Why did the AGL share price trail the ASX 200 in September?

The AGL share price tumbled 11% during the month.

| More on:
Stressed business woman sits at desk with head resting on her hand

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points

  • The AGL share price underperformed the broader market in September, falling 11% to close the month at $6.84
  • Its tumble came amid news a generator at the company's Loy Yang A power station would be out of service longer than anticipated and the revelation of its new leadership team
  • To top it off, the company announced its $20 billion plan to ditch coal and provided earnings guidance for financial year 2023

September is generally a rough month for markets, and it was no different in 2022. The S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) slumped 7% last month and the AGL Energy Limited (ASX: AGL) share price put on an even worse performance.

There was plenty of news from the energy producer and retailer in that time. And it all came to a head on Thursday when the company announced its $20 billion plan to ditch coal by 2035.

The AGL share price closed the final session of September at $6.84, 10.9% lower than it finished August.

The ASX 200 dumped 7% in that time while the S&P/ASX 200 Utilities Index (ASX: XUJ) slumped 15%.

So, what went wrong for the AGL share price last month? Let's take a look.

What weighed on AGL's stock in September?

This year has been a rough one so far for ASX 200 energy provider AGL.

The company's planned demerger was binned in May after a brutal campaign led by major shareholder Mike Cannon-Brookes. That saw a number of the company's upper management vow to step down.

Additionally, its Loy Yang A coal-fired power station was dealt a blow in April when one of its generators was taken out of action after an electrical fault.

But why are we delving back into the company's prior suffering? It's because the market heard updates on both happenings last month.

First, AGL revealed the generator would not return to service in September as planned. Its restart date was pushed back to mid-October after a fault was found during testing.

Then, AGL updated the market on its new leadership team.

Former chair Peter Botten stepped down on 19 September as Patricia McKenzie stepped up to the plate. Director Diane Smith-Gander also took her leave.

The company also announced CEO Graeme Hunt planned to exit his role at the end of September. It will be temporarily filled by former chief financial officer Damien Nicks.

But the big news was still to come.

The company released the outcome of its major strategic review on Thursday, vowing to close its Loy Yang power station by financial year 2035. To do so, it will fork out $20 billion to decarbonise its portfolio.

The company also provided earnings guidance.

It predicts it will bring in between $1.25 billion and $1.45 billon of underlying earnings before interest, tax, depreciation, and amortisation (EBITDA) and between $200 million and $320 million of underlying profit after tax in financial year 2023.

AGL share price snapshot

Each of the three announcements released by AGL in September saw its share price trade either flat or lower. However, most of the stock's major falls came on days in which the company was silent.

Instead, the stock seemingly tracked the utilities sector's performance, with only one day in which it went against its peers. On Friday, the AGL share price gained 3.6%, while the utilities sector slumped 1.6%.

But one poor month doesn't make a long-term loss. The AGL share price has gained 8% since the start of 2022. It's also trading 18% higher than it was this time last year.

For comparison, the ASX 200 has fallen 15% year to date and 10% over the last 12 months.

Motley Fool contributor Brooke Cooper has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Energy Shares

Coal miner holding a giant coal rock in his hand making a circle with his hand, symbolising a rising share price.
Energy Shares

Top broker just increased its price target on Whitehaven Coal shares

Can this coal miner keep charging ahead?

Read more »

A group of miners in hard hats sitting in a mine chatting on a break as ASX coal shares perform well today
Energy Shares

This ASX coal giant just delivered a record quarter. Is it back in favour?

Yancoal closes out the year with record production, rising prices, and a stronger balance sheet.

Read more »

Smiling oil worker in front of a pumpjack.
Energy Shares

Is the Santos share price too cheap to ignore?

Is this one of the best value ASX 200 businesses around?

Read more »

ASX uranium shares represented by yellow barrels of uranium
Energy Shares

Why uranium is gaining momentum as 2026 gets underway

Uranium prices are rising again as demand strengthens and supply remains tight entering early 2026.

Read more »

An oil refinery worker stands in front of an oil rig with his arms crossed and a smile on his face as the Woodside share price climbs today
Energy Shares

Is the Woodside share price an opportunity too good to pass up?

This energy business has gotten cheaper. Is it the right time to buy?

Read more »

A woman looks unsure as she ladles mixture into a pan surrounded by small appliances
Energy Shares

Natural gas prices have fallen 22% in a month. Here's what is driving the drop

Natural gas prices have slid 22% in a month as weak demand and strong supply pressure markets.

Read more »

Two people jump in the air in a fighting stance, indicating a battle between rival ASX shares.
Energy Shares

AGL Energy versus Origin Energy shares: Which is a better buy for 2026?

Here’s my pick between the two ASX energy stocks.

Read more »

A woman throws her hands in the air in celebration as confetti floats down around her, standing in front of a deep yellow wall.
Energy Shares

Bell Potter names the best ASX uranium stocks to buy now

The broker has given its verdict on these three stocks

Read more »