Is it madness to buy CBA shares now?

Would I buy CBA shares today? Let's see.

On the surface, it looks as though this Wednesday's session has been a rough one for Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA) shares. At the time of writing, the CBA share price has lost 1.32% of its value and is back to around $142.30. 

That's a decent loss, to be sure. However, when you consider that this move merely puts CBA about 2% below its current all-time record high of $145.24, things suddenly don't look so dire, particularly when we consider that this ASX 200 bank stock only hit that new record last month.

Despite today's retreat, CBA shares remain up a huge 25.35% in 2024 to date, as well as an even more impressive 48% over the past 12 months. Check it out for yourself below:

As we discussed just yesterday, this rapid ascension of the CBA share price might elicit some mixed reactions, depending on whether one currently owns this bank stock.

However, there's little doubt that anyone who is thinking about buying more CBA shares today is probably weighing up the wisdom of purchasing more of this bank when its share price has risen so enthusiastically.

Well, let's debate whether buying CBA today is a good long-term bet or just pure madness.

A man looking at his laptop and thinking.

Image source: Getty Images

Is the CBA share price a buy so close to record highs today?

Unfortunately, for CBA bulls, I have to admit that I relate to the latter characterisation far more than the former.

I tend to agree with the views of Peter Warnes that we covered yesterday, in which CBA shares' blistering rise appears to be disconnected from this company's fundamentals. Warnes argued that:

Despite a price/earnings ratio (PER) of 24, typically reserved for companies with strong growth potential, CBA's compound annual growth in earnings per share was just 1.1% over the past decade. I suggest future growth will be modest, circa 5% at best, making the current P/E and PEG ratios unsustainable.

Back in August, CBA delivered its full-year earnings report, covering FY2024. For the year to 30 June 2024, the bank reported that its operating income was flat at $27.17 billion, its operating expenses were up 3% to $12.22 billion, and its cash net profits after tax were down 2% to $9.84 billion.

These figures, at least to me, in no way justify this bank's near-50% gain over the past 12 months. In fact, they make this gain look completely unjustified. I also agree with Warnes' assertion that there aren't many growth opportunities in easy reach for CBA going forward.

As such, I think buying CBA shares today isn't quite madness, but it is certainly highly optimistic. Remember, you don't even get the comfort of a bank-standard dividend with CBA today. Its recent share price explosion has resulted in the company trading on a dividend yield of just 3.27% right now.

All in all, I am staying well away from this bank stock at its current levels. I just cannot envisage a scenario that prompts CBA to trade meaningfully higher anytime soon. I could be wrong, as I have been in the past, on this one. But even so, that's my position, and I'm sticking to it.

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Bank Shares

Animated man balancing on a chart with a red and green arrow symbolising volatility.
Bank Shares

NAB shares: I weighed up the bull and bear case. Here's my call

Can the bank overcome its latest headwinds?

Read more »

Work colleagues discussing finance charts and graphs on a laptop computer and tablet in their office.
Bank Shares

Why I'd buy NAB shares but not Westpac shares

I've been comparing the latest results, and there's one area of the business that gives me greater confidence in my…

Read more »

Smiling woman look at her computer screen.
Bank Shares

3 reasons I would buy ANZ Bank shares at under $40

There's still work ahead, but I think the improvements underway could lead to stronger profits over time.

Read more »

Work colleagues discussing finance charts and graphs on a laptop computer and tablet in their office.
Bank Shares

CBA just delivered another $2.8 billion quarter. Would I buy the bank's shares?

The latest results showed stronger profits, but there are signs that some borrowers are feeling the pressure.

Read more »

Numerous Australian dollar notes laid out.
Bank Shares

How much must I invest in Westpac shares to earn $2,000 of dividend income?

Can Westpac be a good source of dividends?

Read more »

A man thinks very carefully about his money and investments.
Bank Shares

Everything you need to know about the latest ANZ dividend

The bank’s latest dividend has just been announced.

Read more »

Happy wife holding her hands on her husband's shoulders while both look at a laptop.
Bank Shares

Should I buy ANZ shares after it reported a $7.6 billion FY26 profit?

The latest results had some disappointments, but I think there are good reasons to take a closer look at the…

Read more »

Man working on a laptop from home.
Bank Shares

Why I'd buy Macquarie shares after today's results

The latest results contained some impressive figures and a few disappointments. Here's why I'm looking at it after the sell-off.

Read more »