Why falling in love with your ASX shares can cost you big time

There are inherent dangers in just listening to our investment hearts.

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

ASX shares can be a great tool to build wealth, but it's important not to get wrapped up in a particular stock or sector.

Some investments have demonstrated a long-term track record of compounding growth, without the large swings of booms and busts.

However, we've also seen some big bubbles burst. It's a good idea to avoid those alluring investments which could be a trap, particularly if looking we're at them after there has already been a huge jump in their share prices.

an attractive young woman with sad eyes holds a red paper love heart over her mouth as though she has been unlucky in love.

Image source: Getty Images

The danger of loving a volatile investment

Henry Jennings from Marcus Today was recently quoted in The Age, explaining why it can be dangerous:

Because love is blind, you need to make sure that you have fallen for the right one. You need to check that you are not blindly following a sector or trend.

Hot sectors attract less than scrupulous companies who are more interested in a pump and dump and raising money to pay directors. There will be many pretenders. Only a few winners.

Don't get sucked into the next big thing. Do lots of research and continually question whether the project stands up.

Everyone loves a good story. The idea that an ASX small-cap share can generate large returns is really appealing, particularly if it has plans on how to do it. A business that is developing a new healthcare treatment or looking for a new mineral deposit could do extraordinarily well if it's successful.

But those speculative ideas sometimes don't play out as positively as the company would hope, to the detriment of the investors backing the business. That's why those types of ideas are seen as high risk and why there's more potential for capital losses.

I'll also point out the danger of the market getting too far ahead of itself with an ASX share (or sector), even if it's not a risky biotech share or a resource explorer.

The valuation needs to make sense

When we invest in ASX shares, we're not just buying ticker codes – there are real businesses involved.

I don't think there's much point investing in a company that's seemingly never going to make a profit. After all, making a profit is the main point of being in business.

Businesses are only going to be able to make a certain amount of profit in the future (not infinity). Some analysts like to do a discounted cash flow analysis to try to work out how much the business should be worth.

That profit is going to be worth a certain amount to the market at the time, whether that's three years down the line, five years, or any particular timeframe.

Does today's price actually make sense for how much profit may be made in three years? Is there a fair chance the profit may not be as large or as certain as the market is pricing it? The market already knows about the 'optimistic' case for the business, such as growing lithium demand or a store rollout plan. But is today's price actually undervaluing the opportunity?

Sometimes investors get way too ahead of themselves, sending a share price up a huge amount when it's based on a temporary factor. An example is when a cyclical commodity price is at the top of its cycle.

Time and again, I've seen investors price a cyclical ASX share as though the conditions are seemingly permanent. It pays to remember a strong commodity price may not last forever. However, weak conditions may not last forever either.

It could be a mistake to price a business as though the commodity price will stay low. Personally, this is when I like to pounce on opportunities. Retail is another sector that can see changing conditions and investor confidence.

Foolish takeaway

It's a good idea to do research about the positive potential of an investment. But don't get wrapped up in the story without taking into account the price and what the market is implying with a company's market capitalisation.

If we overpay for a business that's overshot a 'fair price' then, at some point, there could be a danger of a sizeable share price decline. So the bigger the safety margin we buy with, the better.

Some people end up selling out of their investments when their investments go down, locking in a loss. It goes without saying that buying high and selling low is not a strategy we should follow.  

Motley Fool contributor Tristan Harrison has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Investing Strategies

A panel of four judges hold up cards all showing the perfect score of ten out of ten
Growth Shares

10 excellent ASX shares to buy in May

Here is a selection of high-quality shares that could be in the buy zone this month.

Read more »

View of a business man's hand passing a $100 note to another with a bank in the background.
Bank Shares

New ANZ dividend: Here's everything you need to know

ANZ's new dividend has just been revealed.

Read more »

A man points at a paper as he holds an alarm clock, indicating the ex-dividend date is approaching.
Dividend Investing

16 ASX shares going ex-dividend in May

Newmont is among the ASX shares to go ex-dividend this month.

Read more »

man holding two stacks of coins varying in size representing a comparison of dividend yields between Medibank and NIB
Blue Chip Shares

How are Australia's biggest ASX stocks really tracking in 2026?

Some blue chips lag while others surge, however opportunity remains.

Read more »

a group of smart looking kids, wearing formal clothes and all with spectacles, sit in a line and smile charmingly.
Blue Chip Shares

3 ASX 200 shares for smart investors in May

Let's see what could make these smart picks for the month ahead.

Read more »

Man with a rocket strapped to his back on a tiny bicycle ready to take off.
Growth Shares

2 ASX shares tipped to grow 90% or more in the next 12 months!

These stocks have the potential to deliver major returns!

Read more »

Young businesswoman sitting in kitchen and working on laptop.
Growth Shares

Down 67%, is this ASX 300 share a bargain buy?

A sharp share price decline has reset expectations, but the underlying growth story and market opportunity have not changed.

Read more »

Smiling couple sitting on a couch with laptops fist pump each other.
Cheap Shares

2 ASX 200 shares down 50% that I would buy today

Short-term pressure has weighed on these businesses, but their underlying positions may not have changed as much as the share…

Read more »