15% yield! But are these ASX high-yield shares dividend traps?

When is a 15% yield too good to be true?

| More on:
a man in a business shirt and tie takes a wide leap over a large steel trap with jagged teeth that is place directly underneath him.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points

  • An ASX dividend share with a yield of 15% might sound off some alarm bells for investors
  • But that's what these two ASX shares seem to be offering today
  • Are they bargains of the century, or dreaded dividend traps?

Picking ASX shares that prove to be dividend winners is always a tricky game. As is any other kind of investing for that matter. But it's the unique metrics that dividend investors have to navigate which makes this area of investing a little more unique. All investors know upfront what kind of dividends an ASX share has paid out over the past 12 months. And, by extension, the kind of dividend yield each ASX share may possess.

But as investors should know, just because an ASX share has a high dividend yield, it doesn't mean investors can take that to the bank. A common investing mistake is to choose an ASX dividend share due to a seemingly fat yield, only to have that yield pared back. Not to mention a simultaneous share price fall to boot. This scenario is often described as a 'dividend trap'.

So let's look at some ASX shares today that seem to be offering outsized yields right now. Could any of them be a dreaded dividend trap?

When is a high dividend yield just trap bait?

Magellan Financial Group Ltd (ASX: MFG) is one such share. Magellan has had a horrible year, losing around 66% of its value. But this has pushed up Magellan's trailing dividend yield to an eye-watering 15.57% on current pricing. The interesting thing about Magellan is that when the company reported its half-year earnings last month, it declared an interim dividend of 110.1 cents per share, which coincidentally was paid out today.

That was Magellan's highest-ever interim dividend. So why aren't investors flocking to this company's massive 15%-plus yield? Well, Magellan makes its money from its funds management business. And the company has been experiencing record fund outflows over the past few months for a number of reasons.

So it seems that investors are betting that this outflow will start to bite the company's ability to keep funding dividends at these kinds of levels. We'll have to see if this turns out to be the case, but at least one broker isn't too sure it will.

Another ASX dividend share with a 15% yield right now

Fortescue Metals Group Limited (ASX: FMG) is another ASX dividend share seemingly offering a monster dividend yield right now. On current pricing, the iron ore giant has a trailing dividend yield of close to 15.5%. That's even after the company cut its interim dividend by 41% as announced in its earnings last month. The cut was the result of Fortescue directing more capital towards its emerging Fortescue Future Industries hydrogen business.

Fortescue's profits (and dividends) are intrinsically tied to the price of iron ore itself. Last month, Fortescue announced that its average revenue per dry metric tonne over the half was US$96. But iron ore has continued to boom in recent months, and is now going for a six-month high above US$160 a tonne.

If the iron ore price continues to hold at these levels, and Fortescue can continue to extract it at relatively low costs (made harder recently by surging oil prices), we could well possibly see dividends continue to roll in at these high rates. But again, we shall have to wait and see.

Motley Fool contributor Sebastian Bowen has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Dividend Investing

A mature-aged couple high-five each other as they celebrate a financial win and early retirement
Dividend Investing

5 top ASX dividend shares to buy right now

Analysts think income investors should be loading up on these shares.

Read more »

Two adults and a child look happy as they walk through airport with child sitting on suitcase.
Dividend Investing

Will Qantas shares pay a dividend in 2024?

Will the dividends return this year? Let's find out.

Read more »

A woman sits at her computer with her chin resting on her hand as she contemplates her next potential investment.
Dividend Investing

2 market-leading ASX dividend stocks to buy in April

Analysts have put buy ratings on these market-leaders.

Read more »

Father in the ocean with his daughters, symbolising passive income.
Dividend Investing

I'd spend $8k on these ASX 200 shares today to target a $6,102 annual passive income

I believe these ASX 200 shares will continue rewarding passive income investors for years to come.

Read more »

Man holding Australian dollar notes, symbolising dividends.
ETFs

Want the latest dividend from the Vanguard Australia Shares ETF (VAS)? Here's what you have to do

If you want to bag the latest VAS dividend, here's what you need to do.

Read more »

A smiling businessman in the city looks at his phone and punches the air in celebration of good news.
Dividend Investing

Investing for passive income? Keep any eye out for that boosted Telstra dividend today!

If you own Telstra shares, keep an eye out for that juicy dividend payout today.

Read more »

A happy construction worker or miner holds a fistfull of Australian money, indicating a dividends windfall
Dividend Investing

Invest $12,000 in Woodside stock and get $5,700 in passive income

Reliable dividend shares are everywhere on the ASX. Here's how you could use that to your advantage.

Read more »

Australian dollar notes in businessman pocket suit, symbolising ex dividend day.
Dividend Investing

3 ASX 300 dividend shares to buy in April

These shares have been named as buys by brokers and tipped to offer very attractive yields.

Read more »