable projects.

Read more »