Here's why I don't buy ASX dividend shares with big yields anymore

A big dividend yield can sometimes make you poorer.

When I first started investing in ASX shares, I gravitated towards dividend stocks with large yields. At the time, you could only get a savings account with a yield of around 3.5%. So buying a dividend share with a yield of 4% or 5% seemed like a no-brainer.

However, buying up big-yielding ASX dividend shares is no longer a goal that I pursue in my share portfolio. In fact, most of my recent purchases have been stocks with yields well under what a savings account can provide today.

So why the change of heart? Did I suddenly lose my taste for receiving a sizeable dividend paycheque in the mail?

Hardly.

I love passive dividend income as much as the next investor. Especially if it comes fully franked.

However, I've realised that, as an investor at my age and with my life goals, maximising dividend income isn't the best use of my money today.

I am aiming to compound my money and grow my wealth at the highest rate possible. Dividends are great. But the ASX shares that usually pay the highest dividends right now are companies that are mature, with most of their growth behind them.

Take two of my earliest ASX share buys, National Australia Bank Ltd (ASX: NAB) and Telstra Group Ltd (ASX: TLS). Both are wonderful businesses and remain in my portfolio. However, there's almost no chance I will add to these positions going forward. I might even sell them this year.

These companies are simply not growing at a fast clip anymore. That's why they choose to spend most of their free cash flow paying shareholders dividends and buying back their own stock.

There's nothing wrong with that, of course. It's great for retirees and other investors who rely on big dividend paycheques. But for someone like me who wants to grow their wealth by at least the market's rate of return, I think there are better opportunities elsewhere.

Accountant woman counting an Australian money and using calculator for calculating dividend yield.

Image source: Getty Images

ASX dividend shares: Choosing growth over income

An ASX share I hope to buy soon provides a nice contrast.

TechnologyOne Ltd (ASX: TNE) is an ASX tech stock that has been delivering blistering rates of growth. Sure, it only pays a dividend yield of 0.76% today. However, this company managed to grow its revenues by 17% in FY24 and profits before tax by 18%. Its 2024 dividend payouts grew by 14.87% over what it paid out in 2023.

At 81.97 times earnings, TechnologyOne shares are currently a little too pricey to warrant me buying them. But if I can get these shares at a decent discount, I think they would blow past what NAB or Telstra could net me in total returns.

If I hold these shares for long enough, and that dividend growth rate keeps up, it won't be too long until I'm getting a Telstra-like yield on my cost anyway.

As such, I'd rather have a company that grows its revenues and earnings by double digits every year than one with low single-digit growth, but offers a big dividend yield.

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen has positions in National Australia Bank and Telstra Group. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has positions in and has recommended Technology One. The Motley Fool Australia has positions in and has recommended Telstra Group. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Technology One. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Dividend Investing

Numerous Australian dollar notes laid out.
Dividend Investing

Aurizon Holdings vs Atlas Arteria: Which ASX 200 high-yield share wins for reliable passive income?

Aurizon and Atlas Arteria both offer yields above 6%, but which is the safer option?

Read more »

Smiling woman with her head and arm on a desk holding $100 notes, symbolising dividends.
Dividend Investing

Vanguard ETFs will pay dividends today. Here's how much

Vanguard manages some of the most popular ASX ETFs including VAS, VHY, VGS, and VEQ.

Read more »

Man holding Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
Dividend Investing

2 ASX dividend shares with 40% to 120% upside

A leading broker sees big yields and bigger returns on offer here.

Read more »

Woman holding $50 and $20 notes.
Dividend Investing

Dividend payday for ASX ETF investors! Here is how much you'll get

Own ASX A200, DHHF, or other Betashares ETFs? You will receive dividends today.

Read more »

A wallet with an Australian one hundred dollar note poking out sits on top of an electricity meter with the numbers rapidly going up.
Dividend Investing

How many Origin Energy shares do I need for $1,000 per month of passive income in FY27?

Find out what it takes to earn $12,000 every year in passive income.

Read more »

Woman with headphones on relaxing and looking at her phone happily.
Dividend Investing

Why this ASX dividend share is a retiree's dream for 2027

This business is a strong pick for dividends, in my view.

Read more »

Man reading his emails on a laptop while relaxing on a beach.
Dividend Investing

WAM Leaders vs Growthpoint Properties: Which 7%+ yield stock looks better for passive income?

Chasing passive income? Here’s which high-yield stock I think looks better.

Read more »

Man holding out $50 and $100 notes in his hands, symbolising ex dividend.
Dividend Investing

2 ASX shares with dividend yields above 9%

These stocks offer very high dividend yields.

Read more »