The Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX: CBA) share price is back over the $100 mark in early trade on Wednesday.
The $169 billion S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) giant plummeted 7% over the course of September – known to be the worst month for markets. It's since picked itself up by the bootstraps, lifting 10% so far this month.
The CBA share price closed at $99.78 on Tuesday and, at the time of writing, is $100.69, a rise of 0.91%.
But with such a recovery under its belt, does the banking giant's stock still offer investors upside?
Is now a good time to buy CBA shares?
CBA is the ASX 200's biggest bank and a resoundingly popular share. But optimistic experts are few and far between.
JP Morgan is said to believe the banking giant "offers the best leverage to rising rates and has the most defensive loan book". For that reason, the broker commented:
We struggle to see CBA underperforming its peers meaningfully.
Rate hikes, like the six implemented by the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) this year, let banks reprice their loan offerings, thereby increasing their net interest margins (NIM) and, in turn, their profits. Though, rising rates also bring risks for banks' loan books.
On a less positive note, CBA is JP Morgans' least preferred ASX 200 bank, as my Fool colleague Bronwyn reports.
Turning to other brokers, Credit Suisse had a $102.80 price target and a neutral rating on the biggest bank's stock late last month, my colleague James reports. That represents a potential 3% upside.
The broker also expects CBA to grow its dividends, tipping it to pay out $4.25 per share in financial year 2023. That would mark a 10% increase on the $3.85 per share CBA paid in financial year 2022.
Turning to the bears, Goldman Sachs rates the stock a sell while Morgan Stanley is said to have slapped it with an $85.50 price target, according to Livewire, representing a potential 14% downside.
Morgan Stanley is also said to be sceptical of the entire banking sector, expecting rate hikes and fiscal consolidation to continue for longer than previously predicted.
Finally, as my Fool colleague Zach covered in depth yesterday, CBA is both the most profitable ASX 200 bank share and the most expensive. It's trading with a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of around 18.
