The BIG problem with ASX ethical investing

Ethical investing on the ASX is all the rage in 2020, but how much difference does it really make to the world?

| More on:

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Ethical investing (sometimes called ESG investing) has been one of the biggest growth trends we have seen on the share market over the past few years. Whether it's exchange-traded fund (ETF) products coming to market, or companies like Australian Ethical Investment Limited (ASX: AEF) offering 'ethical' superannuation products, you can't get far these days without coming across an investment product branding itself as 'ethical'.

It's clearly a growing trend too. That's probably why the Australian Ethical Investment share price is up 700% over the past 5 years. The company did grow funds under management by 19% in FY20 alone, so we can see this trend quantified here.

Ethical investing sounds nice and warm and fuzzy on the surface. 'Invest with your values' is one catchline you might hear, or else 'make a difference with your money'. All sounds great, right?

Take an ETF from BetaShares – the BetaShares Global Sustainability Leaders ETF (ASX: ETHI). This ETF promises to deliver a "portfolio of large global companies that meet strict sustainability and ethical standards". That sounds nice.

Well, it's not as nice as you might think. And I'll explain why I think ethical investing is a trend that's built on something of a farce.

The big problem with ethical investing

The problem with ethical investing lies in this one premise – shares are traded on a secondary, not a primary market. What does this mean? Well, it describes the nature of what happens when you buy shares. Contrary to what many 'ethical investors' might think, you do not support a company when you buy its shares. You're not giving money to the company, you are buying the shares off of someone else, another investor who receives the cash when you buy.

It's the same concept as buying a used car. You're not 'supporting Toyota' when you buy your neighbour's old Camry off of them. Toyota doesn't even get a cut. It's the same with Toyota shares or the shares of any other company.

So the idea that you're 'supporting fossil fuel companies' by owning their shares makes no sense. Whether you or anyone else owns the shares makes no real difference to the world, or to the world's demand for fossil fuels (the real thing supporting fossil fuel companies). All you're doing is cutting yourself out of the profits of these companies by cutting someone else in.

Now if you can't stomach the idea of receiving these profits, then fine, choose an ethical ETF or some other ethically-branded investment product. But don't think you're making a difference either way. The only thing that actually influences how much money a company makes is if and how it sells its products. Not who's entitled to those profits.

Foolish takeaway

I know ethical investing sounds great on paper, but in reality, you're usually being charged higher fees for an ethical portfolio that won't make an iota of difference to the world we're living in. This might help you sleep at night (and if that's the case, go for it). But don't make the mistake of thinking the higher fees you are paying are contributing to anything other than your funds' bottom line.

Sebastian Bowen has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. owns shares of Australian Ethical Investment Ltd. The Motley Fool Australia has recommended Australian Ethical Investment Ltd. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on How to invest

A couple sits in their lounge room with a large piggy bank on the coffee table. They smile while the male partner feeds some money into the slot while the female partner looks on with an iPad style device in her hands as though they are budgeting.
How to invest

Where to invest $8,000 in April 2024

Here's what sort of returns could be on offer from these ASX shares according to analysts.

Read more »

An ASX dividend investor lies back in a deck chair with his hands behind his head on a quiet and beautiful beach with blue sky and water in the background.
How to invest

Shares vs. property: How to generate $500 passive income per month

We run the numbers.

Read more »

A woman holds a lightbulb in one hand and a wad of cash in the other
How to invest

ASX 200 shares vs term deposits: What $5,000 invested a year ago is worth now

Which has been the superior option for investors?

Read more »

Kid on a skateboard with cardboard wings soars along the road.
How to invest

Shares vs. property: Why cheaper homes and ASX small-cap shares are rising fastest in 2024

We look into the changing trends in shares vs. property.

Read more »

Smiling young parents with their daughter dream of success.
How to invest

2 ASX shares that could help set you up for life

Analysts are saying good things about these buy-rated shares.

Read more »

a man wearing casual clothes fans a selection of Australian banknotes over his chin with an excited, widemouthed expression on his face.
How to invest

$20,000 invested in these ASX 200 shares 10 years ago is worth how much?

Would you be laughing all the way to the bank today or not?

Read more »

Busy freeway and tollway at dusk
How to invest

If inflation rebounds I'll be buying this leading ASX 200 share

Inflation doesn’t impact all ASX 200 shares equally.

Read more »

Businessman working and using Digital Tablet new business project finance investment at coffee cafe.
How to invest

Forget term deposits and listen to Warren Buffett's advice with ASX shares

Are you missing out if you buy term deposits?

Read more »