Rio Tinto (ASX:RIO) vs Traditional Owners: $400m battle continues

What could be overshadowing the Rio Tinto share price today?

The Rio Tinto Limited (ASX: RIO) share price is under pressure today despite iron ore prices holding firmly at US$135.50 per tonne.

At the time of writing, shares in the world's second-largest metals and mining company are fetching $111.24, down 2.22% from its previous close. Accounting for today's move to the downside, the mining giant's share price is now 19% off of its 52-week high.

The sluggish start to the week for the Rio Tinto share price comes amid a renewed focus on the miner's unresolved royalty dispute with Traditional Owners.

Battle between ASX shares represented by 2 investors facing off short sellers

Image source: Getty Images

A $400 million weight hanging over Rio's head

In July 2020, Rio Tinto discovered and informed the Gumala Aboriginal Corporation (GAC) of an underpayment in relation to the Yandicoogina mine in Western Australia. According to Rio Tinto, these underpayments pertaining to its Land Use Agreement amounted to $40 million.

However, upon conducting a forensic audit, GAC believes the underpayment is $400 million. This is an order of magnitude more than Rio's estimate.

Fast forward more than 18 months, ASX-listed Rio Tinto is still yet to settle its dispute with GAC. The unresolved matter risks overshadowing Rio Tinto's 25th anniversary of its royalty agreement with Traditional Owners in March.

For Rio Tinto, this would only add to its tarnished reputation following the destruction of the culturally significant Juukan Gorge in May 2020.

In an attempt to resolve the underpayment dispute, Rio Tinto is believed to have offered $150 million. The amount is substantially more than the original $40 million offered by the mining company. Although, it is still less than half of what GAC believes to be the rightful figure.

The grey area surrounding the Yandicoogina agreement arises from a difference in how the royalty is determined. Unlike modern arrangements, the much older agreement with GAC is based on the amount of ground disturbance. How 'disturbance' is defined is at the core of this unresolved matter.

Due to these issues, ASX-listed Rio Tinto and GAC are also in the process of negotiating new terms for the agreement. This could see GAC paid based on iron ore sales instead of ground disturbance. In addition, GAC is fighting for part of future royalties to be paid in Rio Tinto shares.

Unearthing Rio Tinto share price performance

The performance of the Rio Tinto share price is flat over the last 12 months. Shares in the mining giant have tumbled in tandem with iron ore prices.

For comparison, the S&P/ASX 200 Index (ASX: XJO) is up 4.8% in the past year. This means ASX-listed Rio Tinto has underperformed the market by ~5%. However, it has provided a better return than other iron ore peers. An example is Fortescue Metals Group Limited (ASX: FMG), which is down 13% in the last year.

Motley Fool contributor Mitchell Lawler has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Bruce Jackson.

More on Resources Shares

Two workers working with a large copper coil in a factory.
Resources Shares

Why you might want to buy BHP shares before next week

Copper will be key to BHP's fortunes going forward.

Read more »

A woman sits on a step laughing at something on her mobile phone as it is being charged by a lithium-powered battery.
Resources Shares

This ASX lithium stock could soar 327% or more, brokers say

The most bullish experts think the shares could rise up to 505% over the next 12 months.

Read more »

Copper balls.
Resources Shares

Copper price falls to 6-month low, taking Rio Tinto and BHP shares with it

The copper price has become a barometer of investor confidence in the US AI investment boom.

Read more »

Woman and man worker in quarry on excavation machine looking at a clipboard.
Resources Shares

At $143, are Rio Tinto shares oversold or overpriced?

Find out where brokers expect the shares to travel next.

Read more »

a man in a business suit points his finger amid a digitised map of the globe suspended in the air in front of him, complete with graphs, digital code and glyphs to indicate digital assets.
Resources Shares

2 ASX shares tipped to grow up to 35% in the next 12 months

These stocks may have a very exciting future.

Read more »

Young businesswoman sitting in kitchen and working on laptop.
Resources Shares

Could the BHP share price return more than 10% in 2027?

The shares have already enjoyed a strong year, but I've been looking at whether investors could see more gains in…

Read more »

Businessman at his desk, looking seriously at information on his digital tablet.
Resources Shares

Which is the better buy, BHP or PLS shares?

I've been comparing two mining giants with plenty of growth ahead. Here's which one I'd rather own.

Read more »

Mining vehicle at a mine site.
Resources Shares

Monadelphous shares are up more than 20% in two days. Are they still a good buy?

The company's first-half numbers are looking good.

Read more »