Beaten down: Are Cochlear, Pro Medicus or CSL shares a better buy right now?

Which struggling healthcare stock could bounce back?

Three ASX healthcare giants have endured a very rough 12 months. 

At the time of writing: 

These results have all contributed significantly to the softness of the broader ASX healthcare sector. 

The S&P/ASX 200 Health Care Index (ASX: XHJ) is down approximately 33% in the last 12 months. 

For context, the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) is up 9.3% in that same span. 

Shot of a young businesswoman looking stressed out while working in an office.

Image source: Getty Images

What are brokers saying about these healthcare stocks?

These three companies are amongst the largest healthcare stocks by market cap.

This means it could be an opportunity to buy low, with long-term upside. 

Let's see if there is any upside according to experts. 

CSL

In February, CSL reported total revenue of US$8.3 billion, down 4% while net profit fell 7% to $1.9 billion.

Messaging from management indicated this was a disappointing result, and investors seemed to agree. 

Sentiment around this healthcare giant seems to be mixed. 

The team at Fairmont Equities recently put a sell recommendation on CSL shares. 

Ord Minnett has a hold rating and $198.00 price tag. 

Meanwhile, UBS has a price target of $235 on CSL shares. 

CSL shares closed at $142.86 yesterday. 

Pro Medicus

Pro Medicus was amongst the worst performing ASX 200 stocks during February. 

It's worth noting on the positive side however, is that three of the company's directors have increased their existing stake by purchasing additional Pro Medicus shares. 

This can be a sign of confidence from management, which can positively influence investor sentiment. 

It now sits almost 48% lower than the start of 2026. 

The company appears to be another victim of AI disruption fears.

Pro Medicus closed trading yesterday at $116.19. 

However, 13 analysts ratings via TradingView place have an average 12 month target of $220.75. 

That's almost 90% upside from current levels. 

Cochlear

Cochlear shares have also endured a rough year, particularly post earnings. 

It was dumped on results day on 17 February after missing expectations. 

The response from Morgans was a hold recommendation and 12-month share price target on Cochlear of $214.93.

The broker said the 1H26 result was softer than expected, with revenue, margins and profit negatively impacted mainly on longer than anticipated contracting for the newly launched Nucleus Nexa system (Nexa).

This target is approximately 15.66% higher than yesterday's closing price of $185.83. 

The 15 analyst offering one year forecasts via TradingView have an average price target of $255.59 on Cochlear shares.

That would be approximately 37% upside.

Motley Fool contributor Aaron Bell has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended CSL and Cochlear. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has recommended Pro Medicus. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended CSL, Cochlear, and Pro Medicus. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Healthcare Shares

Teamwork, planning and meeting with doctors and laptop for medical, review and healthcare. Medicine, technology and internet with group of people for collaboration, diversity and support in hospital
Healthcare Shares

CSL vs Pro Medicus: Which ASX healthcare share is better?

Both CSL and Pro Medicus have faced recent challenges but have enviable long-term track records. Here's which one I'd buy…

Read more »

Scientists working in the laboratory and examining results.
Healthcare Shares

This ASX biotech could rise almost 50%, Morgans says

Turning science into contracts could unlock value for this company.

Read more »

Doctor with stethoscope using a tablet in a hospital.
Healthcare Shares

Telix Pharmaceuticals wins FDA Fast Track for BiPASS prostate cancer imaging

Telix Pharmaceuticals shares are in the spotlight after the FDA granted Fast Track for its BiPASS pre-biopsy prostate cancer imaging…

Read more »

Three scientists looking at a laptop in a lab.
Healthcare Shares

What would it take for CSL shares to return to $250?

The shares have already recovered strongly, so I wanted to see whether $250 is realistic.

Read more »

Doctor with stethoscope typing on her computer.
Healthcare Shares

Is the ResMed share price a cheap buy?

I look at what the next few years of earnings growth could mean for today’s valuation.

Read more »

Medical workers examine an x-ray or scan in a hospital laboratory.
Healthcare Shares

Expert names 'undervalued' ASX 200 healthcare stock to buy today

A top fundie expects more outperformance from this resurgent ASX healthcare share.

Read more »

A gavel is placed on a stand on a desk with a legal representative wearing a suit in the background.
Healthcare Shares

Cochlear shares fall as investors face another setback

Cochlear shares are back in the red.

Read more »

Doctor with stethoscope typing on her computer.
Healthcare Shares

Is the Medibank share price a buy for its 6% dividend yield?

This business is offering very healthy dividends.

Read more »