Leading broker names 1 ASX 200 share to buy and 1 to hold

Here's what the broker is saying about these shares.

Key points
  • Ramelius Resources is seen as an exciting buy by Morgans, with gold production expected to double by FY30 and a promising outlook on free cash flow, suggesting over 25% upside potential.
  • Treasury Wine Estates, however, faces challenges with excess inventory and soft demand in key markets, leading to a cautious hold rating as it navigates internal culture shifts and strategic changes under new leadership.
  • While Ramelius is poised for growth with improved fundamentals, Treasury's path involves restructuring and strategic realignment, offering investors different avenues based on risk tolerance and investment goals.

Looking for some new additions to your portfolio?

If you are, it could be worth hearing what Ord Minnett is saying about a couple of popular ASX 200 shares.

One of them is rated as a buy and the other is a hold. Here's what the broker is recommending:

Two male ASX 200 analysts stand in an office looking at various computer screens showing share prices.

Image source: Getty Images

Ramelius Resources Ltd (ASX: RMS)

Ord Minnett notes that this ASX 200 gold share has released its five-year production outlook.

The company is expecting to double its production to 500,000 ounces by the end of the decade. And while its free cash flow will be a little lower than expected, it doesn't think this should put investors off. It said:

Ramelius Resources delivered a five-year outlook following its recent Spartan acquisition that forecasts gold production will more than double to circa 500,000 ounces a year by FY30, although free cashflow (FCF) will take a hit of circa 23% versus consensus estimates in FY26 before improving from there, with the outlook signalling upgrades of 25% for market expectations for FCF over FY27–30.

Some additional capital expenditure has been brought forward to FY26 to expand the Mt Magnet mill capacity to around 4.3 million tonnes of ore per annum (Mtpa) by FY28 – construction starts March quarter next year with completion scheduled for the September quarter in 2027, but the net impact over FY27–30 and beyond should be broadly positive versus previous consensus estimates.

Overall, the broker feels that recent share price weakness has been overdone and that it is trading at an attractive level compared to peers. It adds:

In our view, the steep pull-back in the Ramelius stock price since early October is not commensurate with the improving fundamentals of its business, and the stock now screens even more attractively versus its peers, e.g. a price to net asset value multiple of 0.8x versus the 1.2x pricing of its peers. ‍ We anticipate outperformance on continued production growth, delivery of increased FCF, and organic news flow which could drive further upside.

Morgans has a buy rating and $4.50 price target on the gold miner's shares. This implies potential upside of over 25% for investors over the next 12 months.

Treasury Wine Estates Ltd (ASX: TWE)

Another ASX 200 share that Ord Minnett has been looking at is wine giant Treasury Wine Estates.

The broker has taken an axe to its valuation for the Penfolds owner following a review of its model as its new CEO takes over. It explains:

Ord Minnett has reviewed its Treasury Wine Estates model as new CEO Sam Fischer takes the reins, which has led to significant changes to our FY26 earnings forecast and a steep reduction in our target price to $6.50 from $8.00. Our changes are driven by the following factors: (i) excessive inventory in its Americas business, which will need to be cleared – we forecast revenue declines of $150 million at a margin of 55% as stock is depleted from its sales channels; (ii) weak demand for its Penfold products in China during the mid-autumn festival season; and (iii) removal of earn-out payments on its acquisition of Daou Vineyards in 2023.

Further on the Americas segment, the new boss will need to consider Treasury's future in what has always been a difficult US market, with the company lacking scale and the high-profile brands, Daou excluded, to compete in what is a highly fragmented market.

Morgans has a hold rating and $6.50 price target on its shares, suggesting that upside of 13% is possible from current levels.

Motley Fool contributor James Mickleboro has positions in Treasury Wine Estates. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Treasury Wine Estates. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Broker Notes

Woman holding her glasses and looking at her laptop.
Broker Notes

Buy, hold, sell: Deep Yellow, SGH, Telstra shares

We review three fresh buy, hold, and sell calls from expert market analysts. 

Read more »

View of a row of blue and black server racks in a data centre.
Broker Notes

How high does Macquarie think Megaport shares will go?

Shares in this technology company are looking cheap, the broker says.

Read more »

A happy group of workers around a table raise their arms in the air as though celebrating a work achievement. One woman is on her feet with her arm raised in the air in a fist-pumping action.
Broker Notes

Brokers tip up to 67% for these 3 ASX shares

All three are rated a strong buy

Read more »

A mining worker wearing a white hardhat and a high vis vest stands on a platform overlooking a huge mine, thinking about what comes next.
Broker Notes

7 ASX mining shares with 11% to 158% upside ahead: experts

Brokers have updated their ratings and price targets on BHP, Mineral Resources, and others. 

Read more »

Two male ASX 200 analysts stand in an office looking at various computer screens showing share prices.
Broker Notes

6 ASX shares upgraded by experts amid a weak market 

Brokers have increased their ratings on Capricorn Metals, REA Group, and others this week. 

Read more »

woman on phone
Broker Notes

With $2.4 billion in FY26 profits, are Telstra shares a good buy today?

A leading expert delivers his outlook for Telstra shares.

Read more »

Woman looking at her computer and pondering something.
Broker Notes

Barrenjoey tips this ASX financial stock to rise 73%

A new deal has impressed the analysts.

Read more »

Sell written several times on board.
Broker Notes

Sell alert! Expert calls time on Corporate Travel and CBA shares

A leading expert expects CBA and Corporate Travel shares to face significant headwinds.

Read more »