Why is it so mentally challenging to buy more of my favourite ASX stock after its share price has fallen?

Being greedy when others are fearful sounds a lot easier than it is…

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Along an ASX stock market investing journey, one will inevitably come up against psychological barriers, intrinsic personality traits that will prevent one from achieving the best results possible from an investing portfolio.

There are many of these barriers and traps. They typically include trying to time the market, following the herd or investing in a hot fad for the fear of missing out on 'easy' gains that others are conspicuously enjoying.

The market correction that we've been enduring over the past few weeks will inevitably bring up another one of these insidious barriers: buying more of your favourite investments after its share price has fallen.

We humans tend to assume that the market's pricing mechanisms are always correct. This can feel great when we buy an ASX stock that subsequently goes up in value. The market is effectively endorsing our decisions, letting us know that we made the right choice by giving us additional money, at least on paper. This isn't really a barrier to success.

However, its evil twin is. Just as we tend to think the market endorses our wins, we also tend to assume that it punishes our losses when the price of an ASX stock that we have already bought falls below our buy price.

If the market is always correct, then it is painfully pointing out our mistakes when this happens. It can be enough to discourage us from buying those shares of our favourite company ever again. Or at least until its ASX stock price goes back up to where it was before, and then even higher.

Only then, you might realise that you've missed a rare opportunity to buy stock of what remains a great business at a firesale price.

A young woman looks at something on her laptop, wondering what will come next.

Image source: Getty Images

ASX stocks: How to be greedy when others are fearful

There is also the inherent fear factor. If we buy a particular ASX stock at $50 a share, and those shares drop to $40, our brains can have a tendency to tell us that that particular company is a rotten apple, and any subsequent investments will result in another loss of money. That's regardless of the fundamentals of the business, of course. Our brains aren't very good at keeping those at front of mind during a market panic.

Overcoming these biases, these psychological barriers, is mentally challenging. But it is essential to do so if anyone wishes to become a successful investor. But don't take it from me; take it from legendary investor Warren Buffett. Here's some of what Buffett said about buying shares in a different market slump way back in 2000:

If you have a temperament that when others are fearful, you're going to get scared yourself, you know, you are not going to make a lot of money in securities [shares] over time, in all probability…

If they buy a stock and they think if it goes up it's wonderful, and if it goes down it's bad. We think just the opposite. When it goes down, we love it, because we'll buy more. And if it goes up, it kills us to buy more.

So how can we overcome these barriers? Well, I'm not a psychologist. But I can tell you what's worked for me personally.

I too have faced, and occasionally been tripped up by, these psychological trappings. To combat this, I wrote out my investing game plan for the next few years. I thought about what I would do, and which shares I would buy in a market downturn, and I recorded it on a piece of paper that is now pinned to my wall. Before I make any moves in the stock market, buys or sells, I read this paper, and ask myself how this move will fit into my long-term plan.

This worked well for me during the COVID crash of 2020 when I was able to buy shares of many of my favourite ASX businesses at very low stock prices. I am hoping it works for me again during the potentially tough times ahead. Your own mind can be one of the largest barriers you will face on the way to investing success. Knowing this is a victory in itself. But the true victory is having a plan to overcome them and sticking to it.

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen has positions in Berkshire Hathaway. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Berkshire Hathaway. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Berkshire Hathaway. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on ASX Share Market News

Man controlling a drone in the sky.
Broker Notes

Defence Duel: Are Elsight or DroneShield shares a better buy right now?

These defence stocks have big upside.

Read more »

Two work colleagues looking at a laptop and discussing something.
Broker Notes

Why cheap WiseTech shares could rise almost 60%

Bell Potter has given its view on this tech stock following its results.

Read more »

Businessman at his desk, looking seriously at information on his digital tablet.
ASX Share Market News

5 things to watch on the ASX 200 on Thursday

There are some big results due to be released today.

Read more »

A group of three builders wearing worker overalls and carrying hard hats in their hands jumps jubilantly atop a rooftop space on a commercial building.
Broker Notes

This ASX builder is well positioned for 40% share price growth: Broker

This company is in the box seat for the big Olympics build.

Read more »

Three women athletes lie flat on a running track as though they have had a long hard race where they have fought hard but lost the event.
Share Gainers

Here are the top 10 ASX 200 shares today

It was a disappointing showing from the market this hump day.

Read more »

Man and woman sitting at table with the man looking a bit puzzled at his laptop.
52-Week Highs

South32, Woolworths, BHP shares reach 52-week high: Buy, sell or hold?

Brokers only rate one of these ASX shares as a buy.

Read more »

Hour glass with graph points rising.
ASX Share Market News

ASX 200 closes in on record territory as BHP and Woolworths surge

The ASX 200 is nearing record highs after another strong session.

Read more »

An old-fashioned news boy stands on a stool and yells through a microphone in an open field.
ASX Share Market News

Why Woolworths, Domino's and DroneShield shares are turning heads on Wednesday

Woolworths, DroneShield, and Domino’s shares are making waves today. But why?

Read more »