Woodside vs Fortescue shares: One I'd buy and one I'd sell

Here's what we can expect over the next 12 months.

Key points
  • Woodside is viewed as a buy due to potential tailwinds from recovering oil prices, with analysts projecting a potential upside of up to 27.8%, despite recent challenges to crude prices.
  • Fortescue shares, though recently boosted by resilient iron ore prices, are seen as a sell due to the company's lack of diversification and potential vulnerability to future iron ore price declines.
  • Analysts, including Macquarie, express caution on Fortescue, assigning an underperform rating with a target price indicating a potential 9.1% downside.

Woodside Energy Group Ltd (ASX: WDS) and Fortescue Ltd (ASX: FMG) are two of the largest resource stocks on the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO). Their shares move for very different reasons, their risks differ, and the outlook for one is much stronger than the other.

When it comes to these two powerhouses, I'd buy one but sell the other.

A boy in a green shirt holds up his hands in front of a screen full of question marks.

Image source: Getty Images

I'd buy Woodside shares

Woodside shares closed 0.11% lower on Wednesday afternoon, at $26.27 a piece. Over the past month, the Australian petroleum exploration and production company's shares are 18.01% higher, and over the year, they're up 7.71%. The company's share price pushed higher on the back of a steep uptick in the crude oil price in late October. 

Unfortunately, the latest increase hasn't done much to recover the crude oil price losses over the year. It is still 13.35% lower than 12 months ago and well below the peaks seen in 2022. 

Thankfully, Woodside shares have remained relatively stable, and the company has been able to maintain strong dividends throughout the year.

While the dwindling oil prices have dampened Woodside's performance potential, it looks like the company could be set for some tailwinds going forward.

Fairmont Equities' Michael Gable recently said that the share price chart of Woodside indicates the stock has bottomed, amid seeing signs of it starting to move higher again. Although the broker currently has a hold rating on the shares.

Other brokers are more bullish on the stock. TradingView data shows 7 out of 15 analysts have a buy or strong buy rating on the shares. The remaining 8 have a hold rating. The maximum target price is $33.57, which represents a potential 27.8% upside for investors over the next 12 months.

I'd sell Fortescue shares

Fortescue shares closed 2.16% higher on Wednesday afternoon, at $20.36 each. Over the past month, the shares have climbed 0.99% higher, and they're now up 14.7% compared to this time last year. 

The iron ore mining giant's shares have been boosted by the recent resilience of the iron ore price. Iron ore has recovered from an annual low in July. Over the past month, it has fallen 1.18%, but it is still 2.27% higher than a year ago, according to trading on a contract for difference (CFD) that tracks the benchmark market for this commodity.

Fortescue also posted its September quarter results on 23 October. The miner reported record total iron ore shipments over the three months of 49.7 million tonnes, up 4% year on year.

But I'm concerned that, given Fortescue isn't a diversified miner like some of the other mining majors, any further pull-back in iron ore prices over the next 12 months could have a huge impact on Fortescue's financials.

Analysts seem to have the same sentiment, too. Macquarie has assigned an underperform rating to Fortescue shares and a target price of $18.50. That represents a potential 9.1% downside for investors at the time of writing.

Motley Fool contributor Samantha Menzies has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Macquarie Group. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Macquarie Group. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Opinions

A fit woman in workout gear flexes her muscles with two bigger people flexing behind her, indicating growth.
Opinions

I wanted growth, not hype. Only 3 ASX shares passed my checks

One of these ASX shares is tipped to climb up to 38%.

Read more »

rubbish bins
Opinions

I've always loved Wesfarmers shares. But after a trip to Kmart, I'm not so sure

A weekend trip took some gloss off this stock.

Read more »

Piles of increasing coins alongside an hourglass.
Opinions

Why I'm planning to buy more Soul Patts shares in 2027

I think Soul Patts is a great long-term buy.

Read more »

a close up of a woman's face looks skywards as she is showered in a sea of graphic symbols of gold and silver coins bearing the bitcoin logo.
Cryptocurrencies

Are you a 'greater fool' for owning Bitcoin?

Is Bitcoin truly an investment?

Read more »

A woman in a red dress holding up a red graph.
Opinions

I went looking for shares which could double by 2030. These 3 made my shortlist

All of these shares are in recovery mode.

Read more »

A little girl is surprised at a science experiment.
Opinions

2 ASX shares with the potential to double in a year, and the risk that keeps me cautious

One of these ASX shares could climb up to 123% higher.

Read more »

A man in business attire plunges into water.
Opinions

My 2027 ASX shortlist started with 50 shares. It ended with these 3

There's no such thing as a perfect ASX share, but these three tick my boxes.

Read more »

A man in a business suit uses a rope to climb up the side of a huge pile of papers fashioned like a tall building against a blue sky backdrop with clouds representing an assessment of whether CBA shares stacked up well in March
Opinions

CBA shares: I investigated the bull and bear case. Here's my verdict

The market is split, so I did my own research.

Read more »