Are ASX tech shares cheaper than US tech stocks?

After a brutal 12 months, which market could investors pick up the best cloud computing bargains?

Most readers of The Motley Fool don't have to be told twice how much technology shares have suffered this year.

They just need to look at the sea of red in their portfolios as evidence of how much these stocks have re-rated over the past 12 months.

The S&P/ASX All Technology Index (ASX: XTX) has now dropped more than 31% year to date, while the Nasdaq Composite (NASDAQ: .IXIC) has plunged 29.4%.

But as the world approaches the point at which interest rates will stop increasing, it's time to assess where the bargains can be picked up.

Cloud computing is a dominant area of tech that pretty much covers every relevant growth business in the sector. The term simply refers to tech products and services delivered over the internet.

Every quarter, New Zealand's Clare Capital examines the valuations of listed cloud companies in the US and Australia/New Zealand markets.

The latest report provides an insight as to where an investor could secure a better entry point when buying tech shares.

A woman sits at her computer with her hand to her mouth and a contemplative smile on her face as she reads about the performance of Allkem shares on her computer

Image source: Getty Images

US vs ANZ tech valuations

The home of public technology businesses is the United States, which has a plethora of innovative companies listed on both the NYSE and NASDAQ exchanges, all serving a massive population.

Tech is a relatively minor part of the ASX, which is dominated by mining and finance businesses.

Perhaps this explains why investors in the US seem to appreciate cloud companies more.

As of the end of September, Clare Capital's US cloud index shows a median 'enterprise value to next 12 months revenue' ratio of 5.2. 

The ANZ cloud index is positively a bargain compared to that, sitting at a median multiple of 2.8.

So one could conclude that ASX tech companies are now significantly cheaper than their US counterparts.

Clare Capital's methodology involves 93 companies in the US and 50 from Australia and New Zealand.

"It is worth noting that there is a significant company size difference between the two indices, with the median EV of US companies at NZ$8.3 billion versus NZ$0.3 billion for ANZ companies," read the report.

Courtesy: Clare Capital

Tech carnage could now have 'plateaued'

The brutality of 2022 is seen in how Clare Capital's US cloud index has dropped 64% over the past 12 months. The ANZ index has plummeted 48%.

However, the freefall of US cloud companies seems to have "plateaued after a rough year", with the 30 September multiple just 4% lower than the previous quarter.

Meanwhile, the Australia and New Zealand valuations actually increased 9% over the same three months.

While local tech shares are cheaper than the US equivalents, investors will need to carefully examine each company on their potential.

Historically, US tech shares have shown more upside due to a larger addressable market and an investor base more enthusiastic about the sector.

Motley Fool contributor Tony Yoo has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Technology Shares

Sport fans cheering at a game in a stadium.
Technology Shares

Could WiseTech shares smash past $100 in the next 12 months?

WiseTech shares have jumped 12% higher over the past week alone.

Read more »

IT specialist using laptop in data centre full of server racks.
Technology Shares

This small-cap ASX tech stock could more than triple in value: Broker

A new deal could mean big things for this company.

Read more »

Worried woman with hand on her mouth looks at her phone with a laptop open in front of her.
Technology Shares

NEXTDC slashes FY27 guidance after M3 Melbourne power delay

NEXTDC has cut its FY27 revenue and EBITDA guidance after delays to power upgrades at its M3 Melbourne data centre.

Read more »

A silhouette of a soldier flying a drone at sunset.
Technology Shares

Codan has issued yet another profit upgrade

Strong demand for drone technology continues to drive growth.

Read more »

A female scientist in a laboratory setting using a tablet to review data, with a male scientist working in the background.
Technology Shares

Should I buy Pro Medicus shares after its big news?

Another US contract adds to a growth story I think still has a long way to run.

Read more »

Man lying down on sofa and trading on his laptop.
Technology Shares

Zip to consolidate shares 5-for-1 in 2026: What shareholders need to know

Zip plans to consolidate shares 5-for-1, pending shareholder approval at its 2026 AGM.

Read more »

Woman with her kitten on a laptop in her home office.
Technology Shares

Should I buy WiseTech shares after today's big news?

I take another look at the tech stock after an important source of uncertainty was removed.

Read more »

a man sits at a computer in deep thought with hand on chin in a darkened room as though it is late and night and he is working on cybersecurity issues.
Technology Shares

Down 11% in a month: Is it time to buy Xero shares?

Have the ASX tech shares now bottomed? Or is there more downside coming?

Read more »