Should Australians invest for growth or income in superannuation?

What type of investments would make the best choice?

Key points
  • Australians have various asset options for superannuation investments, including cash, bonds, property, and shares, which should be chosen based on income vs. growth potential.
  • Shares, despite their volatility, can offer excellent long-term returns, particularly growth shares that benefit from compounding and are taxed less frequently.
  • In retirement, dividend shares can provide stable cash flow, though growth shares or ETFs may be more effective to allow those assets to last for decades.

Putting money into superannuation is widely seen as one of the best things Australians can do for their long-term wealth. But, it's not as clear cut what the right type of investments in superannuation are.

There is a wide range of assets that people can choose to invest in, such as cash, bonds, property, infrastructure, Australian shares and global shares.

I think many assets can be boiled down to whether a majority/all of the asset's return comes from income or growth.

There isn't one answer that fits every investor's goals and preferences, but there are certainly some factors that investors should consider.

Australian notes and coins surrounded by a calculator and the word super spelt out.

Image source: Getty Images

Accumulation phase

It's great how superannuation contributions are taxed at a lower rate than normal income for working Australians.

Investment earnings are also taxed at a lower rate in superannuation than in our personal names.

But, what makes the most sense to invest in as we build our nest egg towards retirement?

For plenty of Australians, reaching retirement age could be decades away. That gives us plenty of time to build up our asset base.

It's true that shares are one of the most volatile asset classes year to year. However, shares have also generated excellent wealth-growing returns over the ultra-long-term.

When someone has an investment horizon measured in decades, it's much easier to be patient and ride through those volatile share market times. If we're going to retire in 30 years from now, it doesn't really matter what happens with volatility in the next year or in 2027. What's going to deliver the biggest return over the decades?

In terms of growth shares or dividend shares in superannuation, I'd prefer to go for growth shares. Not only could those businesses grow their earnings at a faster pace thanks to the power of compounding, but it may also mean less of the return lost to tax along the journey.

Every time a dividend/other income is paid, it's taxed. However, growth shares aren't taxed when they go up in value. Capital growth is only taxed when the asset is sold.

Retirement phase

Australians entering superannuation may have a range of assets already, so an individual strategy and course of action may be appropriate to figure out with a financial planner.

ASX dividend shares can be particularly effective for Australians in retirement because of their ability to deliver a materially pleasing level of cash flow for investors thanks to the good dividend yield. Certain ASX dividend shares can provide investors with a pleasingly stable (and growing) payout.

Some retirees may not want to be exposed to the higher volatility of growth shares in retirement, even if they may be able to deliver stronger returns over the long-term. Don't forget, investors can sell a small portion of their shares each year to create cash flow, it doesn't have to come from dividends. I like strong-performing exchange-traded funds (ETFs) such as VanEck MSCI International Quality ETF (ASX: QUAL) for a strategy like that.

Remember, even in retirement, a retiree may need their assets to last for decades, so it's worthwhile being invested in (ASX) shares because of how they can deliver the strongest return over the decades and help wealth creation. That's why (ASX) shares can be such good investments at any stage of superannuation, in my view.

Motley Fool contributor Tristan Harrison has positions in VanEck Msci International Quality ETF. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Superannuation

Person holding Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
Superannuation

How much superannuation do I need to earn $56,000 per year in passive income?

How much do you have stashed away?

Read more »

Happy couple kayaking together.
Superannuation

Here's the average Australian superannuation balance at 57 and 67

Let's see what the average person has in their super at these ages.

Read more »

A wad of $100 bills of Australian currency lies stashed in a bird's nest.
Superannuation

How much is needed in superannuation for $1500 in weekly passive income?

Let's lay out in black and white how much you need to save.

Read more »

Different coloured piggy banks on different coloured squares.
Superannuation

How much do I need in my superannuation to retire comfortably at age 67?

How does your superannuation balance stack up?

Read more »

Senior couple sledding in the snow.
Superannuation

How much is needed in superannuation to target a $10,000 monthly passive income?

This is how I’d go about generating $10,000 of annual passive income.

Read more »

Australian dollar notes around a piggy bank.
Superannuation

How much should I have in my superannuation at age 55?

How much do you have stashed away for retirement?

Read more »

Retirement plan written on a chalkboard with increasing bar graphs and dollar signs on top.
Superannuation

Why I'd invest $50,000 of superannuation in New Hope, Mineral Resources and BHP shares

New Hope, Mineral Resources, and BHP shares offer surprising diversity for your superannuation investment.

Read more »

A happy couple looking at an iPad.
Superannuation

Here's the average Australian superannuation balance in SMSFs

Let’s see how wealthy Australian SMSF investors have become…

Read more »